33 souls on cargo ship missing in Hurricane Joaquin, October 2015

Coast Guard calls off search for El Faro black box weeks after the ship and its bridge were located and only one body of the 33 crew members was found

The 790ft ship lost power during a hurricane and disappeared October 1

A search team later found the ship in 15,000 feet of water

But the ship's mast, where the black box was mounted, was never found

Data recorder charts the date, time and speed of a vessel and conversations between captain and crew

Investigators remain hopeful they can determine what happened to the ship without the voyage data recorder

Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...s-search-El-Faro-black-box.html#ixzz3rjxTcuBK

That was the lamest most mediocre search and rescue I have ever heard of. They were slow from the start, they couldn’t even be bothered to recover a body floating in the water. By the time they got serious in looking for the ship and black box, it had already run out of juice and stopped pinging. Why do they even have these black boxes on ships and planes, if they are not even going to start looking for it untill after it stops pinging?:facepalm:

I’m sure the ship’s owners are happy though. Now we will never know exactly what happened.
 
They lost the engine power, how does that make the captian overconfident? They were left to the mercy of the storm and had no chance..

Overconfidence would be going into the path of a storm in an old ship thinking this ship could make it.
 
[video=youtube;q3h8HbloK0o]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q3h8HbloK0o[/video]
 
El Faro captain was warned about storm by text message from his second mate who was on vacation and skipped trip

El Faro sank after sailing directly into Category 4 Hurricane Joaquin last October killing all 33 crew on board

Second Mate Charles Baird testified he warned Capt. Michael Davidson that the storm was forecast to become a hurricane

US Coast Guard panel in Jacksonville is currently investigating the sinking

Baird said the captain responded that he planned to follow his normal route but would skirt south of the hurricane

He also testified that El Faro had been sailing with a broken wind speed gauge for two to three months

Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...m-text-message-second-mate.html#ixzz40chXOXAd
 

:great: Now we will find out what really happened.

I’m happy that Sen. Bill Nelson pushed the NTSB to do their job. It’s sad that it takes intervention from a Senator to get the NTSB to recover a data recorder. This whole thing looks like a cover up to me. It’s sitting right out in the open in plain sight. The first search team, sure weren't trying very hard to find it.
 
NTSB: Retrieving cargo ship El Faro's voyage data recorder could take months

The NTSB said in a statement that investigators who found the data recorder aren't able to retrieve it because they don't have the right equipment to do it aboard their research vessel Atlantis, which is owned by the Navy and operated by the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution in Massachusetts. The data recorder is attached to a steel beam that's connected to the mast structure, which is resting about 1,500 feet from the rest of the El Faro.

"Now that we have been able to see just how the VDR is oriented relative to the mast structure, it’s clear that we’re going to need specialized deep-water salvage recovery equipment in order to bring it up," Brian Curtis, acting director of the NTSB Office of Marine Safety, said in a statement. "Extracting a recorder capsule attached to a four-ton mast under 15,000 feet of water presents formidable challenges, but we’re going to do everything that is technically feasible to get that recorder into our lab."

NTSB: Retrieving cargo ship El Faro's voyage data recorder could take months
 
El Faro data recorder may provide closure for grieving families


JACKSONVILLE, Fla. - Military Sealift Command in Virginia deployed the USNS Apache Friday in an attempt to retrieve the voyage data recorder from the wreckage site of the sunken cargo ship El Faro. Family members of the lost crew hope the information it contains can offer closure.


Family members of the El Faro crew are very hopeful that this will be the trip that gives them answers. They want to know what’s on the VDR so that they can know what was happening during the minutes before El Faro sank.


Before the Apache left Virginia, one of the last things brought on board was a wreath in memory of the 33 crew members lost.


Investigators told News4Jax they hope to be at the wreckage site by Tuesday and will spend 2-4 days on site, trying to retrieve the VDR before they head back.

http://www.news4jax.com/news/el-faro-data-recorder-may-provide-closure-for-grieving-families
 
Recorder from Cargo Ship El Faro Recovered

8/9/2016

The voyage data recorder from El Faro, a US flagged cargo ship that sank during Hurricane Joaquin in October 2015, was successfully recovered from the ocean floor late Monday evening.

Military Sealift Command’s fleet ocean tug USNS Apache departed Virginia Beach, Virginia, Friday with personnel from the NTSB, the U.S. Coast Guard, the U.S. Navy and Phoenix International aboard. After arriving at the accident location on Monday morning, technicians maneuvered CURV-21, a deep ocean remotely operated underwater vehicle, down about 15,000 feet to the sea floor where the wreckage of El Faro rests.


Specialized tools were used to extricate the VDR capsule from the mast structure to which it was attached. The capsule was recovered to the deck of the ocean tug at about 10:30 pm Monday evening.


The voyage data recorder will be examined while at sea by NTSB investigators aboard the USNS Apache, to assess the condition of the device and to ensure proper preservation for readout and further examination ashore. The VDR will be transported to the NTSB's laboratory here after the Apache returns from sea on or about Aug. 12, 2016. Once at the NTSB's lab a team of specialists will audition the recording. It is not yet known how long it may take to review the data and audio information that may be captured on El Faro's VDR. While the minimum design requirement for VDRs of this type is for 12 hours of recording, it may contain additional information -- the review of which is a thorough and time consuming undertaking. NTSB will provide updates as investigators learn more about the condition and contents of the El Faro's VDR.

http://www.ntsb.gov/news/press-releases/Pages/pr20160809.aspx
 
All I can say about this is, it's too bad the Captain didn't survive so he could be charged with manslaughter.

NTSB releases transcripts detailing El Faro's final hours

According to the transcript, the third mate called Davidson just after 11 p.m. to discuss the weather situation and the ship's proximity to the storm.

The third mate called back at 11:15 p.m. and said El Faro would be 22 miles from the storm and suggested a change to a southerly course.

The audio indicated that the captain told the third mate there would be no change in course.

The second mate arrived on the bridge just before midnight to take over for the third mate.

At 1:01 a.m., the second mate called Davidson and mentioned the weather and potentially altering the course.

After phone call ended, the second mate indicated to a crew member on the bridge that Davidson wanted to stay on the planned course.

As the morning progressed, the sounds of objects, possibly cargo or structure, were heard shifting and falling in the vicinity of the bridge.

At 4:10 a.m., Davidson returned the the bridge of the ship.

About 20 minutes later, the chief mate received a call from the engine room about the ship's list and engine oil level concerns.

At 5:12 a.m., and extreme list of El Faro is reported. The captain received at call at 5:43 a.m., saying there was a problem in the No. 3 hold and flooding was suspected.

Davidson ordered the ship turned to port at 5:53 a.m. to help alleviate the list.

El Faro then lost propulsion at 6:13 a.m. Numerous conversations about correcting the list and stopping the flooding can be heard.

At 7:17 a.m., a distress message is sent, and 10 minutes later Davidson sounded a general alarm.

At 7:30 a.m., there were reports of containers in the water, and Davidson ordered the abandon ship alarm be sounded. He then ordered life rafts in the water.

The recording ends at 7:40 a.m. with the captain and a crew member still on the bridge.

All 33 crew members on board were killed

NTSB releases transcripts detailing El Faro's final hours
 
All I can say about this is, it's too bad the Captain didn't survive so he could be charged with manslaughter.

I agree. Thank you for posting this. What a fuc***ing waste.

Is this a case of profit at all costs for the company over safety, or a Captain believing that? Or sheer incompetence?

Either way, utterly unnecessary waste of lives. And from the very start I wanted to believe this was just a horrible case of wrong time wrong place. Damn.
 
I agree. Thank you for posting this. What a fuc***ing waste.

Is this a case of profit at all costs for the company over safety, or a Captain believing that? Or sheer incompetence?

Either way, utterly unnecessary waste of lives. And from the very start I wanted to believe this was just a horrible case of wrong time wrong place. Damn.

In this case, I think it was just sheer incompetence.
 
For those who would like to read the entire transcript, here is the download link for it. You can read all 500+ pages of it, right to their last words as the ship was going down. It's pretty dramatic.

http://dms.ntsb.gov/pubdms/search/document.cfm?docID=447547&docketID=58116&mkey=92109

I would have turned that boat around while the captain went to sleep. They let him sleep for hours before re alerting him that things were getting worst.

But he kept on going while acting like he has done this 1000 times.

The recordings were sad.

Rest in peace to the crew.
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
169
Guests online
3,697
Total visitors
3,866

Forum statistics

Threads
592,590
Messages
17,971,449
Members
228,833
Latest member
ddph
Back
Top