Okay...now a coherent moment (had a soft drink...yeah...I know...bad...but my chemo round is almost over...only one more visit after this week)...soft drinks pep me up--hence, more sense (and sad rhyming).
1. GA is the last known person to see KC with a live Caylee.
2. GA is the first person (since KC abandoned the car) to see inside (along with the manager of the Wrecker place).
3. GA is the first person to be inside the car and drive it since KC abandoned it. He drove the car home, alone, to the A residence.
4. GA is the only member of the A family to have seen KC during the period of time between June 16th and July 15th before CA tracked her down with AH's help. The alleged effin gas can incident and a car chase (a date he cannot remember) in which he chased KC on the toll road staying behind her in his words at a safe 100 yard distance until he lost her.
He is all over some of the most important dates/piece of evidence in the case.
I started thinking about him because what if he isn't the "aw shucks, just trying to help, I love my daughter, don't mind my wife cuz I can't help it" kind of guy.
5. He is the only person to make a suicide attempt (after the remains were found) in which LE was brought in to assist in finding him.
6. In September, it was KC who sent a private note to LE requesting if they, LE, could bring GA to jail (not CA or LA) to speak with her.
I have a few more but the more I think about it in the barest forms...things are not adding up to GA being completely clueless and just being pushed around by CA.
Yours is the only theory I find plausible in any way. I am not totally there yet, but I am starting to lean. Kronk has always not set right with me, and this would explain a lot. This has been a case of coincidences and eerie similarities, but some things stretch belief a bit. It would certainly explain his confliction. He looks absolutely tormented to me these days. What a position to find himself in if it's true. I can't even imagine. It's understandable on some levels if he did cross the line. It would only be triage, save who's left to save. Casey. Because he saw that poor Caylee was already gone.
The 2.5 day decomp, though. Wouldn't that blow LE's timeline? Because that would mean for him to find the body in July that a more advanced state of decomp would have been present? Either in lieu of or in addition to the 2.5 day evidence? And if she waited that long, forgive me but this is gross, wouldn't there have been a much larger stain, because at that point, there would mainly be liquid. If I could get past this, I could accept your theory.