GUILTY MI - Emma Rose Bingaman, 2, died after torture & abuse, Mt. Morris Township, 30 July 2018

[Niner]

@misgrn - might be too early to ask for the next court date?

TIA if you find one!

 

[misgrn]

@misgrn - might be too early to ask for the next court date?

TIA if you find one!

For Destiny:
***MUST APPEAR IN COURT***
97 05/12/21 CRIMINAL PLEA HEARING
PROCEED DIGITAL RECORDED-DEF IN JAIL
APA POULOS, ATTY MAINPRIZE
HAJEK AND DEFT PRESENT. ATTY
MAINPRIZE HAJEK REQUESTED AN
ADJOURNMENT TO TALK TO DEFT
AGAIN. COURT GRANTED AND SET
NEW DATE(2 DAYS).
98 SET NEXT DATE FOR: 05/14/21 8:30 AM
CRIMINAL PLEA HEARING
............................... END OF SUMMARY .......................


For George:

PRE-TRIAL HEARING
89 05/12/21 PRE-TRIAL HEARING
PROCEED DIGITAL RECORDED-DEF IN JAIL
APA POULOS, ATTY EWING AND
DEFT(VIDEO) PRESENT. PARTIES
ARE READY TO PROCEED W/ A
TRIAL. COURT SET NEW PRETRIAL
DATE.
90 SET NEXT DATE FOR: 07/14/21 9:15 AM
PRE-TRIAL HEARING
............................... END OF SUMMARY .............................

http://www.co.genesee.mi.us/roaccsinq/default.aspx

Eta: I will check on the 14th for an update for Destiny.

 

[Niner]

Thanks @misgrn - looks like Destiny is going for plea deal.

 

[Niner]

Friday, Mary 14th:
*Plea Hearing (via Zoom) (@ 8:30am ET) – MI – Emma Rose Bingaman (2) (July 30, 2018, Mt. Morris Township; died from torture & abuse, weighed less than 10 lbs.) – only for *Destiny Danielle Bingaman (23/now 25) arrested (7/30/18), charged & arraigned (8/2/18) with 1st degree felony murder, 1st degree child abuse, torture & 2 counts of 1st degree child abuse committed in front of another child. Plead not guilty. Held without bail.
*George Bingaman (32/now 35) arrested (7/30/18), charged & arraigned (8/2/18) with 1st degree felony murder, 1st degree child abuse, torture & 2 counts of 1st degree child abuse committed in front of another child. Plead not guilty. Held without bail.
4 yr old girl & 1 yr old boy removed & placed in temporary foster care.
Jury trial was set to begin on 1/20/21-cancelled.
Court info from 5/6/19 thru 2/10/21 reference post #120 here:
MI - Emma Rose Bingaman, 2, died after torture & abuse, Mt. Morris Township, 30 July 2018
3/24/21 Update: Counsel may appear in court; defendants participated by Zoom. Proceed digital recorded-defendant in jail. APA Poulos & attorney Ewing by Zoom. Proceed with a trial due to COVID, no trials at this time. For both: Next pretrial hearing on 5/12/21.
5/12/21 Update: Destiny: Criminal plea hearing proceed digital records. Defendant in jail. APA Poulos, attorney Mainprize Hajek & defendant present. Attorney Hajek requested an adjourn to talk to defendant again. Court granted & set new date to 5/14/21 @ 8:30am. George: Defendant in jail. APA Poulos, attorney Ewing & defendant (via video) present. Parties are ready to proceed with a trial. Court set new pretrial hearing on 7/14/21 @ 9:15am.

 

[misgrn]

@Niner

For Destiny:

99 05/14/21 CRIMINAL PLEA HEARING
PROCEED DIGITAL RECORDED-DEF IN JAIL
APA POULOS, ATTY MAINPRIZE
HAJEK AND DEFT PRESENT. DEFT
HAS CHANGED HER MIND AND WANTS
TO WITHDRAW HER PLEA. PEOPLE
STATED THAT THE OFFER ENDS
TODAY IF PLEA WITHDRAWN.
COUNSEL WILL TALK TO DEFT
FURTHER TODAY AND ADVISE THE
COURT ON HOW TO PROCEED.
100 CRIMINAL PLEA HEARING
PROCEED DIGITAL RECORDED-DEF IN JAIL
BACK ON THE RECORD: APA JURVA
BRINN(FOR APA POULOS), ATTY
MAINPRIZE HAJEK PRESENT.
DEFT'S PRESENCE WAIVED. ATTY
MAINPRIZE HAJEK INFORMED THE
COURT THAT DEFT WITHDRAWS HER
PLEA. PARTIES REQUESTED THE
MATTER BE SET FOR PRETRIAL W/
CO-DEFT CASE. COURT GRANTED
AND SET NEW DATE.
101 SET NEXT DATE FOR: 07/14/21 9:15 AM
PRE-TRIAL HEARING

http://www.co.genesee.mi.us/roaccsinq/default.aspx

 

[Niner]

Thanks a bunch @misgrn ! Much appreciated!

 

[InspectorM]

Do cases like these usually take this long? This is the only case I've ever followed.

 

[Niner]

Do cases like these usually take this long? This is the only case I've ever followed.

I'd say yes - especially now with COVID they will probably take longer....

 

[Niner]

Wednesday, July 14th:
*Pretrial Hearing for both (@ 9:15am ET) – MI – Emma Rose Bingaman (2) (July 30, 2018, Mt. Morris Township; died from torture & abuse, weighed less than 10 lbs.) – *Destiny Danielle Bingaman (23/now 26) arrested (7/30/18), charged & arraigned (8/2/18) with 1st degree felony murder, 1st degree child abuse, torture & 2 counts of 1st degree child abuse committed in front of another child. Plead not guilty. Held without bail.
*George Bingaman (32/now 35) arrested (7/30/18), charged & arraigned (8/2/18) with 1st degree felony murder, 1st degree child abuse, torture & 2 counts of 1st degree child abuse committed in front of another child. Plead not guilty. Held without bail.
4 yr old girl & 1 yr old boy removed & placed in temporary foster care.
Jury trial was set to begin on 1/20/21-cancelled.
Court info from 5/6/19 thru 3/24/21 reference post #124 here:
MI - Emma Rose Bingaman, 2, died after torture & abuse, Mt. Morris Township, 30 July 2018
5/12/21 Update: Destiny: Criminal plea hearing proceed digital records. Defendant in jail. APA Poulos, attorney Mainprize Hajek & defendant present. Attorney Hajek requested an adjourn to talk to defendant again. Court granted & set new date to 5/14/21 @ 8:30am. George: Defendant in jail. APA Poulos, attorney Ewing & defendant (via video) present. Parties are ready to proceed with a trial. Court set new pretrial hearing on 7/14/21 @ 9:15am.
5/14/21 Update: Destiny: Criminal plea hearing. Proceed digital records; defendant in jail. Present: APA Poulos, attorney Mainprize Hajek & defendant present. Defendant has changed her mind & wants to withdraw her plea. State stated that the offer ends today if plea withdrawn. Counsel will talk to defendant further today & advise the Court on how to proceed. Back on record: APA Jurva Brinn (for APA Poulos). Attorney Hajek informed the Court that defendant withdraws her plea. Parties requested the matter to be set for pretrial with co-defendant's case. Court granted request. Next pretrial hearing on 7/14/21 @ 9:15am.

 

[Niner]

This was listed for George:

07/14/21 PRE-TRIAL HEARING
PROCEED DIGITAL RECORDED-DEF IN JAIL
ADJOURNED
APA LEGENDRE, ATTY EWING AND
DEFT PRESENT. COURT SET NEW
DATE.
95 SET NEXT DATE FOR: 07/21/21 12:00 PM
PRE-TRIAL HEARING
ADJ FROM 7/14



Destiny's was still showing 7/14

 

[Niner]

@misgrn - was just wondering if Destiny had a next court date yet? Maybe the same as George?

TIA!

 

[misgrn]

@misgrn - was just wondering if Destiny had a next court date yet? Maybe the same as George?

TIA!

This is the last update on Destiny sorry for not including it before:

CRIMINAL PLEA HEARING
PROCEED DIGITAL RECORDED-DEF IN JAIL
PLEAD GUILTY
MOTION BY APA POULOS TO AMEND
COUNT 1 TO 2ND DEGREE MURDER.
MOTION HEARD/GRANTED. PLEA:
GUILTY. PLEA AGREEMENT: DEFT
WILL PLEAD GUILTY TO COUNT 1
AS AMENDED. IN TURN, PEOPLE
WILL DISMISS COUNTS 2-5.
SENTENCE AGREEMENT: THE PEOPLE
DO NOT OBJECT TO THE COBBS
PROPOSAL FOR A 162 MONTH
MINIMUM SENTENCE. NO SENTENCE
ENHANCEMENT. NO CONSECUTIVE
SENTENCING. NO HYTA/7411.
RESTITUTION AS DETERMINED BY
COURT. COURT SET SENTENCE
DATE. COURT USES/ACCEPTS P.R.
AS FACTUAL BASIS.
104 00001 SET NEXT DATE FOR: 09/03/21 9:00 AM
SENTENCING
105 PLEA AGREEMENT FILED
106 ADVICE OF RIGHTS FILED
107 00002 CRIMINAL PLEA HEARING
PROCEED DIGITAL RECORDED-DEF IN JAIL
NOLLE PROSEQUI
108 00003 CRIMINAL PLEA HEARING
PROCEED DIGITAL RECORDED-DEF IN JAIL
NOLLE PROSEQUI
109 00004 CRIMINAL PLEA HEARING
PROCEED DIGITAL RECORDED-DEF IN JAIL
NOLLE PROSEQUI
110 00005 CRIMINAL PLEA HEARING
PROCEED DIGITAL RECORDED-DEF IN JAIL
NOLLE PROSEQUI
111 DEFT'S MOTION FOR ENTRY OF
PLEA PURSUANT TO COBBS
PROPOSAL FILED
112 06/30/21 REMOVE NEXT EVENT: 07/14/21 9:15 AM
PRE-TRIAL HEARING
113 MOTION/ORDER OF NOLLE PROSEQUI
(COUNT 2,3,4, AND 5) AND PROOF
OF SERVICE OF SAME FILED
............................... END OF SUMMARY

http://www.co.genesee.mi.us/roaccsinq/default.aspx

 

[Niner]

So - back on 5/14/21 she withdrew her guilty plea - and now again plead guilty... I hope she doesn't change her mind again!

Thank you for all that info @misgrn - much appreciated!

 

[Niner]

Wednesday, July 21st:
*Pretrial Hearing (@ 12pm ET) – MI – Emma Rose Bingaman (2) (July 30, 2018, Mt. Morris Township; died from torture & abuse, weighed less than 10 lbs.) – only for *George Bingaman (32/now 35) arrested (7/30/18), charged & arraigned (8/2/18) with 1st degree felony murder, 1st degree child abuse, torture & 2 counts of 1st degree child abuse committed in front of another child. Plead not guilty. Held without bail.
4 yr old girl & 1 yr old boy removed & placed in temporary foster care.
Jury trial was set to begin on 1/20/21-cancelled.
*Destiny Danielle Bingaman (23/now 26) arrested (7/30/18), charged & arraigned (8/2/18) with 1st degree felony murder, 1st degree child abuse, torture & 2 counts of 1st degree child abuse committed in front of another child. Plead not guilty. Held without bail.
Court info from 5/6/19 thru 5/12/21 reference post #129 here:
MI - Emma Rose Bingaman, 2, died after torture & abuse, Mt. Morris Township, 30 July 2018
5/14/21 Update: Destiny: Criminal plea hearing. Proceed digital records; defendant in jail. Present: APA Poulos, attorney Mainprize Hajek & defendant present. Defendant has changed her mind & wants to withdraw her plea. State stated that the offer ends today if plea withdrawn. Counsel will talk to defendant further today & advise the Court on how to proceed. Back on record: APA Jurva Brinn (for APA Poulos). Attorney Hajek informed the Court that defendant withdraws her plea. Parties requested the matter to be set for pretrial with co-defendant's case. Court granted request. Next pretrial hearing on 7/14/21 @ 9:15am. George: Pretrial hearing on 7/14/21.
6/30/21 Update: Destiny (again) plead guilty. Motion by APA Poulos to amend Count 1 to 2nd degree murder. Motion heard & granted. Defendant will plead guilty to Count 1 as amended. In turn, People will dismiss Counts 2-5. Sentence agreement: The People do not object to the Cobbs' proposal for a 162 month (13½ years) minimum sentence. No sentence enhancement, no consecutive sentencing, no HYTA/7411. Restitution as determined by the court. Court sets sentencing date on 9/3/21 @ 9am. 7/14/21 Update: George: Pretrial hearing rescheduled to 7/21/21.

 

[Niner]

@misgrn - just wondering if George has a next court date yet? I still get "access denied" trying to get into the court site...

TIA!

 

[misgrn]

@misgrn - just wondering if George has a next court date yet? I still get "access denied" trying to get into the court site...

TIA!

07/21/21 PRE-TRIAL HEARING
PROCEED DIGITAL RECORDED-DEF IN JAIL
APA SMITH, ATTY EWING AND DEFT
PRESENT. PARTIES HAVE REACHED
A PLEA DEAL. COUNSEL REQUESTED
PLEA HEARING DATE BE SET.
COURT SET HEARING DATE.
97 SET NEXT DATE FOR: 07/26/21

http://www.co.genesee.mi.us/roaccsinq/default.aspx

 

[Niner]

Thanks @misgrn !

 

[Niner]

Monday, July 26th:
*Plea Hearing (@ am ET) – MI – Emma Rose Bingaman (2) (July 30, 2018, Mt. Morris Township; died from torture & abuse, weighed less than 10 lbs.) – only for *George Bingaman (32/now 35) arrested (7/30/18), charged & arraigned (8/2/18) with 1st degree felony murder, 1st degree child abuse, torture & 2 counts of 1st degree child abuse committed in front of another child. Plead not guilty. Held without bail.
4 yr old girl & 1 yr old boy removed & placed in temporary foster care.
Jury trial was set to begin on 1/20/21-cancelled.
*Destiny Danielle Bingaman (23/now 26) arrested (7/30/18), charged & arraigned (8/2/18) with 1st degree felony murder, 1st degree child abuse, torture & 2 counts of 1st degree child abuse committed in front of another child. Plead not guilty. Held without bail.
Court info from 5/6/19 thru 5/14/21 reference post #134 here:
MI - Emma Rose Bingaman, 2, died after torture & abuse, Mt. Morris Township, 30 July 2018
6/30/21 Update: Destiny (again) plead guilty. Motion by APA Poulos to amend Count 1 to 2nd degree murder. Motion heard & granted. Defendant will plead guilty to Count 1 as amended. In turn, People will dismiss Counts 2-5. Sentence agreement: The People do not object to the Cobbs' proposal for a 162 month (13½ years) minimum sentence. No sentence enhancement, no consecutive sentencing, no HYTA/7411. Restitution as determined by the court. Court sets sentencing date on 9/3/21 @ 9am. 7/14/21 Update: George: Pretrial hearing rescheduled to 7/21/21.
7/21/21 Update: George: APA Smith, Attorney Ewing & defendant (in jail) are present. Parties have reached a peal deal. Counsel requested plea hearing date be set. Next plea hearing on 7/26/21.

 

[Niner]

Any word on George's plea hearing? I couldn't find anything...

TIA!

 

[misgrn]

I could find any updates either