The prisoner's story is certainly plausible. Probably not enough to get a reliable conviction on however. But even if that story isn't totally correct, I bet that something very similar happened. Someone (or more likely more than one person) grabbed Brittanee after she left the hotel. A total crime of opportunity. They took her away to someplace and you can fill in the blanks after that. The total lack of evidence to support the story is preventing this from proceeding. Its horrifying and so very sad that this will likely never be brought to justice.