MO MO - Package Killer SK Gary Muehlberg murdered Robyn Mihan, Sandy Little *Guilty*, Brenda Jean Pruitt in 1990

owsley

Former Member
Joined
May 12, 2019
Messages
840
Reaction score
712
Riverfront Times longread
A Serial Killer Murdered 3 Women in
1990 in St. Louis. He’s Never Been Caught

On a cool October morning in 1990, a man jogging along Basston Drive in Maryland Heights noticed an odor so foul it warranted alerting the two municipal workers cutting weeds nearby. The workers tracked the odor to a 35-gallon plastic trash bin sitting out of place in the grass between Basston and Page Avenue. The bin had no lid and was instead covered in trash bags secured with wire. The municipal workers attempted to load the bin into their truck only to find it was exceptionally heavy.
..
The media and the police quickly connected the Maryland Heights Jane Doe to the case of Robyn J. Mihan, an eighteen-year-old whose body had been found six months prior. Mihan's body had been discovered bound between two mattresses in Silex, Missouri. Both women had been discarded on the side of highways — Jane Doe 20 miles west of the city, Mihan about 60 miles northwest. Both had shirts pulled tight around their faces and their hands tied together. Traces of dog hair had been found on both bodies as well.

Four months after Jane Doe's discovery, a security guard in O'Fallon, Missouri, found a third body — also a woman. She was in a homemade wooden box and was also badly decomposed.

..
Between March 1990 and February 1991, one man abducted at least three women from the same area in south city, raped, mutilated and murdered them before leaving their bodies along highways outside of town. Because he discarded all the bodies in some sort of receptacle — a trash bin, a pair of mattresses, a homemade wooden box — the few people familiar with the murders refer to him as the package killer.
.....
great long article at link

 
Last edited:
I lived in Clayton, MO during that time period and I don’t remember ever hearing about these murders! Of course I was in high school and didn’t really watch the news ( still don’t) how sad for these women and their families that the killer has never been caught
 

Convicted murderer Gary Muehlberg has been charged with the murders of Robyn Mihan, Brenda Pruitt, Donna Reitmeyer and Sandy Little.
 
SEpt 20 2022

1663673845220.png
''Prosecutors talk to Muehlberg after DNA tied him to one of the murders Lohmar said, and agreed to abolish the death penalty if he cooperated.

No objective has been set.

In August, Muhlberg sent a letter to Weber expressing remorse for his heinous actions, calling it a “negative, dark, short period in my past life”.

“I must live with my past—the good and the bad parts. Not going on anymore,” he wrote, according to the St. Louis Post-Dispatch.

The newspaper reported that he has confessed to another murder, but has not yet been charged as police continue to investigate the case.''
 
The families of Brenda Pruitt, Sandra Little, Robyn Mihan and Donna Reitmeyer now know the identity of an alleged serial killer who put their bodies inside various containers and packages more than 30 years ago — and police are hoping to add the family of a yet-to-be-identified woman to that list.

Prosecutors from St. Louis County, St. Charles County and Lincoln County announced Monday Gary Muehlberg, 73, has been charged with four counts of first-degree murder for the homicides of four women who were working as prostitutes when they were killed. Muelberg confessed to killing them between 1990 and 1991 after picking them up along Cherokee Street in St. Louis.
 
Oct 19 2022
By Ryan Krull Oct 19, 2022 rbbm.

''As the prosecution against the alleged serial murderer progresses, Weber is asking for the public's help identifying that fifth victim, about whose identity Muehlberg seems to have only retained the most threadbare of clues.

According to Weber, Muehlberg has said the unidentified woman was white, with shoulder-length, dark brown hair.

Weber says that Muehlberg remembers picking up one of the women he killed from the Wedge bar at corner of Bates and Virginia in the Carondelet neighborhood''

"He was in the bar that night," she says, adding that if anyone knows anything about a woman last seen there to please contact law enforcement.


Weber says that Muehlberg dumped the unidentified victim's body last of all the women he killed, meaning that it would have been after February 1991. He doesn't remember when he abducted the woman, but he thinks he held onto her body for the longest, maybe even for years.

Weber says that puts the approximate time of this woman's abduction anywhere between 1989 and 1991.


There are also some discrepancies surrounding where Muehlberg left the unidentified victim's body.''

''Muehlberg says he left her body in a metal barrel at the Ram Jet self-service car wash on Natural Bridge Avenue in Berkeley during winter.''

However, the son of the car wash's owner — as well as a Pagedale municipal employee — say that they remember a woman's body being found at a different Ram Jet on Pennsylvania Avenue.

"Muehlberg says it was at one car wash. And we have two people that say, 'No, there was a body dumped at a different car wash.' He's adamant that it was that specific car wash on Natural Bridge," Weber says.

She says it's entirely possibly that there were bodies discovered at both car washes.

"We need the public’s help," Weber says. "If anyone knows about a body being disposed of at a car wash in the St. Louis area, please call us. Any of the past investigators should know something."

Muehlberg has told Weber he's talking to someone in prison to help recover memories. But prison officials say there's no one like that on staff.''
 
March 7, 2023

ST. CHARLES — A man suspected in at least five St. Louis area serial killings pleaded guilty Monday to the murder of 21-year-old Sandy Little.
Gary Muehlberg, 73, was sentenced to life in prison Monday for first-degree murder in Little's 1990 strangling.

 

Attachments

  • 1678227701671.png
    1678227701671.png
    73 bytes · Views: 0
By Stephanie Usery
Mar. 21, 2023 rbbm.
1679418599923.png
''T. LOUIS COUNTY (KMOV) – The so-called ‘Package Killer’ has pleaded guilty to two more murders.

Gary Muehlberg was already serving a life sentence for the 1993 murder of Kenneth Atchison when DNA linked him to at least four additional murders. While speaking to investigators last year, Muehlberg reportedly confessed to the murders of the four women.


In September 2022, St. Louis County Prosecutor Wesley Bell charged Muehlberg, 73, in connection with the deaths of Robyn Mihan, 18, Sandy Little, 21, Brenda Jean Pruitt, 27, and Donna Reitmeyer, 40.

''On Tuesday, he pleaded guilty to killing Pruitt and Reitmeyer.''
A hearing is scheduled for later this month in Mihan’s murder.''
 
Pruitt was 27 when her family reported her missing on May 9, 1990. Her body was found in October 1991 inside a plastic trash can on the side of a busy road in St. Louis County. Authorities said she had been smothered or strangled.
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
175
Guests online
3,097
Total visitors
3,272

Forum statistics

Threads
592,171
Messages
17,964,587
Members
228,712
Latest member
Lover305
Back
Top