For four weeks, everything is an argument, until March 1, 2010, when the defense has rested and the state has rested and everyones waiting for a verdict... After 15 hours of deliberation, they return a verdict. Tavon is guilty of reckless driving and engaging in a speed contest, they say. But on the eight counts of manslaughter, one for each person who died that night, nine jurors favor conviction, three dont. Mistrial.
The states attorneys, Ivey and Adams, make big statements that afternoon, saying theyll re-try the case vigorously again that fall, but they know that wont happen. They cant re-create a case like this. They cant re-create tears from some witnesses or catching others in a lie. They cant spend another month in court. They cant put people through that. They know theyll never get a full conviction.
The jurys message is this: Tavon was racing Darren that night, but he didnt hit anybody and probably isnt guilty of killing anyone. He won because he lost the race.