Somehow reading this just made me more convinced that some random sex pervert did not do this, nor any outsider. Maybe John is just a poor writer, but what parent wouldn't take a moment to consider whether to call the police if they took that ransom note at all seriously. With hardly even a breath, nearly simultaneously with his 'absortion', John tells Patsy to call 911, then she calls all their friends to come over and help, then he considers how to get the money even though the note says they are watching them?
To me it seems you would err on the side of caution, not invite a bunch of friends over so the house is obviously busy. Caution the 911 or LE that a note claims they are watching them and could they come unmarked.
- He arranged the money and called the people they were to meet in another state before searching the house?
- He only goes downstairs because he suddenly remembers the broken window from months before?
- Patsy is just upstairs rocking, clinging to a cross, and waiting to vomit?
- The police tell him how to answer a call but he complains they should have told him to search the entire house first (he never says anything to them about it though or ever has the urge to do it himself from the start)?
- It's afternoon before he realizes all those people are contaminating the crime scene?
- I find it disturbing that when he finally sees JonBenet his reaction is not horror at finding her looking the way she did, but basically, "we finally found her!" - then he goes on quite a while musing she might still be alive although he says she is cold and stiff as he carries her (and seemingly unconcerned with moving her body).
- Why was their priest already there anyway?
This is from the horse's mouth after all these years, lots of time and space to edit, and he can't even make this sound logical? I know people have different reactions to crises, death and such horrors, but I always wonder when I watch someone's response to a homicide - do they seem to be mimicking something like you'd see on tv or how they think it should look rather than represent normal (even within a broad range) reactions.