Updated, at 10:54PM
.So many possibilities sightings. So many potential leads. Only to be let down, until now.
Out of the blue one day, Joe got a Facebook message from a young woman who saw Bethanys photo on a missing child poster and realized it looked eerily similar to a photo of herself as a child.
There were also other details that only the real Bethany would know.
"The young lady said, 'I have this birth mark. It's on the left side right above my hairline, Joe said. "This isn't just your run of the mill. This could really be her."
"Very, very striking similarities. Facial similarities, Brewer said.
She also claimed to be adopted and has problems getting employment, because her social security number does not match her birth name.
"We're not saying at this point and time that this is Bethany Tiner, because DNA will prove whether it is or is not, Brewer said.
The young woman is in her early twenties just like Bethany. She also submitted a DNA sample to investigators, and now they are waiting on the results
Authorities say the results of the DNA test could take up to three weeks.