Do we even have hard evidence that Janelle and Mike were actually EVER with Susie and Stacy that night? Other than Janelle/Ms Kirby's testimony?
Here's what I've seen:
1) Janelle makes inconsistent statements about the arrival of Stacy/Susie to her house. First, in the June 19th News Leader she says that Stacy arrived first and that Susie was "late". Then in the 28th article, she says that Susie got there first and then Stacy arrived after. Not a big deal except that saying Susie had been "late" makes it seem too specific to suddenly forget a week later.
2) First public mention of the initial departure from the Kirby residence is in the Kansas City Star on June 9. Kathy Kirby says the girls left her house with Janelle around 9 and this is the last time she saw them. Doesn't mention Mike. Same with June 9th article in News Leader- 9 with Janelle, no mike. June 10th New Leader says same- Janelle, Stacy, Susie (no Mike) leave and walk to Joy party. When do we see Mike joining the walk to the Joy's? I still haven't found anything that says he's with them at this point but I would like to see the date this was first disclosed.
3) No one, to my knowledge, mentions Janelle or Mike in their recollections of events. Although Janelle says the two "never left her sight for more than a few minutes", Appleby doesn't mention either one of them, only that he talked to Susie while Stacy was talking to "other people." Then we hear the reverse from Michelle Elder, who says she talked awhile with Stacy while Susie was the one talking to others. Why does no one mention Janelle/Mike if they were all joined at the hip as JK says they were? Also, contrary to some of Janelle's early statements which seem to imply that the group all traveled between parties together, we know that Appleby makes it clear that only the two girls rode with him to from the Elder party and back to their cars. Who were Janelle/Mike riding with since they supposedly didn't have a car either? In a Jeep, you should be able to easily fit five....why weren't Jk/Mh in that car?
4) The final stop at the Kirby's is definitely where information starts getting super sketchy. Initial police report, when asked when they were last seen, Janelle and Mike first say "at a graduation party" then follow up with that they all went to Janelles. Why not just say Janelles? Also no mention by KK of hearing them outside. Wouldn't you chime in and say you heard them if police were asking? June 9 article in Kansas City Star says last seen at 2:00 leaving graduation party. Clear that at this point media hasn't talked to Appleby yet. No mention of Kirby house departure and 2:00 is the last time they were at the Joy house. Again, Kathy Kirby quoted in article but makes no mention of hearing the girls outside. June 9, News Leader article "last time Kathy Kirby saw Suzi and Stacy was at 9pm. Yet again, no mention of hearing them outside. Wouldn't any normal person when asked when they last saw someone mention if you heard them? Says they returned after 2am to get cars but doesn't specify who was with them. Now, on June 10th, the story begins to change. Whereas before, Kathy Kirby didn't hear anything and had not seen the girls since 9, all of a sudden the article in the News Leader says at around 2am "Kathy Kirby offers to let them spend the night but not wanting to impose they decline." So is she now suggesting she saw and talked to them at 2am? Or is she saying that when they left her house at 9 they already knew they weren't going to Branson? Fishy fishy fishy. Finally, around June 14th, KK decides to tell everyone that ACTUALLY, she heard Suzi and Stacy outside when they got back. Apparently she just remembered. Neat.
Again, the reason I'm going through all of this is because I think that KK/JK/MH aren't telling the whole truth. For the inconsistencies above, I would argue it's most likely that Janelle and Mike were shacking up somewhere and she didn't want word to get out about that- especially to Ms Mccall. I'm beginning to think that KK took Asher aside early on and "confided" their silly secret to him....perhaps he checked with the hotel, alibi checks out, but wink wink we're not going to tell anybody don't worry. The kids have been through enough. And here we have the head of M.A.D.D. with us too- their little girl Adina. These are good kids, nothing to see here folks. Which is why they were allowed to get away with so many discrepancies and why no one challenged them at all, even though their stories in hindsight seem wildly inaccurate and inconsistent.
If anyone has any additions or corrections to anything above, please feel free to let me know! It's hard to find a lot of the older articles, I know I'm missing a bunch.