Found Deceased CO - Dylan Nicholas Redwine, 13, Vallecito, 19 Nov 2012 *father arrested* #4

[RANCH]

I can't believe it. Bogan said that Mark made up the conflicting stories about a cold sore and nerf ball cut because he was scared. Of course he was scared. He was caught lying to the FBI.

The jury is going to love that one. JMO

 

[asyousay]

Elaine was the one blaming Mr Mark Redwine for this, that is her attitude

Well considering she sent her son off to visit his father against her better judgment and he ended up dead with no plausible explanation given is it any wonder she blamed the last known person to see him?!

 

[katydid23]

what LE chooses to emphasise and not emphasise says a lot about how they are trying to target Mr Mark Redwine

 

[Chelly]

37 minutes left.

 

[RANCH]

I dunno.... In Federal and several state courts, a dog alert is deemed probable cause for a search warrant. IMO, that's a strong vote for evidence. At trial, the problem is NOT challenging the dog alert but detention (i.e., the amount of time the driver/vehicle can be detained waiting for the sniff dogs to arrive).

http://directives.chicagopolice.org/forms/Vehicle Sniffs.pdf

That's why scent dogs are called walking search warrants by some. JMO

 

[LotusPawprint]

All three prosecutors have to be chomping at the bit to do the rebuttal.
(I know it's already decided but they have to be itching to refute every nonsensical piece of garbage out of Moron's mouth)

 

[katydid23]

you have to determine who you are going to believe

'it wasn't a protest it was a gathering'

I dont remember collecting the miller lite can

The fact that Dr France broke off part of the skull is not important

I looked at the cranium

etc etc


These are ^^ all statements that dont stand up to scrutiny

 

[Warwick7]

The forensic blood evidence isn't really strong IMO.

What is strong is Mark denying multiple times that Dylan bled in his house until the FBI truck arrived and he knew they would find Dylan's blood.

We the go from Dylan not bleeding to having a cold sore that dripped blood to a last gasp story about a nerf ball cutting his lip which made him spit blood on the floor. All in rapid succession.

I doubt the defense will bring that up either. JMO

Great post, and I want to add a tidbit to that: "He talked about wrestling Dylan to the couch...."
I think that is exactly true!

 

[katydid23]

last thing I want to talk about is the timeline--MR is incapable of killing his son dismembering him and dumping him up the mountain in such a short time

 

[Cindizzi]

you have to determine who you are going to believe

'it wasn't a protest it was a gathering'

I dont remember collecting the miller lite can

The fact that Dr France broke off part of the skull is not important

I looked at the cranium

etc etc


These are ^^ all statements that dont stand up to scrutiny

And the last one he said was “ I hugged him goodbye “!
How the hell can he include EH comment on that list? That’s just cruel.

 

[katydid23]

defense showing Walmart video

Dylan in electronic section--not out of ordinary for 13 yr old---they pick out movies--this is not homicidal rage---I see them walking out together---I dont see him looking about to snap and kill his son

 

[katydid23]

Elaine had said that sometimes Dylan would fall asleep or lose a charge, ending the convo...[what's the chance that happened at 8pm? ]

 

[wary]

I have to agree with the defense on the HRD dog. The dog alerts are not evidence of a dead human in Mark's house and truck. JMO

I was stunned to read that a HRD will alert on hair or a fingernail. If this is true, it goes against everything I’ve heard about HRD training. And, if it’s true, then it’s impossible to take HRD signals seriously UNLESS they actually find human remains.

 

[RANCH]

The homicidal rage came a bit later. If it happened a Walmart Mark would have been in prison a long time ago.

This isn't helping Mark in any way.

 

[Ghostwheel]

I have to agree with the defense on the HRD dog. The dog alerts are not evidence of a dead human in Mark's house and truck. JMO

This is true. It is evidence that a trained dog identified decomposing remains of some sort in those areas, which can include blood. But this is only part of an overall larger picture of "Dylan was not bleeding, Dylan had a cold sore, Dylan was hit in the mouth with a Nerf ball". The fact that the blood was found means that the story changing has more impact. The dog itself is not one thing to be considered in a void, but a part of a larger picture. IMO, the dog helped them to find the locations where the blood would be, and MIGHT also indicate that there were other decomposing remains, but by no means actually proves it because there WAS blood, which is decomposing remains.

 

[shotgun09]

Are we there yet?

 

[Seattle1]

That's why scent dogs are called walking search warrants by some. JMO

And probably why I'm more confident in forensic evidence dogs than not. (Forensic evidence dog is never looking for live scent).

 

[katydid23]

That only leaves 13 hours, to commit the crime and clean it up, look at the distance to the remains site---

[that's plenty of time, IMO]

 

[Chelly]

Are we there yet?

23 minutes

 

[Cindizzi]

Prosecution never implied he dismembered DR.

Bogan saying use the forensic phone logs and do the math. It would only leave 13, 14 hours to do all this and cleanup.