It seems pretty evident to me that both girls met there that day with the intent of inflicting harm on the other. MD absolutely went too far in the moment, but that's what I believe it was, adrenaline in the moment and the determination to get things over with ASAP, and ensure that MD was the victor and Kaylee didn't gain the upperhand. I don't believe MD intended to cause Kaylee such harm, and by watching the video (which I have done more than once) I don't feel that MD even them realised the damage she had done and the seriousness of Kaylee's condition. She wasn't looking at Kaylee as she stepped over her.
I believe MD is remorseful. Explaining her reasons for being there and involved in the fight in the first place doesn't mean she isn't sorry for the outcome.
I don't think it's fair to paint MD as an out of control violent monster because of one horrific incident. As far as we know, and I wholeheartedly believe the press would've found and published any violent history or any trouble making behaviour rumours by now, MD has no questionable history, and everyone appears shocked that she was capable of such violence, and I'm willing to bet that MD herself could be included in that.
MOO.
This is perhaps the best summary of what I feel happened as well. Thanks for putting it in words.
The Juvenile Officer said much the same thing and then recommended MD be tried as a juvenile.
At first, I wanted MD tried as an adult, but that was when I only had that horrific video to go on. After I read that MD was actually a star pupil and that she'd felt bullied for the past few months, I started to see her more as a child (despite her large size) who felt backed into a corner.
Then, when I learned that KG had a history of similar conflicts, I started to wonder if I'd been hasty in immediately thinking MD was the sole aggressor and KG the only victim.
Now, I see both girls as victims of one sort or another.
Since MD didn't have a record or history of violence before this incident, I don't think locking her up can be considered the best solution. I think she needs to work on controlling her anger, and I'd prefer to see her sentenced to her sentenced to a few years of working with victims of abuse and violence.
I hope KG makes a full recovery, and it sounds as though she might, but I don't want to see her charged with anything. If this incident doesn't change her mindset, I fear nothing will. This was a hefty price to pay for foolhardy choices.
I hope this is also a wake-up call for those living in Hazelwood and similar high-crime communities. Parents -- teach your children well.