OH OH - Janice, 21, & Brandon Beidleman, 18 mos, Columbus, 13 Sept 1981

nerosleuth

Well-Known Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2009
Messages
1,488
Reaction score
1,160
On the evening of Sunday September 13, 1981, twenty one year old Janice Beidleman and her 18 moth old son Brandon Beidleman were last seen leaving the home of a relative in the area of Myrtle Avenue and Marcia Drive on the north side of Columbus. They had been visiting relatives that day.

Before leaving her relative’s home, Janice Beidleman told several of her relatives that she was going to stop at a grocery store on the way home to her residence on Beechwold Drive.

She was last seen driving away from her relative's home in her 1974 Chevrolet Vega with her son Brandon in the back seat.

After Janice Beidleman and her son failed to return home that evening, her husband contacted police to report that his wife and son were missing.

On the afternoon of Monday September 14, 1981, Columbus Police were checking out a report of an abandoned vehicle on a service road under the Agler Road bridge just west of Sunbury Road. The service road was on the grounds of the Bridgeview Golf course and also next to Alum Creek.

The abandoned vehicle was Janice Beidleman’s 1974 Chevy Vega.

While searching the area under the Agler Road bridge, police found the body of Janice Beidleman and Brandon Beidleman floating in Alum Creek.

Janice Beidleman had been beaten and strangled. Brandon Beidleman had been suffocated.

Residents living on Clubhouse Drive reported that they heard a woman screaming and a baby crying coming from the area of Putter Avenue during the evening of Sunday September 13, 1981. Due to the shrub line that separated the two housing developments in that neighborhood, they could not see anything from the area of Putter Avenue.

Jewelry and other items that belonged to Janice Beidleman were found on Putter Avenue. Detectives speculate that after Janice Beidleman left her relative’s home, she was kidnapped somewhere and taken to Putter Avenue where she was beaten and killed. Her killer then drove her car less than a quarter mile away to the location under the Agler Road bridge and dumped the bodies of Janice Beidleman and Brandon Beidleman into Alum Creek.

No arrests have been made and the murder of twenty one year old Janice Beidleman and her 18 month old son Brandon Beidleman remains unsolved to this day.


Sources:

Cold Case Detectives Hope To Solve 28 Year Old Murder


http://www.10tv.com/content/stories/2009/11/25/story-columbus-beidleman-murder.html

Note: Above Link have photos of crime scene.



Janice And Brandon Beidleman


http://www.10tv.com/content/stories/2011/04/28/story-unsolved-crime-janice-brandon-beidleman.html



Grandview Heights Cold Case Files Janice And Brandon Beidleman


https://m.facebook.com/GrandviewHei...4.1073741830.270999736367248/475247585942461/
 
In November 1980, there was a murder in the Columbus area involving a young mother and her nephew.

Lynn Vest and her nephew Jeremy Pickens were found dead on the east side of Columbus in November 1980.

The murders of Lynn Vest and her nephew Jeremy Pickens occurred ten months before the September 1981 murders of Janice Beidleman and her son Brandon Beidleman.

I don’t know if the murders of Janice Beidleman and Brandon Beidleman and the murders of Lynn Vest and Jeremy Pickens were committed by the same murderer or by a different murderer, but there are a few similarities between those two unsolved murders from the early 1980’s in the Columbus area.

I created a Websleuth thread for Lynn Vest and Jeremy Pickens who were found murdered on the east side of Columbus in November 1980.



http://www.websleuths.com/forums/sh...-23-Jeremy-Pickens-2-%BD-Columbus-Ohio-12-Nov
 
This is from the Lynn Vest Jeremy Pickens thread on Websleuths:


http://www.websleuths.com/forums/sh...-23-Jeremy-Pickens-2-%BD-Columbus-Ohio-12-Nov


The similarities are startling:

Married women

Travelling alone in a car with a child

Children both male, close in age

Husbands reported them missing

Both boys suffocated

Both women strangled

In this case, the detective believes the killer was a person known to Lynn and Jeremy. So perhaps it is a coincidence. I haven't read all of the articles yet. Maybe I'll change my mind, but right now, I have doubts.

There are other similarities:


Both married women were close in age

Both women and child were last seen leaving home by a family member

Both women and child had errands that they had to take care of



And there are other differences:


Lynn Vest and Jeremy Pickens were white

Janice Beidleman and Brandon Beidleman were black

Lynn Vest drove a 1979 Ford Mustang Cobra hatchback

Janice Beidleman drove a 1974 Chevrolet Vega
 
I recently visited the public library at looked at Columbus newspaper articles on microfilm from the early 1980’s about the homicides of Janice Beidleman and Brandon Beidleman.

Here’s what the Columbus newspaper articles reported during the early 1980’s about the homicides of Janice Beidleman and Brandon Beidleman.


Columbus Citizen Journal Tuesday September 15, 1981

Mother, Son Missing Since Sunday Night Found Slain In Creek

The bodies of a 21 year old Columbus woman and her 20 month old son, both missing since Sunday night, were found Monday afternoon in Alum Creek, near Agler and Sunbury Roads.

Janice Beidleman was found lying on her back in about one foot of water and her son Brandon Beidleman was found face up about 50 yards downstream under the bridge on Agler Road.

The coroner said that Janice Beidleman was unclothed and apparently had been raped and slain near where the body had been found. Her clothes were strewn about on the creek bank between her body and the car she had been driving. Her body was about 50 feet from the car, an orange and white Chevrolet Vega that was registered to her husband.

The coroner speculated that the boy had been slain in the same spot as his mother, and then floated downstream. The youngster was clad in a white diaper and tennis shoes.

The coroner said that the cause of death had not been determined of either victim and it had not been known how long the victims had been dead.

A neighborhood resident discovered Mrs. Beidleman’s body about 1:20 p.m. and called authorities. The resident said that he had seen the Vega drive down the wooded ravine toward the creek late Sunday night.

Police said that they found no possible murder weapons and did not have a motive or suspects in connection with the apparent homicides.

Mrs. Beidleman’s husband rushed to the crime scene about 4 p.m. after he heard a radio news report about the discovery of a woman and child in the creek. The husband talked with a sheriff’s deputy at the scene and it was confirmed that his wife was found slain. Minutes later, more than 20 relatives of the Beidlemans’ began arriving after having heard news reports about the two bodies.

Relatives said that Janice Beidleman was running errands Sunday night when she disappeared. After leaving a relative’s house around 9:20 p.m., Janice Beidleman had planned to stop at a grocery store before going home.

The husband was recently laid off from a local automotive factory where he worked as a quality control inspector. Janice Beidleman had previously worked at a local hospital and was a full time homemaker and mother at the time of her death.

After a jurisdictional question regarding the crime scene location, Columbus Police homicide detectives took over the investigation.

A Columbus Police homicide detective told a reporter that the slaying was similar to the November 12, 1980 murders of Lynn Vest and Jeremy Pickens.


Columbus Dispatch Tuesday September 15, 1981

Mom Strangled; Baby Suffocated With Pillow

A young mother was beaten on the head, apparently raped and strangled before her nude body and that of her 20 month old son were dumped in Alum Creek.

Janice Beidleman, 21, and the diaper clad body of her son Brandon Beidleman, were found about 1:20 p.m. Monday afternoon in a foot of water in the creek which runs along Bridgeview Golf Course.

The murder victims lived a little more than two miles from where their bodies were found in the area west of Sunbury Road and just north of Agler Road on the city’s northeast side.

The county coroner said that Janice Beidleman had several bruises from blows on the head and lacerations and scratches indicating she had been raped. The victim also had bruise marks on her neck and died of strangulation. The coroner also said that her son had died of suffocation.

Detectives speculated that the woman had been beaten by a man’s fist and that her son was suffocated with a pillow that was found near the creek. Detectives also speculated that at least two people who may have known the victims killed the woman and her child.

Detectives were investigating the possibility that the attacker or attackers killed the woman elsewhere and then dumped her body in the creek. No blood was found in the car, which was 50 yards from the water’s edge.

The mother and her son had been missing since 11:30 p.m. Sunday night after she left her mother’s home for the five mile trip to her home where she lived with her husband.

The husband told a reporter at the roped off crime scene area where the bodies were found that when he reported his wife and son missing to Columbus Police at 6:30 a.m. Monday morning, he was told that he had to wait 24 hours before he could file a missing persons report.

An eyewitness who lived on Sunbury Road told a reporter that he noticed a car that was similar to the victim’s car that did not have its headlights on drive down a gravel road that runs off of Sunbury Road at about 10:45 p.m. Sunday evening. The eyewitness said that the gravel road was often used by fishermen to reach Alum Creek.

The eyewitness noticed the car was near the creek around 12:30 p.m. Monday and went to investigate. The eyewitness said that the driver’s door was open and 10 to 15 bobby pins were on top of the car roof. The eyewitness also said that there was a man’s foot print on the ground on the passenger side of the car.

The eyewitness found the body of Janice Beidleman lying face up in the water. After the eyewitness summoned authorities about the grisly discovery, Franklin County Sheriff deputies found the boy’s body on the west side of the creek underneath the Agler Road Bridge.

The area where the bodies were found was on the edge of the Mifflin Township and Columbus city limits line. The bodies were found 50 yards from each other and it was determined that the bodies were found inside the Columbus city limits.

Relatives said that Janice Beidleman and her son Brandon Beidleman arrived at her mother-in-law homes about 8:00 p.m. Sunday evening.

After dinner Janice Beidleman took her aunt back to her home to pick up her 14 year old brother at her aunt’s home. Janice Beidleman called her husband from her aunt’s house telling him that she and her son were heading home after she dropped her 14 year old brother off at her mother’s home. Janice Beidleman visited briefly with her mother and told her mother that she might stop at a grocery store at the Northern Lights Shopping Center.


Columbus Dispatch Wednesday September 16, 1981

Screams Heard Half Mile From Location Of Bodies

A mother and her 20 month old son who were found dead Monday in Alum Creek may have been beaten or killed on a barricaded road about half a mile away.

Residents near the Bridgeview Hills subdivision, about half a mile west of Sunbury Road and south of Agler Road say they heard a woman screaming, a baby crying and a man’s muffled voice on a barricaded road at the south end of the subdivision about 11 p.m. Sunday.

Residents said that Putter Avenue, located between Wedge Street and Clubhouse Drive, had been barricaded for about two years to prevent people from dumping garbage in the uninhabited section of the subdivision.

A resident living on Wedge Street near the barricade reported hearing a woman screaming and a baby crying minutes after hearing a loud thud from a fast moving car going over the curb and around the barricade.

The resident also heard a man’s voice saying “shut up” and “keep him quiet”. A next door neighbor also heard a woman’s voice saying “don’t cry, baby”.

The resident inadvertently called the Mifflin Township Fire Department instead of the police. A paramedic squad arrived at 11:13 p.m., and muffled voices could still be heard when the paramedics arrived. The paramedics told the resident that it was a police matter and radioed Columbus police. A cruiser and a helicopter arrived about 11:20 p.m., searched the area but found nothing.

Another resident who lived on Clubhouse Drive reported seeing headlights of a car shining through some trees behind the barricade. The resident on Clubhouse Drive also heard the screams and crying.

Areas East of Wedge Street are in Columbus and areas west of Wedge Street are in Mifflin Township.

A homicide detective told a reporter that detectives had not been aware of the incident regarding residents hearing having heard a woman screaming and a baby crying. The homicide detective also said that detectives spent Tuesday tracking down tips called into the department and made no headway into the case.


Columbus Dispatch Thursday September 17, 1981

Police Searching Area Of Screams

Prompted by a story in the Columbus Dispatch, homicide detectives late Wednesday began searching a barricaded road in northeast Columbus for clues in the Sunday slayings of a young woman and her infant son.

Residents in and near the Bridgeview Hills subdivision had told The Columbus Dispatch they heard a woman “scream in terror”, a baby crying, and a man’s muffled voice coming from a barricaded road in the south end of the subdivision south of Agler Road. Witnesses at both ends of the barricaded road said they saw a car in the area.

Although neighbors said two police cruisers and a helicopter investigated the incident, detectives were unaware of details of the incident until reading an article in the Columbus Dispatch.

When asked why the uniformed officers hadn’t told detectives about the incident, a detective said that “officers didn’t put two and two together”, adding that “detectives wished that they had heard of that incident before it appeared in the newspaper”.

The detective said that if the double homicide and the incident Sunday night are related, the assailant could have returned to the area and removed evidence.

Detectives met Wednesday with Franklin County Sheriff’s deputies to review the deputies’ reports on the homicide. The sheriff’s department began investigating the killings first on Monday, but turned the investigation over to Columbus Police when it was discovered the area was in the city.


Columbus Dispatch Friday September 18, 1981

Police Think 2 Men Killed Mother, Son

Columbus Police detectives believed that Janice Beidleman and her son were killed by two men half a mile from where their bodies were found on Monday.

Detectives searched the barricaded road on the south end of the Bridgeview Hills subdivision where area residents heard a woman screaming, a baby crying, and a man’s muffled voice late Sunday.

Detectives are convinced that the screams residents heard are those of Janice Beidleman and her son because of the number of persons who heard them at the same time.

There was no evidence of a struggle where the bodies were found and police cannot account for the Beidleman’s whereabouts from 10:30 p.m. Sunday until residents heard the screams about 11:00 p.m. Sunday.

A detective said that there was evidence that Janice Beidleman was raped and sodomized, indicating there were two assailants.

Detectives speculate that Janice Beidleman was probably raped and killed, then taken from the area by her assailants when they heard a police helicopter arrive at the scene about 11:13 p.m. Sunday night.

Detectives believe that the assailants were familiar with the area, noting that the car was driven around a guard rail barricade at the east end of Putter Avenue, and then down an access road off of Sunbury Road, where the bodies were found.

Beidleman and her son left her mother’s house at 10:30 and were going home. They were not seen again until their bodies were found in Alum Creek across from the Bridgeview Golf Club about 1:30 p.m. Monday.



Columbus Dispatch Sunday September 20, 1981

30 Minutes Missing On Deadly Day

The article gave a timeline concerning the whereabouts of Janice Beidleman and her son Brandon Beidleman on Sunday September 13, 1981.

At 11:00 a.m., Janice Beidleman, her son, and her husband get into the family’s Chevrolet Vega as they leave their apartment which is off of Morse Road and Westerville Road. As they make their journey towards the home of her husband’s friend, they notice the gas gauge on the Chevy Vega reads nearly empty.

At 11:20 a.m., the Beidleman family pulls into the Bonded Oil Company service station at East Hudson Street and Joyce Avenue. The Beidlemans only have $10 between them. Janice pays for $3 worth of gas keeping $2 for herself. Her husband gives her another $2 and keeps $3 for himself.

At 11:30 a.m., the Beidleman family arrives at the home of her husband’s friend on Jermain Drive. Janice’s husband and her husband’s friend are members of a motorcycle club. Janice’s husband keeps his motorcycle in the garage at his friend’s home since the Beidlemans doesn’t have a garage where they live at their apartment complex.

At 12:15 p.m., Janice Beidleman and her son leave the house of her husband’s friend. It was the last time that Janice’s husband would see his wife and son alive. Janice’s husband and his friend rode their motorcycles with other friends on that Sunday afternoon. Janice Beidleman and her son return back to their apartment which is off of Morse Road and Westerville Road.

At 4:30 p.m., Janice Beidleman and her son arrive at her aunt’s house on Bonham Avenue to visit her aunt. Janice Beidleman’s 14 year old brother is also at her aunt’s house.

At 6:00 p.m., Janice Beidleman takes her son Brandon and her brother to White Castle to pick up some hamburgers for the group.

At 7:30 p.m., after eating, Janice and her aunt decide to take her son Brandon to visit his grandmother who lived off of Woodland Avenue, about a mile and half away from Janice’s aunt. Her brother stays behind at his aunt’s house.

At 9:30 p.m., Janice, who has taken her aunt back home, receives a telephone call from her husband who is at home at their apartment.

At 10:00 p.m., Janice leaves her aunt’s house after some prodding from her 14 year old brother, who had to attend middle school the next day. Before Janice Beidleman departs from her aunt’s house, Janice write out a shopping list. Janice tells her aunt that she planned on stopping at the Kroger grocery store at the Northern Lights Shopping Center on Cleveland Avenue in Clinton Township.

At 10:15 p.m., after a two mile drive from her aunt’s house, Janice Beidleman arrives at her mother’s house on Marcia Drive to drop her 14 year old brother at her mother’s house. Janice stays at her mother’s house for 15 minutes and tells her mother that she was going to the grocery store before heading back with her son to their apartment.

At 10:30 p.m., Janice’s 14 year old brother carries her infant son to the back seat of her Chevrolet Vega, where there is a pillow on the back seat and placed her son on the pillow. It was the last time that Janice’s mother and brother would see Janice Beidleman and her son Brandon Beidleman alive.

The newspaper article noted that the Marcia Drive home is in a quiet neighborhood of streets that dead end to the north and east. To leave, Janice would have to travel towards Cleveland Avenue.

The newspaper article also noted that if Janice Beidleman did reach the Northern Lights Shopping Center on Cleveland Avenue, she would have found that the Kroger’s grocery store closed. A 24 hour operation all week, the Kroger’s grocery store closes at 10:00 p.m. on Sundays.

At 11:00 p.m., residents of the Bridgeview Hills subdivision off of Agler Road see a car drive around a barricade into an uninhabited area. A woman’s screams and the crying of a baby are heard. It is in this area, less than half a mile from her parents home, that police believe Janice Beidleman and her son Brandon Beidleman is killed.

Police believe that the missing half hour, from 10:30 p.m. to 11:00 p.m., lies the answer to the mystery. Police believe there were two assailants, but they have drawn a blank trying to fill in that time.

Janice Beidleman’s relatives say that Janice, protective of her baby, would not have stopped to pick up a hitchhiker or aid a stranger, but wonders if Janice had stopped for someone she knew or if her car forcibly entered?



Columbus Dispatch Tuesday September 14, 1982

Memory Of Murder: Misery Never Leaves

A year ago today only minutes after hearing that her daughter and grandson failed to return home the previous night, Janice Beidleman’s mother heard a news report on the radio about the body of a young woman and infant had been found in Alum Creek.

She had hoped that she was wrong, but when she arrived at the crime scene, her instincts that the body of a young woman and an infant were proved to be correct that the victims were her daughter and grandson.

Janice Beidleman’s mother is the last person known to see her daughter and grandson alive.

Police speculate that someone got into Janice Beidleman’s car after she left her mother’s home, killed Janice Beidleman and her son Brandon Beidleman, and dumped their bodies in the creek near Sunbury and Agler Roads.

The final moments of Janice’s life, when she was raped, sodomized, beaten, and strangled, are vivid in the memory of Janice Beidleman’s mother.

Janice Beidleman’s mother noted that her daughter was always so afraid of being raped and that her daughter didn’t deserve to die like that, adding that she loved her grandbaby and would never forget him.

No one has ever been arrested for the deaths and police have been unable to account for thee 30 minutes after Janice Beidleman and her son Brandon Beidleman left her mother’s home at 10:30 p.m. on Sunday September 13, 1981.

At 11:00 p.m., screams and a crying baby were heard about half a mile from where the bodies were found. Police feel that the missing minutes hold the key to the murders, but have been unable to account for the time.

A homicide detective told a Dispatch reporter that the Beidleman murders is still an active investigation.

Janice Beidleman’s mother told a reporter that the killers of her daughter and grandson think they got away, but she firmly believes that it will all come out someday.
 
That's sad. Too bad the ear witnesses and the medics wern't more diligent because it would very possibly have saved a life or lives.
 
That's sad. Too bad the ear witnesses and the medics wern't more diligent because it would very possibly have saved a life or lives.

If you had an emergency in Columbus back in 1981 where you needed either the police or fire departments, you had to dial the seven digit phone number as the 911 system did not exist back then. That's why one of the ear witness accidently called the paramedics instead of the police.

It wasn't until the late 1980's that the Columbus area finally had a 911 system for emergencies.

Had the 911 system existed in Columbus back in 1981, police may have responded to the neighborhood a lot earlier, perhaps saving lives and getting a dangerous predator off the streets.
 
I think it's the same perp in both cases. Was Columbus dangerous back then?
 
I think it's the same perp in both cases. Was Columbus dangerous back then?


Columbus didn’t have as many homicides back then as they do now. But looking at the newspaper articles on microfilm would give an impression that the metro Columbus area was dangerous back then.

At the same time when the Beidleman murders occurred, the Columbus newspapers reported an elderly woman had been found sexually assaulted and strangled in her own home. A suspect was later arrested and convicted for that crime.

And a few days before the Beidleman murders, the murder of Robin Durrer was also reported in the Columbus newspapers. The Beidleman and Durrer murders are not related, but there is a Websleuths cold case thread on Robin Durrer.


http://www.websleuths.com/forums/sh...n-Marie-Durrer-19-Reese-Ohio-9-September-1981
 
This is a case that needs to be solved. DNA ? there must have been a rape test kit performed on this young mom. Not only was she brutally killed, but a little toddler as well. Find who did this.
 

On the evening of September 13, 1981, Janice Beidleman and her 18-month old son left the home of a relative in the area of Myrtle Ave. and Marcia Dr. Ms. Beidleman had told several of her relatives that she was going to stop at a grocery store on the way home to her residence on Beechwold Dr. Ms. Beidleman was last seen driving away from her relative’s home in her 1974 Chevrolet Vega with her son Brandon in the back seat. The following afternoon, Janice Beidleman’s car was found beneath the Agler Road Bridge just west of Sunbury Road. Janice Beidleman’s body and Brandon Beidleman’s body were both found floating nearby in Alum Creek. Janice Beidleman had been beaten and strangled. Brandon Beidleman had been suffocated. Anyone with information about this crime is asked to call Crime Stoppers at 461-TIPS (8477) or visit the website at www.stopcrime.org.
 

Attachments

  • 1637233-teaser.aspx[1].jpg
    1637233-teaser.aspx[1].jpg
    20.5 KB · Views: 0
Last edited by a moderator:

Staff online

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
158
Guests online
1,307
Total visitors
1,465

Forum statistics

Threads
587,122
Messages
17,876,135
Members
226,966
Latest member
Ennn
Back
Top