I'm sure the veterans here have at one time or another said where they think JB was killed and when but I kind of wanted to see all of those theories under one thread. When do you think she was killed? Why do you think that? Where do you think she was killed? Why do you think that? I think she was killed after 11pm but before 1am. There's no specific reason for my theory except opinion. It had been a long day and I'm sure everyone went to bed soon after getting home that night. The molester would have to wait for everyone to be asleep for the maximum privacy, which makes me think midnight-ish. I don't know what to think of the neighbor who heard the scream. It doesn't fit any theory of her death that I have. I think she was killed in or near her room. Mostly because the bigger amount of proof suggests that as the center of activity. Again, not a firm opinion...just an opinion.