If there was a struggle between PR and JBR that night, resulting in a head injury, PR would have realized immediately that her daughter needed to be taken to the ER. Even if she died on the way to the hospital, PR still would have taken her inside to try to save her life. I believe that something else happened that night, where PR did something weird to JBR, perhaps an innocent punishment type thing, only to find her dead a few minutes later. I was thinking about the garrot. Suppose PR tied a garrot around JBR's neck, in a way that it kept her from moving, say from off the toilet? JBR could have struggled to free herself, unknowingly strangling herself like a dog that jumps over a fence while tied to his leash. Does anyone remember reading a time when PR put a dog's leash around JBR's neck after she had wet the bed? I thought the housekeeper talked about it happening, but I can't find it anywhere in a book or on the internet.