Hi all..
I have been fascinated by this case ever since I saw the Disappeared episode that featured it. I've probably seen just about every episode, but this one in particular has always stuck in my mind. Three adult women, here one minute and gone the next, without anyone (seemingly) knowing what happened in the early hours of that June morning. After watching the Disappeared episode, I looked up the case to see if the hospital parking garage had been dug up, because the way it was left, it seemed quite likely that's what was going to happen. I also think that like many others, I judged Janelle and Mike pretty harshly for their actions. I think in hindsight, it's easy to say we wouldn't have done the same, but this was a different time, and of course, the circumstances are different for everybody. Unfortunately, it's hard to know if any hard, potential evidence was destroyed from the residence that morning and the hours that followed.
I have gone back and forth in my mind many times about this case, but one thing I have asked myself initially was whether the abductor(s) ever actually entered the house at all. The purses being lined up in Suzie's bedroom indicates that perhaps they did, Cinnamon being reportedly locked in the bathroom seems odd, and Sherill's closet was apparently uncharacteristically messy, but that aside, it's hard to know for definite (as with many "facts" in this case). I now tend to believe that he/they did enter the property, but perhaps if there was more than a lone culprit in the abduction, it may have been possible that the house was staged/ransacked after the women were loaded into the vehicle. This theory only seems logical if there was of course more than one person involved. During and following the act, it's pretty likely the dog was barking like crazy, and locking her in the bathroom would of course dull the sounds at the front of the house and avoid waking any neighbors. Then, just another one of many questions, was the porch light broken prior to the abduction or during? I think many believe that this was a potential way to gain entry into the home/distract the women to the front of the house while he/they entered through the back. Another possibility is this was broken during a struggle on the porch. It's the seemingly small things in this case that can be discussed in so much detail, and with differening opinion which makes it so fascinating.
I saw someone mentioned a couple pages back about the history of the house. I read there was a lady in her 60s who owned the property for five years prior to Sherill and Suzie moving in. The small snippet of the News-Leader article I read said she had occasional prowlers at the home. Given the location of the house, right off a main road, and on a quiet residential street, it seems like an ideal target for creeps like that. Something else unsettling about the location of the home is the land off to the right, which has a gravel road leading around the back of the home and a small parking lot for various establishments. I'm not sure if this has altered much from 1992, but even then, it would seemingly leave the property quite exposed and accessible from that side by jumping the fence.
I realize I've kind of gone on and on here without really giving a solid theory, but I find myself questioning a lot about what happened in this case, as I'm sure many others do. It comes into my mind every now and then, and I can only imagine how hard it must be for everyone close to the women. As unlikely as it seems, I hope it is resolved once and for all. It isn't even comprehendible how terrifying the situation was, especially after a day of celebration and reflecting on future plans. I hope to join in many further conversations about the case - thanks for reading!