CA CA - Nancy MacDuckston, 52, Santa Cruz County, 11 Aug 2003

One thing that's intrigued me about this case is its similarity to the Patrick McDermott case. Patrick was the boyfriend of Olivia Newton John. He staged his own death in 2005 - leaving his wallet etc on a boat and declared "most likely drowned" by the Coast Guard in 2008. Nancy also left her wallet (and presents) in her van near cliff's edge. And like McDermott her actual fate was not clear as no body ever turned up despite efforts. McDermott was tracked down in Mexico a couple of years later on and didn't want to be bothered. Brian on Brian's Dreams web site said he "saw" her in Mexico and named the town. And in another oddity McDermott even looks a little like the guy Nancy was said to have dined with on the day of her disappearance.

All a bit far-fetched with the events being two years separated. But at the very least it shows that people faking their death at water's edge and starting a new life abroad to escape whatever - does happen. Nancy could well be alive - even hanging out with Patrick. An article in 2006 said McDemott had been spotted with a mystery blonde woman at a $33/night Mexican Beach shack.


http://ohnotheydidnt.livejournal.com/7037555.html

http://myarmsfoldback.blogspot.com/2006/06/olivia-newton-johns-boyfriend-fakes.html
Patrick McDermott - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
 
@EdinburghLass I would say that most of the friends and parents of the nursury school where she was in charge felt it looked like a suicide. She left very very detailed plans about how to care for the animals at the school the night before she went to relax at the coast. And she left out things like insurance and other papers that would be critical to continuing the running of the nursury school in her absense. So just from those clues it seemed she knew she was going away forever before she left. Some who knew her argued that not too much should be read into those clues. But I would rule out stranger abduction because of the advance notice. Other possibilities would be of course suicide off the crazy high cliffs of Davenport. But another possibility would be a planned disappearance like Patrick McDermott who staged his disappearance water's edge and ended up in Mexico because of difficulties in his life. And she could have done this in coordination with another person - say the guy she was seen having dinner with at the Davenport Cash Store and Restaurant. Or it could be she had met that guy online or somehow and they planned to have a discreet romance and he turned out to be a kidnapper or murderer. They were never able to locate that guy.
 
Did a google after thinking about Nancy today and found this 2011 article that says she sent postcards on the day she disappeared. I don't recall ever hearing that before?

http://www.examiner.com/article/nan...g-belmont-woman-last-seen-with-mysterious-man

A few days later two friends received postcards that Nancy probably mailed the day she went to the post office. They said, "Hey, I'm finally taking that vacation, a day trip."
 
I have a couple ancillary connections to this story: I grew up in Santa Cruz and went to used to hang out with one of Nancy's nephews in college. Haven't talked to him in a few years but I still wonder about this case from time to time. Suicide off the cliffs of the the coast from Santa Cruz up to Pigeon Point is now more likely to be hypothermia or shark attack than it would be from any fall. The cliffs just aren't that steep that you would know you will die as opposed to severely injuring yourself.

Strange sugar.
 
Actually the only cliffs that will almost guarantee a deadly fall are the cliffs at New Brighton State Park in Capitola.
 
I think a 5-story cliff could kill.

http://www.eastbaytimes.com/sanmateocountytimes/localnews/ci_4521373

The only traces of MacDuckston were a hat, chair and book found outside her minivan, parked near a five-story cliff a few miles north of Davenport, a coastal community near Santa Cruz where MacDuckston was last seen.

Did she take her own life? Was she murdered? Did she simply vanish? Did she fall from the edge of a cliff? These are the unanswered questions haunting her family.
 
The fact that Nancy made long-term arrangements with her workplace and sent her friends postcards on the day she disappeared would suggest suicide or a walkaway.

I have to wonder if the sighting of Nancy with the 'Polynesian' man was unreliable or a red herring entirely.
 


  • nancy_jean_macduckston_6.jpg
  • nancy_jean_macduckston_7.jpg
  • nancy_jean_macduckston_8.jpg
  • nancy_jean_macduckston_11.jpg
  • nancy_jean_macduckston_12.jpg
MacDuckston, circa 2003; MacDuckston's minivan; Sketch of MacDuckston's companion
  • Missing Since 08/11/2003
  • Missing From Belmont, California
  • Classification Missing
  • Sex Female
  • Race White
  • Date of Birth 11/04/1950 (72)
  • Age 52 years old
  • Height and Weight 5'6, 125 pounds

  • Clothing/Jewelry Description Blue jeans and possibly a light-colored or denim coat and a bright pink sun hat.

  • Associated Vehicle(s) Tan 2001 Mazda MPV minivan with the California license plate number 4POG552 (accounted for)
  • Distinguishing Characteristics Caucasian female. Dark blonde hair, blue eyes. MacDuckston's hair was chin-length at the time of her disappearance.

Details of Disappearance​

MacDuckston was seen by her adult daughter at home in the 2000 Block of Belle Monti in Belmont, California, on August 11, 2003, approximately 8:30 a.m. She left her home, telling friends and family that she would be shopping in Davenport, California for the day.

MacDuckston was seen shopping at the New Davenport Cash Store and Restaurant at about 10:00 a.m., and at the Davenport Post Office sometime between 1:30 and 3:30 p.m.

Later, between 5:30 and 6:30 p.m., MacDuckston was sighted at the New Davenport Cash Store and Restaurant again, eating a vegetarian dinner with an unidentified man and appearing very happy. The man is described as being Asian or Polynesian with salt-and-pepper hair, aged between his late thirties to early fifties, and about 5'6 and 160 pounds.

A sketch of the man is posted with this case summary. He is not considered a suspect in MacDuckston's disappearance but police would like to identify and question him. He and MacDuckston appeared to have a romantic attachment to each other.

MacDuckston was also seen at the Whale City Bakery sometime on August 11. She has never been heard from again. Her husband reported her missing the next day at 9:00 a.m.

On that same afternoon, MacDuckston's minivan, a tan 2001 Mazda MPV with the California license plate number 4POG552, was found abandoned near some cliffs and a beach on Highway 1 near Davenport in northern Santa Cruz County, California, five miles north of the New Davenport Cash Store and Restaurant. This is one of MacDuckston's favorite places.

There were gifts locked inside the van. A photograph of it is posted with this case summary. There was no sign of MacDuckston near the scene, but some of her belongings were located in the area. Investigators found a folding chair, a blanket, a book about travel in Australia, sunglasses and a bright pink sun hat near Greyhound Rock about a hundred yards from the van; it appears that MacDuckston may have been reading on the beach.

MacDuckston is said to have made some long-term arrangements with her workplace before she disappeared. Police do not suspect foul play in her disappearance and there are indications that she may have left of her own accord, but she was not having problems at home or work and her husband says it would be unlike her to leave behind her young granddaughter.

The circumstances surrounding her disappearance are unclear. Drawing on the subject of the book that was found near the van, investigators have looked for MacDuckston in Australia, but with fruitless results.

Suicide was also considered as a possibility, as the cliffs near where her van was parked are known for suicides. A sheriff's dog tracked MacDuckston's scent to the cliff's edge. However, she had no history of depression or other mental problems.

MacDuckston is a graduate of the University of California at Santa Barbara and was the director of Carlmont Parent Nursery School in Belmont at the time of her disappearance, and her life is said to have revolved around her work.

She is described as an organized, dedicated person and a nature lover who enjoys exploring back roads and isolated areas. She and her husband moved to Belmont in 1979, and have a grown daughter and son. Her case remains unsolved.

Investigating Agency​

  • Belmont Police Department 650-595-7400

Source Information​

. .
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
167
Guests online
4,140
Total visitors
4,307

Forum statistics

Threads
593,069
Messages
17,980,863
Members
229,015
Latest member
Alafair
Back
Top