The most difficult time through all the hearings, motions and trial, the family said, was the 2½ days the Logsdon jury deliberated. “It was brutal,” Marc said...
Months later, when visiting a citywide garage sale in Buhler, a woman approached them on Main Street and asked how they were. “I said ‘fine,’” Marc said. “Then she asked if I remembered her. Once she said that, I knew she was one of the jurors.”
Juror No. 6 told the Timmermeyers she’d hoped she’d run into them someday, to explain why deliberations took so long. “They all agreed as soon as they went in (to deliberations) he was guilty, but they wanted to not give the defense anything that might overturn it. They wanted to go through each piece of evidence.” That meant re-watching hours of videotaped interviews, and reviewing more than 200 exhibits. Logsdon is serving 73 years in prison.