ID - Daralyn Johnson, 9, Nampa, Murdered, 1982 *inmate arrest in 2020*

[ReadySet]

monster is in prison for sexual assault of children but doesn't want to add murder to his rap sheet. nasty subhuman.

Canyon County District Judge Thomas Whitney denied Dalrymple's request on Aug. 11, but no document has been filed within the clerk's office.

The man who will face trial in a Nampa cold case asked for different attorney that isn't LDS or Republican. A judge denied it

Dalrymple has pleaded not guilty and his jury trial is scheduled for May 13, 2024, but that hasn't come without a fight.

www.ktvb.com

 

[Niner]

monster is in prison for sexual assault of children but doesn't want to add murder to his rap sheet. nasty subhuman.

Hey @ReadySet - I can not access the article - can you let me know "what" the Judge denied on his "request"?

Also - I have as next status hearing on 3/6/24 - anything earlier? TIA!

 

[ReadySet]

Hey @ReadySet - I can not access the article - can you let me know "what" the Judge denied on his "request"?

Also - I have as next status hearing on 3/6/24 - anything earlier? TIA!

The man who will face trial in a Nampa cold case asked for different attorney that isn't LDS or Republican. A judge denied it

Dalrymple has pleaded not guilty and his jury trial is scheduled for May 13, 2024, but that hasn't come without a fight.

www.ktvb.com

CANYON COUNTY, Idaho — A Canyon County judge has denied a murder suspect's request to seek a different attorney after he said he wants counsel that is not part of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints.
He also doesn't want an attorney who is Republican.


In motions filed this year, Dalrymple has accused his attorney of depriving him of his right to effectiveness of counsel and asked for a new public defender.
"I asked him to gather records showing where I truly lived, that I was at work, corruption of Caldwell Police and Canyon County Sheriff's
He also asked for a change of venue for his trial claiming the case has notoriety and he doesn't want members of law enforcement on the jury.
Dalrymple wrote he didn't want his defense attorney to be a part of the LDS church or a member of the Republican party.
"...The victim's family is very involved and influential in the Mormon church and for reasons relating to Dalrymple's current incarceration Dalrymple requested the attorneys not be a Republican," he wrote in the filing.
He also asked for more information on Charles Fain, who was convicted in Johnson's murder but later exonerated when the hairs found on her were determined to belong to someone else.

Canyon County District Judge Thomas Whitney denied Dalrymple's request on Aug. 11, but no written order has been filed within the clerk's office.
The Canyon County Prosecutor's Office declined to comment on the matter as the case is still pending. However, they will be responding to pleadings filed in the case.
The Canyon County Public Defender's Office also is unable to give out information on current cases, according to their voicemail system.

@Niner
Nothing earlier than3/6/24

 

[Niner]

Thank you for that info @ReadySet !

 

[FrostedGlass]

The latest Murder Sheet podcast has a short segment on this case.

Beginning at the 24mm

The Cheat Sheet: Civil Cases and Cameras

The Cheat Sheet is The Murder Sheet's segment breaking down weekly news and updates in some of the murder cases we cover. In this episode, we'll talk about the murder of Laurel Jean Mitchell, the Burger Chef murders, the murder of Bob Adair, the University of Idaho murders, and the murder of...

art19.com

 

[Niner]

Wednesday, March 6th:
*Status Conference Hearing (@ 2:30pm MT) - ID – Daralyn Renée Johnson (9) (missing Feb. 21, 1982, found Feb. 24, 1982, Nampa. Her body, which had been sexually assaulted & beaten, was found in a shallow drainage ditch along the Snake River in Melba by a group of fishermen. Johnson sustained blunt force trauma to the head & torso, but ultimately died from drowning) - *David Allen Dalrymple (24 @ time of crime/62/now 65) charged (5/4/20) & formally charged & re-arraigned (10/27/22) with felony 1st degree murder & felony rape. Plead not guilty. No bond. DA will not seek DP.
Trial was set to begin on 3/13/23 was continued on 5/13/24.
Case & court info from 5/4/20 thru 1/17/23 reference post #113 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...ered-1982-inmate-arrest-in-2020.520075/page-6
1/19/23 Update: Status Conference held. All pending motions; in person. Next status conference hearing on 3/9/23 @ 1:30pm to set new trial date.
3/9/23 Update: Status conference was held in person. Trial dates to be set. Defendant's pro se motion for new counsel; proposed subpoena Tecum. State's Motion to present subpoena Duces tecums-Granted by Judge Thomas W. Whitney. Motion to terminate current counsel & replace with conflict counsel-denied by Judge Whitney. 4/18/23: Motion requesting court to appoint new counsel. Declaration in support of motion to appoint new counsel. 4/26/23: State's supplemental response to request for Discovery-amended 16th. Trial on 3/13/23 was cancelled/vacated. Next status conference hearing on 3/6/24 @ 2:30pm, pretrial conference on 4/10/24 @ 2:30pm & trial now set to begin on 5/13/24 @ 8:30am.
8/11/23 Update: In motions filed this year, Dalrymple has accused his attorney of depriving him of his right to effectiveness of counsel & asked for a new public defender. "I asked him to gather records showing where I truly lived, that I was at work, corruption of Caldwell Police & Canyon County Sheriff's. He also asked for a change of venue for his trial claiming the case has notoriety & he doesn't want members of law enforcement on the jury. Dalrymple wrote he didn't want his defense attorney to be a part of the LDS church or a member of the Republican party. "...The victim's family is very involved & influential in the Mormon church & for reasons relating to Dalrymple's current incarceration Dalrymple requested the attorneys not be a Republican," he wrote in the filing. He also asked for more information on Charles Fain, who was convicted in Johnson's murder but later exonerated when the hairs found on her were determined to belong to someone else. Canyon County District Judge Thomas Whitney denied Dalrymple's request on Aug. 11, but no written order has been filed within the clerk's office.

 

[Niner]

@ReadySet - any updated court hearing dates yet? I have 4/10 next in my notes. TIA!

 

[ReadySet]

@ReadySet - any updated court hearing dates yet? I have 4/10 next in my notes. TIA!

Case Number	Style / Defendant	Case Type	Date / Time	Hearing Type	Judge	Courtroom	Case Category
CR14-20-07840	Dalrymple, David Allen	Criminal	3/14/2024 3:00 PM	Status Conference	Whitney, Thomas W.		Criminal
CR14-20-07840	Dalrymple, David Allen	Criminal	4/1/2024 9:00 AM	Evidentiary Hearing	Whitney, Thomas W.		Criminal
CR14-20-07840	Dalrymple, David Allen	Criminal	4/4/2024 9:00 AM	Evidentiary Hearing	Whitney, Thomas W.		Criminal
CR14-20-07840	Dalrymple, David Allen	Criminal	4/10/2024 2:30 PM	Pre-trial Conference	Whitney, Thomas W.		Criminal
CR14-20-07840	Dalrymple, David Allen	Criminal	5/3/2024 9:00 AM	Status Conference	Whitney, Thomas W.		Criminal
CR14-20-07840	Dalrymple, David Allen	Criminal	5/13/2024 8:30 AM	Jury Trial	Whitney, Thomas W.		Criminal

 

[Niner]

Thanks a bunch @ReadySet !

 

[Niner]

Thursday, March 14th:
*Status Conference Hearing (@ 3pm MT) - ID – Daralyn Renée Johnson (9) (missing Feb. 21, 1982, found Feb. 24, 1982, Nampa. Her body, which had been sexually assaulted & beaten, was found in a shallow drainage ditch along the Snake River in Melba by a group of fishermen. Johnson sustained blunt force trauma to the head & torso, but ultimately died from drowning) - *David Allen Dalrymple (24 @ time of crime/62/now 65) charged (5/4/20) & formally charged & re-arraigned (10/27/22) with felony 1st degree murder & felony rape. Plead not guilty. No bond. DA will not seek DP.
Trial set to begin on 5/13/24.
Case & court info from 5/4/20 thru 4/26/23 reference post #126 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...ered-1982-inmate-arrest-in-2020.520075/page-7
8/11/23 Update: In motions filed this year, Dalrymple has accused his attorney of depriving him of his right to effectiveness of counsel & asked for a new public defender. "I asked him to gather records showing where I truly lived, that I was at work, corruption of Caldwell Police & Canyon County Sheriff's. He also asked for a change of venue for his trial claiming the case has notoriety & he doesn't want members of law enforcement on the jury. Dalrymple wrote he didn't want his defense attorney to be a part of the LDS church or a member of the Republican party. " The victim's family is very involved & influential in the Mormon church & for reasons relating to Dalrymple's current incarceration Dalrymple requested the attorneys not be a Republican," he wrote in the filing. He also asked for more information on Charles Fain, who was convicted in Johnson's murder but later exonerated when the hairs found on her were determined to belong to someone else. Canyon County District Judge Thomas Whitney denied Dalrymple's request on Aug. 11, but no written order has been filed within the clerk's office. Next status conference hearing on 3/6/24 @ 2:30pm.
3/6/24 Update: Next status hearing on 3/14/24 @ 3pm, Evidentiary hearings on 4/1/24 & 4/4/24 @ 9am, Pretrial conference hearing on 4/10/24 @ 2:30pm & status conference hearing on 5/3/24 @ 9am.

 

[Niner]

Monday, April 1st:
*Evidentiary Hearing (Day 1 of 2) (@ 9am MT) - ID – Daralyn Renée Johnson (9) (missing Feb. 21, 1982, found Feb. 24, 1982, Nampa. Her body, which had been sexually assaulted & beaten, was found in a shallow drainage ditch along the Snake River in Melba by a group of fishermen. Johnson sustained blunt force trauma to the head & torso, but ultimately died from drowning) - *David Allen Dalrymple (24 @ time of crime/62/now 65) charged (5/4/20) & formally charged & re-arraigned (10/27/22) with felony 1st degree murder & felony rape. Plead not guilty. No bond. DA will not seek DP.
Trial set to begin on 5/13/24.
Case & court info from 5/4/20 thru 8/11/23 reference post #130 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...ered-1982-inmate-arrest-in-2020.520075/page-7
3/6/24 Update: Next status hearing on 3/14/24 @ 3pm, Evidentiary hearings on 4/1/24 & 4/4/24 @ 9am, Pretrial conference hearing on 4/10/24 @ 2:30pm & status conference hearing on 5/3/24 @ 9am.
3/14/24 Update: Next evidentiary hearing Day 1 of 2 on 4/1/24 @ 9am.

 

[Niner]

Thursday, April 4th:
*Evidentiary Hearing (Day 2 of 2) (@ 9am MT) - ID – Daralyn Renée Johnson (9) (missing Feb. 21, 1982, found Feb. 24, 1982, Nampa. Her body, which had been sexually assaulted & beaten, was found in a shallow drainage ditch along the Snake River in Melba by a group of fishermen. Johnson sustained blunt force trauma to the head & torso, but ultimately died from drowning) - *David Allen Dalrymple (24 @ time of crime/62/now 65) charged (5/4/20) & formally charged & re-arraigned (10/27/22) with felony 1st degree murder & felony rape. Plead not guilty. No bond. DA will not seek DP.
Trial set to begin on 5/13/24.
Case & court info from 5/4/20 thru 3/6/24 reference post #131 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...ered-1982-inmate-arrest-in-2020.520075/page-7
3/14/24 Update: Next evidentiary hearing Day 1 of 2 on 4/1/24 @ 9am. 4/1/24 Update: Evidentiary hearing continues on 4/4/24 @ 9am.

 

[Niner]

Wednesday, April 10th:
*Pretrial Conference Hearing (@ 2:30pm MT) - ID – Daralyn Renée Johnson (9) (missing Feb. 21, 1982, found Feb. 24, 1982, Nampa. Her body, which had been sexually assaulted & beaten, was found in a shallow drainage ditch along the Snake River in Melba by a group of fishermen. Johnson sustained blunt force trauma to the head & torso, but ultimately died from drowning) - *David Allen Dalrymple (24 @ time of crime/62/now 65) charged (5/4/20) & formally charged & re-arraigned (10/27/22) with felony 1st degree murder & felony rape. Plead not guilty. No bond. DA will not seek DP.
Trial set to begin on 5/13/24.
Case & court info from 5/4/20 thru 3/6/24 reference post #131 here:
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/t...ered-1982-inmate-arrest-in-2020.520075/page-7
3/14/24 Update: Next evidentiary hearing Day 1 of 2 on 4/1/24 @ 9am. 4/1/24 Update: Evidentiary hearing continues on 4/4/24 @ 9am.
4/4/24 Update: No info on evidentiary hearing Day 2. Next pretrial conference on 4/10/24 @ 2:30pm.

 

[Niner]

@ReadySet - just checking to make sure his next hearing is on 5/3 & trial still on 5/13/24.
TIA!

 

[Niner]

@ReadySet - just checking to make sure his next hearing is on 5/3 & trial still on 5/13/24.
TIA!

Just bumping up for @ReadySet ! I moved my notes to 5/3 for the time being.

 

[JackieBrown]

Since LE said they do not believe his current charges are the extent of his criminality-

Do any of you veteran sleuthers know a way to find this guy‘s earliest mugshots? My searches come up empty.

I am curious about his duty station/armed forces service? The below indicates he was discharged in 1981.

'A decadeslong nightmare': 2C officials charge convicted sex offender in 9-year-old girl's 1982 death

CALDWELL — When Daralyn Johnson left her Nampa home to walk to Lincoln Elementary School a few blocks away on Feb. 21, 1982, she never made it to her destination.

www.idahopress.com

Any mentions of what did for work?

I am thinking of a particular unsolved case in another state and the striking resemblance of the earliest Dalyrmple mugshot in IdahoStatesman article, to a sketch of perp provided in the other case.

ETA: correct spelling, info on discharge

 

[ReadySet]

Since LE said they do not believe his current charges are the extent of his criminality-

Do any of you veteran sleuthers know a way to find this guy‘s earliest mugshots? My searches come up empty.

I am curious about his duty station/armed forces service? The below indicates he was discharged in 1981.

'A decadeslong nightmare': 2C officials charge convicted sex offender in 9-year-old girl's 1982 death

CALDWELL — When Daralyn Johnson left her Nampa home to walk to Lincoln Elementary School a few blocks away on Feb. 21, 1982, she never made it to her destination.

www.idahopress.com

Any mentions of what did for work?

I am thinking of a particular unsolved case in another state and the striking resemblance of the earliest Dalyrmple mugshot in IdahoStatesman article, to a sketch of perp provided in the other case.

ETA: correct spelling, info on discharge

It was not the suspect but his brother who was in the military.

Investigators were able to immediately eliminate the girls and then three of the four brothers, court records show. At the time of the crime, one of the boys was living in a different state and in the military, and the other two — 13 and 14 years old — were living in McCall and weren’t old enough to drive.
This led investigators to Dalrymple, who lived in Nampa when Johnson was killed. Court records show “the address was on the route (Johnson) would walk to school each morning.”

ETA: He said he was in the military, but that is not confirmed. He may have been lying. Or I guess he may have been in the military, but there is no info. I know of about that. I'm not sure of his work at the time.
ETA: Oh, his current charges are absolutely not the extent of his criminality. He is currently in prison on another conviction, he has a long history of sexual assault.

 

[ReadySet]

@Niner It looks like there have been a lot of motions; including for the jury to see the locations. I am not clear if that was denied or not. Niner, thanks again for all the time and work you put in to keep track of all the cases, especially old cases like this one. As I've said, this case is close to my heart as I have a bit of a connection . Thank you to everyone who is following and weighing in on this case. Justice for Daralyn!

04/10/2024 Pre-trial Conference
Original Type
Pre-trial Conference
Judicial Officer
Whitney, Thomas W.
Hearing Time
2:30 PM
Result
Hearing Held
Comment
In person - Motion for Jury to View Locations - Intent Rule 404(b) / Intent to Use Summary Evidence, Motion to continue JT,motion to shorten time,motion to issue subpoena, motion to seal States' Notice of intent to introduce evidence

• 04/10/2024 Order to Transport
  Judicial Officer
  Whitney, Thomas W.
  Comment
  Defendant
• 04/10/2024 Court Minutes
  Judicial Officer
  Whitney, Thomas W.
• 04/10/2024 Motion Granted
  Judicial Officer
  Whitney, Thomas W.
  Comment
  State's Motion for Jury to View Locations: Sites 1, 2, & 3; State's Motion to Issue Subpoena; State's Motion to Seal State's Notice of Intent to Introduce Evidence
• 04/10/2024 Motion Denied
  Judicial Officer
  Whitney, Thomas W.
  Comment
  State's Motion for Jury to View Locations: Site 4; Defense's Motion to Continue Jury Trial
• 04/10/2024 Objection
  Comment
  State's Objection and Brief in Opposition to Defendant's Motion to Suppress
• 04/11/2024 Affidavit in Support of Motion
  Comment
  in support of Motion to Suppress
• 04/11/2024 Motion to Compel
  Comment
  Discovery & Notice of Hearing
• 04/11/2024 Motion to Shorten Time
  Comment
  for Hearing & Notice of Hearing
• 04/11/2024 Affidavit in Support of Motion
  Comment
  to Suppress
• 04/12/2024 Motion to Suppress
  Original Type
  Motion to Suppress
  Judicial Officer
  Whitney, Thomas W.
  Hearing Time
  10:30 AM
  Result
  Hearing Held
  Comment
  in person
• 04/12/2024 Witness Disclosure
  Comment
  Amended Expert
• 04/12/2024 Affidavit in Support of Motion
  Comment
  to Suppress
• 04/12/2024 Court Minutes
  Judicial Officer
  Whitney, Thomas W.
• 04/12/2024 Exhibit List/Log
  Judicial Officer
  Whitney, Thomas W.
  Comment
  Defendant's
• 04/12/2024 Case Taken Under Advisement
  Judicial Officer
  Whitney, Thomas W.
  Comment
  Motion to Suppress
• 04/12/2024 Order
  Judicial Officer
  Whitney, Thomas W.
  Comment
  Findings and Order Regarding Touhy Request
• 04/16/2024 State's Supplemental Response to Request for Discovery
  Comment
  32nd
• 04/17/2024 Witness Disclosure
  Comment
  Expert - Amended
• 04/17/2024 Objection
  Comment
  to State's Notice of Intent Rule 404(b) Evidence
• 04/18/2024 Subpoena Issued
  Judicial Officer
  Whitney, Thomas W.
• 05/03/2024 Status Conference
  Judicial Officer
  Whitney, Thomas W.
  Hearing Time
  9:00 AM
• 05/13/2024 Jury Trial
  Judicial Officer
  Whitney, Thomas W.
  Hearing Time
  8:30 AM
  Cancel Reason
  Vacated
• 05/13/2024 Jury Trial
  Judicial Officer
  Whitney, Thomas W.
  Hearing Time
  8:30 AM

iCourt Portal - Online records & payments for the Idaho courts

mycourts.idaho.gov

 

[ReadySet]

@JackieBrown
Here are some more pictures of Dalrymple, including earlier pictures.
Also details some of his earlier crimes.

‘Terrorizing behavior’: Suspect in Idaho girl’s 1982 killing abused, victimized females - East Idaho News

 

[Niner]

@Niner It looks like there have been a lot of motions; including for the jury to see the locations. I am not clear if that was denied or not. Niner, thanks again for all the time and work you put in to keep track of all the cases, especially old cases like this one. As I've said, this case is close to my heart as I have a bit of a connection . Thank you to everyone who is following and weighing in on this case. Justice for Daralyn!

04/10/2024 Pre-trial Conference
Original Type
Pre-trial Conference
Judicial Officer
Whitney, Thomas W.
Hearing Time
2:30 PM
Result
Hearing Held
Comment
In person - Motion for Jury to View Locations - Intent Rule 404(b) / Intent to Use Summary Evidence, Motion to continue JT,motion to shorten time,motion to issue subpoena, motion to seal States' Notice of intent to introduce evidence

• 04/10/2024 Order to Transport
  Judicial Officer
  Whitney, Thomas W.
  Comment
  Defendant
• 04/10/2024 Court Minutes
  Judicial Officer
  Whitney, Thomas W.
• 04/10/2024 Motion Granted
  Judicial Officer
  Whitney, Thomas W.
  Comment
  State's Motion for Jury to View Locations: Sites 1, 2, & 3; State's Motion to Issue Subpoena; State's Motion to Seal State's Notice of Intent to Introduce Evidence
• 04/10/2024 Motion Denied
  Judicial Officer
  Whitney, Thomas W.
  Comment
  State's Motion for Jury to View Locations: Site 4; Defense's Motion to Continue Jury Trial
• 04/10/2024 Objection
  Comment
  State's Objection and Brief in Opposition to Defendant's Motion to Suppress
• 04/11/2024 Affidavit in Support of Motion
  Comment
  in support of Motion to Suppress
• 04/11/2024 Motion to Compel
  Comment
  Discovery & Notice of Hearing
• 04/11/2024 Motion to Shorten Time
  Comment
  for Hearing & Notice of Hearing
• 04/11/2024 Affidavit in Support of Motion
  Comment
  to Suppress
• 04/12/2024 Motion to Suppress
  Original Type
  Motion to Suppress
  Judicial Officer
  Whitney, Thomas W.
  Hearing Time
  10:30 AM
  Result
  Hearing Held
  Comment
  in person
• 04/12/2024 Witness Disclosure
  Comment
  Amended Expert
• 04/12/2024 Affidavit in Support of Motion
  Comment
  to Suppress
• 04/12/2024 Court Minutes
  Judicial Officer
  Whitney, Thomas W.
• 04/12/2024 Exhibit List/Log
  Judicial Officer
  Whitney, Thomas W.
  Comment
  Defendant's
• 04/12/2024 Case Taken Under Advisement
  Judicial Officer
  Whitney, Thomas W.
  Comment
  Motion to Suppress
• 04/12/2024 Order
  Judicial Officer
  Whitney, Thomas W.
  Comment
  Findings and Order Regarding Touhy Request
• 04/16/2024 State's Supplemental Response to Request for Discovery
  Comment
  32nd
• 04/17/2024 Witness Disclosure
  Comment
  Expert - Amended
• 04/17/2024 Objection
  Comment
  to State's Notice of Intent Rule 404(b) Evidence
• 04/18/2024 Subpoena Issued
  Judicial Officer
  Whitney, Thomas W.
• 05/03/2024 Status Conference
  Judicial Officer
  Whitney, Thomas W.
  Hearing Time
  9:00 AM
• 05/13/2024 Jury Trial
  Judicial Officer
  Whitney, Thomas W.
  Hearing Time
  8:30 AM
  Cancel Reason
  Vacated
• 05/13/2024 Jury Trial
  Judicial Officer
  Whitney, Thomas W.
  Hearing Time
  8:30 AM

iCourt Portal - Online records & payments for the Idaho courts

mycourts.idaho.gov

To me it does look like the Judge ruled:

04/10/2024 Motion Denied
Judicial Officer
Whitney, Thomas W.
Comment
State's Motion for Jury to View Locations: Site 4; Defense's Motion to Continue Jury Trial

from above. Denied the jury to view & motion to continue trial. I noticed that there are 2 entries for trial - one says vacated, but the next one is "a go".

Thank you for ALL that info! I shall update my notes & put him on 5/3/24.