POI: Joseph Brewer #2

margarita25

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 10, 2012
Messages
49,970
Reaction score
196,051
On what basis was Joseph Brewer ruled out as possibly being LISK?
 

EpiVox444

Member
Joined
Jun 23, 2013
Messages
64
Reaction score
77
On what basis was Joseph Brewer ruled out as possibly being LISK?
Don't know, probably only known to the investigators conclusively... but I would hope that they used his voice samples for Melissa's sister and Sara Karnes to listen to, see if they recognized him in any way. Also, it's worth noting that the investigators have never ruled Shannan Gilbert as a LISK victim, even if they changed their minds on whether her death was homicide or accidental.
 

WINDSOR

Well-Known Member
Joined
Dec 20, 2011
Messages
1,457
Reaction score
3,923
On what basis was Joseph Brewer ruled out as possibly being LISK?

The SCPD by not laying any charges, or even designating anybody as a POI have, after many years of investigating, have de facto ruled everybody out. The fact Brewer has taken the Fifth, answering questions under oath, shows Brewer himself believes he has committed crimes, yet the SCPD have laid no charges. It makes no sense to me.
 

DetectiveB

Well-Known Member
Joined
Nov 15, 2012
Messages
154
Reaction score
349
If anyone remembers the self proclaimed escort "Leanne", she herself said she believed she saw Brewer at the sex party in which Burke attended. Brewer has to know Burke.

In addition -If that's the case it's pretty pathetic that these so called human beings attended a party right after SG, GB4 etc were all found dead.
Brewer and Burke are two peas in a pod. And I am sure there are many more just like them. The good ole boys. Again, Burke made NO effort to speak about or any physical attributes in hunting down LISK that I recall.
 

Fletch1234

Member
Joined
Sep 23, 2021
Messages
16
Reaction score
28
Don't know, probably only known to the investigators conclusively... but I would hope that they used his voice samples for Melissa's sister and Sara Karnes to listen to, see if they recognized him in any way. Also, it's worth noting that the investigators have never ruled Shannan Gilbert as a LISK victim, even if they changed their minds on whether her death was homicide or accidental.
Did they ever describe what age the killer sounded like? Sometimes I wonder if one of the sons of oak beach would pick the girls up for those party's. Get them to feel comfortable on multiple dates with a younger guy and they drop their guard. Listened to the podcast again JB certainly tries to single himself out it seems from rest of community for some reason.
 

EpiVox444

Member
Joined
Jun 23, 2013
Messages
64
Reaction score
77
Did they ever describe what age the killer sounded like? Sometimes I wonder if one of the sons of oak beach would pick the girls up for those party's. Get them to feel comfortable on multiple dates with a younger guy and they drop their guard. Listened to the podcast again JB certainly tries to single himself out it seems from rest of community for some reason.
The only thing I remember about their descriptions of his voice-- both said it-- was that it didn't have a strong New York accent, or New England accent. Assuming the same person spoke to Amber and Sara Karnes of course, which isn't set in stone either. So many deep deep rabbit holes with this case.
 
Top