- Apr 22, 2008
- Reaction score
Agree. This is what I've been saying, too. I think there's a chance JR got sucked into the vortex and became an accessory to the cover-up through the course of the morning. He probably recognized PR's handwriting on some level, but didn't want to believe his eyes, then started piecing things together as he distanced himself from PR and others that morning. I also believe it's possible that he might have first found the body during that unaccounted for 80 minutes - at around 11:00, as he mentioned to MR's boyfriend, but that he didn't want to be the one who found her alone, and that's why he took FW with him later when Det Arndt asked him to search the house for anything out of place. JMO.. a theory in progress, so to speak.John is the one element I have never been able to fit neatly into any theory. I don't believe he ever molested his daughter. I don't believe he killed his daughter. I don't believe he took part in the staging of the body. But I am fairly confident that he knew the body was in the wine cellar prior to "discovering" her on the trip to the basement with FW. I'm leaning toward his finding the body on his first trip down to the basement. But honestly...I just can't make any logical, concrete connections where John is concerned.