rashomon said:
UKGuy,
Sorry for not having been clear enough - I just saw I left out a crucial element in my post. It should have read:
I think JonBenet was put in the wine cellar by John before the police and the Whites arrived, and when John stood at the threshold to that dark room with Fleet, he could not 'see' JB either, but knowing she was in that room (because he himself had put her there), made it appear to FW as if he had just 'detected' the body ("Oh my God!").
While I think it possible that John moved JB to her 'final place' in the wine cellar from another basement room, I don't think he would have dared to do that with the detectives already in the house. I believe he moved her there before the police arrived.
Do you know in which basement room Patsy's paint tray was kept?
rashomon,
No problem thats clearer.
I'm not certain there was a designated place for the piant-tote and easel etc, possibly wherever Patsy decided to leave it.
LHP in PMPT Lawrence Schiller pp. 198-202
Patsy started taking a painting class, and JonBenet drew a lot with crayons and MARKERS. People and flowers. They had a big easel, but most of the time JonBenet painted on a card table in the butler's kitchen. Patsy had her paints and brushes in a white paint tote. Sometimes she asked me to take her paints down to the basement. "I don't want to see it." On the day of the Ramseys' Christmas party, I took the paint tote downstairs.
Downstairs may simply be the hallway leading to the wine-cellar, or simply after you go through basement entrance door, anywhere convenient, since there is a lot of space till you reach the other doors.
A lot of people conflate the paint-tote and the wine-cellar, or use the word 'room' for its location down in the 'basement'.
There are a lot of points that can be raised wrt the paint-tote and JonBenet being discovered in the wine-cellar.
Personally I would discount John moving the body there
prior to the 911 call, since the crime-scene staging was incomplete, JonBenet had not been redressed in her Barbie Nightgown and her white-gap top removed to her bedroom. Something that would only take minutes to do, and there would be no reason not make certain that this was done before making the 911-call.
I do not think she was killed in the wine-cellar either, the abrasions and contusions on her torso, were enveloped in the white blanket.
The upper part of her body, not wrapped, was the focus of the wine-cellar staging. Although the latter is speculation, I've made it, so to suggest her wrapped torso, was the focus of a prior staging.
JonBenet may have been killed in the basement, but the wine-cellar seems to offer no utility to a perpetrator, particularly when it comes to enacting a staging.
.