You are very kind, Lamb, to give him that benefit of the doubt-But for me, I get a certain feeling from this guy, the same feeling I got from the hippie lady who told AndreaL and JeffA that hussies aren't murderers, and the grief counselor non-published lady who tried to convince us KC was grieving. They are people that either purposefully live their lives against the grain (and not in a fun way, in a defiant way) and enjoy hearing themselves spin tales, or they have been paid to turn good solid science into a game.
I do agree it was sloppy work; and his hypotheses are not based on some of the same things I have read since this case started, for instance, I have read that sociopathy really starts to rear its head around and after 18, not prior to 16. If this "doctor" could infer that George killed Caylee or dumped her because, as an ex-cop, he was capable of covering it up, then couldn't he also infer that KC killed Caylee because KC hid the pregnancy? I can Google on a whim two or three studies that indicate that filicides of an unwanted child are often marked by the hiding or denial of pregnancy. And surely if he saw KC's medical records, he knew she did not seek prenatal care until way late in the game-Why? Did he not read the police report on Rick and what ACTUALLY went down at the wedding? That's just one example, there are many a way to infer that KC, and KC alone, murdered Caylee.
It's just as someone wrote here previously-This doctor is a mirror mage of the jury: Absent a smoking gun, he was not willing to indict KC for anything. Anything. If he ever considered she was lying, which he would not even call her a liar, where are the notations in his papers? Made sure to keep them out, eh?
Again I wonder why he would compromise himself amongst his peers-Even if he was only working with what the defense gave him, how is that defensable science? You have to have all available information, otherwise it's cherry-picking and I think other psychologists would call him on that. But, if he feels like he can be a career expert witness, then what he did in this depo will suit him just fine.