GUILTY PA - Joy Hibbs, 36, Bristol Township, 19 April 1991

26RDJTQYQBABXEGHC4FLYE66EU.jpg

March 15, 2022
Cold Case: Widower's Last-Ditch Effort Using Life’s Savings, Hopes to Solve His Wife's Murder (montco.today)
''April 19, 1991, was typical for Croydon wife and mother Joy Hibbs: She ran errands, returned home, and prepared for her evening work shift as a medical assistant. She never made it, reports Vinny Vella for The Philadelphia Inquirer.

According to police reports, someone strangled and stabbed Joy Hibbs to death that afternoon. The perpetrator then covered his or her tracks with a devastating fire. ''

''Charlie Hibbs announced his $25,000 reward and now waits to see if it coaxes any information on Joy Hibbs’ cold case.

“I owe this much to Joy,” he said. “I don’t have closure. And I think if I had closure, I’d be able to move on.”

Anyone with information in this case is urged to call the Bucks County Detective Unit at 215.348.6354. ''
 
26RDJTQYQBABXEGHC4FLYE66EU.jpg

March 15, 2022
Cold Case: Widower's Last-Ditch Effort Using Life’s Savings, Hopes to Solve His Wife's Murder (montco.today)
''April 19, 1991, was typical for Croydon wife and mother Joy Hibbs: She ran errands, returned home, and prepared for her evening work shift as a medical assistant. She never made it, reports Vinny Vella for The Philadelphia Inquirer.

According to police reports, someone strangled and stabbed Joy Hibbs to death that afternoon. The perpetrator then covered his or her tracks with a devastating fire. ''

''Charlie Hibbs announced his $25,000 reward and now waits to see if it coaxes any information on Joy Hibbs’ cold case.

“I owe this much to Joy,” he said. “I don’t have closure. And I think if I had closure, I’d be able to move on.”

Anyone with information in this case is urged to call the Bucks County Detective Unit at 215.348.6354. ''

:(
 
Dec. 6, 2017 Lengthy, bbm.
Pennsylvania Mom's Brutal Murder An Enduring Mystery | HuffPost Latest News
5ba2c8d43c00005b000af8d5.jpeg


''When David Hibbs exited the school bus on April 19, 1991, he was anxious to find his mom. It was a sunny Friday afternoon in Bristol Township, Pa. -- more importantly, it was report card day -- and the 12-year-old boy had just made the honor roll. Unfortunately, that happy moment in time proved to be short-lived. When the boy approached his house, a horror unlike any other he had ever experienced began to unfold before his eyes.''

''Firefighters were soon on the scene and a paramedic placed a still-hysterical David Hibbs in the back of an ambulance.''

''Firefighters found the body of 36-year-old Joy Hibbs in her son's bedroom.
According to retired Bristol Township Detective Lt. Richard Bilson, the scene inside the bedroom was horrific.
"She was lying face-up on a mattress that was nothing but springs," Bilson told HuffPost. "Her body was black -- completely burnt beyond recognition. She looked like a mummy and the entire room was charred."

"The coroner advised us she died before the fire started," Bilson said. "He located five stab wounds, to her neck and chest, and there was a computer cord wrapped around her neck. At that point, it became a homicide investigation."

Unfortunately, there were few clues to be found in the home. The fire had gutted much of the interior and anything that wasn't scorched was watered down or unwittingly trampled upon by firefighters.

"There was nothing we could dust for prints or get DNA from," said Bilson. "We were literally without any physical evidence."


Fire investigators determined the fire was started in the same bedroom where Joy Hibbs' body was found.''

''Hibbs' body was too badly burned for the coroner to determine if a sexual assault occurred; however, an item found at the scene suggested she was not.
"When we examined her, her clothes were burned off, but the snap that was on her jeans -- the waist snap -- was intact and still closed," Bilson explained. "If her jeans had been pulled off, it is unlikely that the [perpetrator] would have took the time to redress her."
Bilson added, "The fire was set by the [perpetrator] to cover his tracks. The fire was strictly an afterthought, to destroy evidence."
In addition to the lack of evidence, authorities were having trouble establishing a motive.''

"She loved the outdoors," her husband, Charlie Hibbs, then 36, told the Philadelphia Inquirer in July 1991. "She liked to fish, to work in the garden and to cook. We spent a lot of time together. We went everywhere together."

''Anyone with information about the murder of Joy Hibbs is asked to contact the Bristol Township Police Department at (215) 788-8289.''
 
May 25 2022
1653514052289.png
1653513886041.png
''A man who authorities said was working as a confidential informant for Bristol Township Police and was an early person of interest was charged Wednesday in the 31-year-old cold case of a mom found dead in her burning Croydon home in 1991.

Robert Atkins, 56, of Fairless Hills in Bristol Township, was charged with first-degree murder, second-degree murder and seven counts of arson and two counts of robbery in the death of Joy Hibbs. He was arraigned by Judge Frank Peranteau, Sr. in Bristol and ordered to Bucks County Correctional Center without bail.''


''Investigators initially believed Hibbs died in an accidental fire. An autopsy the next day however revealed she had been repeatedly stabbed. Her ribs were also fractured and she was likely asphyxiated. The autopsy also determined there was no smoke in her lungs and she likely died prior to the fire.

The Fire Marshal then determined fires were intentionally set in the kitchen, Hibbs’ son’s bedroom and in the hallway.

Investigators later learned Hibbs had cashed her paycheck hours before her death and her wallet was found stuffed in the living room couch. Her purse was also found with items emptied and strewn out in the kitchen while cash was never located.

Police said Hibbs was likely murdered between 11:50 a.m. and 12:50 p.m. that day. During that one-hour window, witnesses spotted a blue Chevrolet Monte Carlo parked outside Hibbs’ home. At the time, investigators named several suspects, including Atkins who had a blue Chevy Monte Carlo and also at one point lived two doors away from Hibbs.''
 
Well I'm glad of the arrest, but ugh IF only some facts had been more thoroughly investigated. Like the car! And please tell me how the now ex-wife could live with herself after this (from article above):

"In 2016, April Atkins would tell police the alibi was a lie, according to court documents.

She said the day of Hibbs' murder her ex-husband showed up at home covered in blood. He confessed he has stabbed someone and set the house on fire. He ordered her to call out of work, pack up their kids and the family fled to the Poconos for two days. She learned about Joy Hibbs murder when the family returned.

April Atkins said she didn't tell police in 2014 because she feared for her youngest child's safety because he lived with Robert Atkins."

This excuse angers me and boggles my mind. If he had been arrested back then, her child wouldn't have been living with him anymore and would have been somewhere safe. Instead she continued to let her child live with someone who could have perpetrated a crime like this! :mad: (Sorry just venting here).
 
It has lightened my soul that someone has been arrested and charged with this awful murder. I feel relieved.

And what was the motive, exactly? An argument over pot or pot dealing?
 

https://www./10008282/solved-the-1991-murder-of-joy-hibbs





 
Sept 21 2022

Defendant Robert Atkins is escorted to the police car after his preliminary hearing for the 1991 murder and arson of Joy Hibbs, 35, of Bristol Township on Wednesday, Sept. 21, 2022.


Defendant Robert Atkins is escorted to the police car after his preliminary hearing for the 1991 murder and arson of Joy Hibbs, 35, of Bristol Township on Wednesday, Sept. 21, 2022.
NUR B. ADAM / BUCKS COUNTY COURIER TIMES
Defendant Robert Atkins is escorted to the police car after his preliminary hearing for the 1991 murder and arson of Joy Hibbs, 35, of Bristol Township on Wednesday, Sept. 21, 2022.


Defendant Robert Atkins is escorted to the police car after his preliminary hearing for the 1991 murder and arson of Joy Hibbs, 35, of Bristol Township on Wednesday, Sept. 21, 2022.
NUR B. ADAM / BUCKS COUNTY COURIER TIMES
Charlie Hibbs, husband of the victim, leaves the courtroom after the preliminary hearing for Robert Atkins who is accused in the 1991 murder and arson of Joy Hibbs, 35, of Bristol Township on Wednesday, Sept. 21, 2022.


Charlie Hibbs, husband of the victim, leaves the courtroom after the preliminary hearing for Robert Atkins who is accused in the 1991 murder and arson of Joy Hibbs, 35, of Bristol Township on Wednesday, Sept. 21, 2022.
 
Sounds like robbery is a potential motive. Question is: if he lived two doors down why would his truck be different in the area? Wouldn't it be normal to see his truck nearby? Also, how did he know she just cashed the check?
 
^ From what I can tell he used to be a neighbour, i.e. he lived two doors down at one point and then he moved away to an area about 15 minutes away from there.

I don't think it was a robbery personally.

It is really sad about the confession regarding the alibi. They have good evidence to back that up. For example where she worked you lost pay if you called on short notice and on that day she called off work on short notice for them to go to the Poconos. She was meant to provide a two hour notice because it was care work with residents who were vulnerable but she called in 45 minutes prior to her shift about an hour after the crime and thus had to forfeit pay. They have the records of this thankfully from where she worked (they obviously kept good records and after all of this time too).

I'm going to reserve judgement about that because while I find it really sad that she did not say anything, we also don't know what kind of threats she was under and I would only form an opinion on that knowing the whole situation (which we don't). I do think it is horrible though. The Poconos thing is more annoying to me that it was treated as an alibi when obviously he had time to commit the crime, travel to his residence and then get to the Poconos so why was it counted as an alibi? I think they have the check in time too.

They base the estimated time of fire as when the clock stopped but it would have been before that when it was lit, so he would have lit it and exited affording him a few more minutes. So if say he left at 12:50pm and returned home at 1:05pm and packed up in 10 minutes, he could have left then and arrived in the Poconos at 3:15pm. Which is the time on the records. Also, they probably rounded it and the journey is approx 2 hours anyway. It's doable so I don't know why it was ever an alibi. To me it's actually suspicious because of the timing rather than anything else.
 
The trial for Robert Francis Atkins, 57, of Falls Township’s Fairless Hills section, is set to begin Monday morning at the Justice Center in Doylestown Borough. B

Atkins is facing charges of first degree murder, murder of the second degree, burglary, two counts of robbery, and seven count of arson.

The defendant opted for a bench trial before Bucks County Court of Common Pleas Judge Wallace Bateman.
 
''jan 29, 2024
The murder trial of a man who was charged more than 30 years after a woman was found dead inside her burning suburban Philadelphia home began on Monday. Loved ones of Joy Hibbs were face to face in a courtroom with Robert Atkins, the 57-year-old Fairless Hills man accused of murdering Hibbs in 1991''.
 
Guilty.
A man who was charged more than 30 years after a woman was found dead inside her burning suburban Philadelphia home was found guilty on Thursday.

Robert Atkins, 57, of Fairless Hills, Pa., was convicted of first-degree murder, arson and other offenses for his role in the 1991 murder of Joy Hibbs.

In May 2022, Atkins was arrested and charged with the crime.


 
After a three-day bench trial, Atkins, 57, was convicted Thursday of first-degree murder and two counts of arson for killing Hibbs, 35, inside her Croydon home in 1991. First-degree murder carries a mandatory life sentence in Pennsylvania.

On Friday, after victim impact statements read by Hibbs' family, including her husband, Charlie, her son and daughter, and a granddaughter she never got to meet, Bucks County Court Judge Wallace H. Bateman Jr. sentenced Atkins to life in prison without parole, along with 15 to 30 years in prison for the two counts of arson, to be served consecutive to the life sentence.
 
''Joy’s husband, Charlie Hibbs, read a victim impact statement in court.

“Joy was my high school sweetheart, my first love, mother to my children, and the loving soul that kept our family together,” he said. “According to my faith, I am supposed to forgive, and I am finding difficulty in doing so.”

“As this nightmare comes to an end for my family,” Charlie Hibbs continued, “his is about to start.”
1707170645005.png
Robert AtkinsBucks County District Attorney's Office
 
April 12 '24
1712933136271.png
''The 1991 murder of Joy Hibbs, a Bristol Township mother of two whose case remained unsolved for more than 30 years, will be featured in an upcoming episode of NBC’s “Dateline.”
The episode, titled “Justice for Joy,” is set to air this Friday at 9 p.m. on NBC 10 and later on Hulu.''
 
Thanks all for the research and posts here. Caught the Dateline with Keith Morrison last evening. Wow….. what a sad story.

SPOILER alert….. so stop reading if desired.

So if I understand the judge’s summation at sentencing, and other details presented and here this thread, the Bristol Township PA police authorities and investigators basically traded a confidential drug informant for a suspect in a murder case at that time? And it was the same individual!

If that is the case, that is appalling and wrong IMO. And it would be interesting to investigate and file FOIA and other requests to obtain any records on that. Seems someone else should be prosecuted for that IMO. Even if posthumously that and those involved should be exposed and identified by authorities. And the resolve and emotion shown in the Dateline by many, including the family, and the final police chief (I believe) to solve this was so revealing and true.

At least the police confidential informant / convicted murderer is now in jail. It is also fitting that the judge set the murder and arson convictions to run consecutively. MOO
 
Thanks all for the research and posts here. Caught the Dateline with Keith Morrison last evening. Wow….. what a sad story.

SPOILER alert….. so stop reading if desired.

So if I understand the judge’s summation at sentencing, and other details presented and here this thread, the Bristol Township PA police authorities and investigators basically traded a confidential drug informant for a suspect in a murder case at that time? And it was the same individual!

If that is the case, that is appalling and wrong IMO. And it would be interesting to investigate and file FOIA and other requests to obtain any records on that. Seems someone else should be prosecuted for that IMO. Even if posthumously that and those involved should be exposed and identified by authorities. And the resolve and emotion shown in the Dateline by many, including the family, and the final police chief (I believe) to solve this was so revealing and true.

At least the police confidential informant / convicted murderer is now in jail. It is also fitting that the judge set the murder and arson convictions to run consecutively. MOO
I saw this story also. Seems like we're seeing more and more of law enforcement not doing their job on these old cases. Why isn't someone investigating why LE looked the other way? Same as the Dobbs case in Idaho where LE forced a wrong confession and forced a
witness to lie. Nothing is done which tells LE they can do it and even if they get caught nothing happens to them. Same with OJ's case he walked because of poor LE investigation. JMO
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
75
Guests online
2,933
Total visitors
3,008

Forum statistics

Threads
592,548
Messages
17,970,796
Members
228,806
Latest member
Linnymac68$
Back
Top