Making a Murderer Questionnaire - Dissertation project

proudfootz

Well-Known Member
Joined
Dec 1, 2016
Messages
806
Reaction score
735
Took the survey.

I did have a few quibbles about how the thing was presented.

The following is a comment I made in the survey about the 'information left out of the documentary':

"I have looked at some of this 'information left out' previously, and some of it is false, some is misleading, and some is irrelevant.

For example, what someone does to a cat in 1982 is not 'evidence' of a crime supposedly committed in 2005 which does not involve any cats.

Or whether someone has a 'perfect' relationship with their live in girlfriend is not evidence of involvement of a murder of a business acquaintance.

There is no evidence Teresa ever asked her employers that she not be asked to return to Avery Salvage Yard.

Some of this 'information' comes from the prosecutor, Ken Kratz, whose honesty is questionable."
 

TTF14

Spaceship Headlight Pattern Expert
Joined
Jan 3, 2014
Messages
13,067
Reaction score
55,187
I completed the survey, but I would say that based on the evidence presented, I would not have been a jury member that would have voted guilty, I don't think. I really don't know if he's guilty or innocent, but I still think the verdict was wrong based on lack of evidence that was presented.
 

BigCityAccountant

Well-Known Member
Joined
Nov 21, 2015
Messages
3,435
Reaction score
214
Took the survey.

I did have a few quibbles about how the thing was presented.

The following is a comment I made in the survey about the 'information left out of the documentary':

"I have looked at some of this 'information left out' previously, and some of it is false, some is misleading, and some is irrelevant.

For example, what someone does to a cat in 1982 is not 'evidence' of a crime supposedly committed in 2005 which does not involve any cats.

Or whether someone has a 'perfect' relationship with their live in girlfriend is not evidence of involvement of a murder of a business acquaintance.

There is no evidence Teresa ever asked her employers that she not be asked to return to Avery Salvage Yard.

Some of this 'information' comes from the prosecutor, Ken Kratz, whose honesty is questionable."
.
I didn't take the survey for the reasons you mentioned above. Sorry. If you asked me how I felt about the documentary and IF I felt there were things left out of the documentary then I would have taken it. I don't think mentioning the things left out of MaM was necessary.
 

proudfootz

Well-Known Member
Joined
Dec 1, 2016
Messages
806
Reaction score
735
I forgot to mention a couple of other things that struck me about the poll:

There are some options listed for 'when did you make up you mind about Steven Avery' listing various points in the documentary and finally 'upon completion of the series'. I think there should be a couple of more options, one of which would be some time after watching the series, and the other being 'I haven't made up my mind about Steven Avery'.

I didn't make up my mind about Steven until some time after doing further reading and research on the case, and the way the poll is worded makes it seem as though the documentary must be what persuades someone one way or the other. And there does seem to be quite a few people who have not made a judgement about Steven's involvement even after watching the documentary and doing additional research.

BigCityAccountant - I agree it was unnecessary to make a list of 'things left out' because it is KK's list of claims and seems to show an implicit bias toward the narrative that MaM is the sole reason many people think Steven is innocent, that Steven's guilt or innocence was the whole point of the documentary, and that KK's list are the only or most important things 'left out'.
 

BigCityAccountant

Well-Known Member
Joined
Nov 21, 2015
Messages
3,435
Reaction score
214
I forgot to mention a couple of other things that struck me about the poll:

There are some options listed for 'when did you make up you mind about Steven Avery' listing various points in the documentary and finally 'upon completion of the series'. I think there should be a couple of more options, one of which would be some time after watching the series, and the other being 'I haven't made up my mind about Steven Avery'.

I didn't make up my mind about Steven until some time after doing further reading and research on the case, and the way the poll is worded makes it seem as though the documentary must be what persuades someone one way or the other. And there does seem to be quite a few people who have not made a judgement about Steven's involvement even after watching the documentary and doing additional research.

BigCityAccountant - I agree it was unnecessary to make a list of 'things left out' because it is KK's list of claims and seems to show an implicit bias toward the narrative that MaM is the sole reason many people think Steven is innocent, that Steven's guilt or innocence was the whole point of the documentary, and that KK's list are the only or most important things 'left out'.
.
Agreed Proudfootz.
I began with Avery and Dassey being guilty. However, having read everything I can on case, I began to have doubts. Those doubts were not propelled by the documentary, but by reading the case files. I believe I had made up my mind that Dassey was innocent before I even watched the documentary. To this day, I cannot say for certain that SA is not guilty, however I tend to believe he is. I watched the documentary 8 months after studying the case. It had little to no impact on my beliefs.
 

columboknows

New Member
Joined
Nov 4, 2015
Messages
10
Reaction score
0
A dissertation for what university and who is your dissertation chair?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Safeguard

On Time Out
Joined
Feb 2, 2015
Messages
2,289
Reaction score
5,682
I didn't take the survey either. I read through and got as far as, "Avery’s sweat was found under Halbach’s car hood, although no fingerprints were analysed."

I can see where this is going. No thanks.
 

missy1974

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 19, 2008
Messages
10,142
Reaction score
31,354
I didn't take the survey either. I read through and got as far as, "Avery’s sweat was found under Halbach’s car hood, although no fingerprints were analysed."

I can see where this is going. No thanks.

Yep, the "sweat" stopped me too.
 

Ver37

New Member
Joined
Aug 27, 2022
Messages
1
Reaction score
0
Sounds very interesting, I would like to read at least an excerpt
 
Top