Just bringing some thoughts over here to this thread, after doing some reading about CPH's father's book (I have not had a chance to read the whole book, yet).
What got me interested in this was a minor discrepancy, but possibly of importance, going back to a court case where CPH goes as PH, MD (defendant) and is connected with the Point Lookout/Lido Beach fire department. Tries to use Good Samaritan law to skirt around not treating a child with proper medical care. And, if I'm correct (please correct me) insinuations of being under the influence. Also read he was a volunteer firefighter.
If CPH is a D.O., why is he called an MD, and that isn't corrected, or brought up as being wrong in the suit, etc. This was in the 1990s, long after he supposedly obtained his degree. I just don't understand it. And why does he go by C.PH, PH, or CPH in different documents(?) Is it a way to muddy the waters and make paper trails more difficult to follow?
I looked into the school where it was said he graduated, and at
this time their degree program is in Arizona. I have no idea if it was in NY back then, but I thought it odd. It's also a fairly prestigious school from what I could see, with a very low acceptance rate. I am not denying his intelligence, just wondering if it was a place, a school that one could "buy their way into."
Back to info on CPH's father. The obit CPH wrote for his dad was apparently/possibly full of fabrications, including that his father couldn't have been a doctor unless his degree information was forged--his highest school grade level completed was 8th grade(?)
If CPH could lie about his father being a doctor, or particulars, what was keeping him from lying about himself or obtaining falsified documents.(?) Usually doctors are affiliated with a hospital, and there is a lot more information on them, their specialties, affiliation with groups of other physicians.
While reading things, I almost felt as if CPH was staying within the realms of working up through emergency services, because maybe he knew someone, or there was less screening than at a traditional hospital? Also, where did he intern? Can't find info about that, either.
Erasing the tapes at Oak Beach/allowing them to be erased proves to me that in my opinion he was worried about incriminating information. His whole pretending to be with Homicide and interviewing people at the gate, is also, one heck of a lie to tell in an attempt to maybe get information and put together what he thought was a plausible story, working around others's statements.
I do think that the wrongful death suit has a lot of merit. And I hope that there's enough evidence.
I also think all the people who met at the gate, as mentioned on the Brewer thread, should have been interviewed, etc. Did that happen? I have no clue.
Also, looking back through Shannan's second autopsy, why the heck was there a hole that appeared to be drilled through her hyoid bone, and larynx missing? Was she not breathing, and someone tried to do a tracheostomy...and didn't know where to do it in the first place?
Shannan Gilbert's Family Attorney Releases Results Of New Autopsy
Just thoughts.