Hi -- newbie here. What a great website! Here's what I'm thinking: Kibby allowed her to leave. If not, he would have freaked out upon finding her missing (tracked her down, left town, etc). If he didn't allow it, her return home wouldn't have been so calm-seeming. So she must have promised him that she would mislead authorities about what happened, including giving the wrong description. I think police purposely released the wrong description as a sign to Kibby that she was keeping her promise, and to keep him unsuspecting of arrest. Whatever happened, it's really sickening. I haven't seen any mention of his parents in any articles -- who raised this monster?