Actually, Judge Edward Davila very quickly advanced to the top of my favorite US District Court Judges!
Judge Davilia was upset when he had to dismiss the jurors early because the defense attorney asked for a sidebar with only 17 minutes left in the day.
The defense was questioning Pandori (former Theranos Lab Director) about an email he allegedly sent to another lab director on his last day of work. Pandori responded multiple times that he didn't recall the email. The defense tried again, asking if it was possible that he might have written it, and Pandori replied it was possible.
From the link:
"Why are we wasting time?" asked the judge. "We had 17 minutes
and surely, surely you could have touched on another subject and come back to this … I had to send the jury home early and it's unfortunate."
[..]
"This is the tail end of that," said Jeffrey Coopersmith of Orrick. "This is informing the issue of why he left."
The problem is, the judge said, is it's not known if the memo is actually Pandori's own words.
Coopersmith told the court that, in the end, the former lab director had "hedged a little bit" by saying he didn't have a memory of the document.
The judge challenged that assertion.
"You repeated the question again and again and again, and we know what witnesses do," Judge Davila said. "They'll yield, they'll say 'yeah, it's possible.'"
The government's lawyer, John Bostic, told the judge that, under a stipulation between the parties, documents stored and produced by Theranos are admissible, but only if there are no issues with authenticity.
Coopersmith told the court that there were numerous ways to authenticate the email and report, which he said was given to the government by Theranos and was numbered in a way that showed it was one of the documents stipulated for admission.
"Here's the bottom line," Coopersmith said. "If this document doesn't come in from Dr. Pandori … we'll do this the hard way … we'll have a paralegal lined up from the U.S. Attorney's Office about what they received from Theranos … "
Judge Davila cut Coopersmith off.
"Don't threaten me, you're better than that," he said.
Read more at: 'Don't Threaten Me,' Judge Warns Balwani Atty At Fraud Trial - Law360
I am always amazed at how US lawyers speak to Judges!