GUILTY PA - Shauna Howe, 11, raped & murdered, Oil City, 27 Oct 1992

The two brothers – James and Timothy O’Brien – accused of murdering little Shauna Howe could have a verdict in their trial as early as next week.

Today the prosecution and defense rested. Final arguments start Monday, and then the fate of the O’Brien brothers is in the jury’s hands.

Tim and James O’ Brien are on trial for first-degree murder for allegedly kidnapping, raping and then murdering the Girl Scout.

But the defense claims Eldred “Ted” Walker is the real killer in the brutal crime.
http://kdka.com/local/local_story_295221349.html
 
THE DEFENSE RESTED ITS CASE AND THE PROSECUTION PROCEEDED TO CALL REBUTTAL WITNESSES TO THE STAND.
THE TESTIMONY JURORS HEARD REFUTED THE DEFENSE`S ARGUMENT THAT ELDRED TED WALKER - THE THIRD DEFENDANT IN THE CASE ACTED ALONE IN THE KIDNAPPING, RAPE AND MURDER OF 11-YEAR OLD SHAUNA HOWE.

HUNDERTMARK CLAIMED WALKER CARRIED THE GIRL`S BODY AROUND IN A CHEVY NOVA BEFORE DUMPING IT OFF THE BRIDGE AT COULTER`S HOLE.
FROM TIME TO TIME, THE JURORS HEARD ABOUT A CHEVY NOVA THAT WALKER ONCE OWNED BUT SOLD TO HIS SISTER-IN-LAW.
THIS WEEK SHE TESTIFIED THAT WHEN SHE RECEIVED THE CAR, THERE WAS A STRONG ODOR COMING FROM THE BACK THAT SMELLED AS IF SOMETHING DIED IN IT.
http://www.wjettv.com/news/default.asp?mode=shownews&id=5738
 
The attorneys for two brothers accused of abducting and killing an Oil City Girl Scout in 1992 used their closing arguments today to attack the credibility of the prosecution's main witness.

Hundertmark and James Goodwin, the attorney for Timothy O'Brien, both attacked Mr. Walker as a liar and pedophile. They honed in on numerous discrepancies among statements Mr. Walker gave authorities over the years and suggested he, not the O'Briens, was waiting for Shauna that night.

Mr. Goodwin also scoffed at testimony from jailhouse snitch Ryan Heath indicating Timothy O'Brien had told him he put Shauna in the car.
http://www.post-gazette.com/pg/05297/594229.stm
 
KDKA’s Don Cannon reports that the jury in the Shauna Howe murder trial was dismissed at 9 p.m. Tuesday night.

The jury will resume deliberations involving the case of the eleven-year-old Girl Scout from Oil City who disappeared on her way home from a Halloween party 13 years ago at 8:30 a.m.

The judge added third degree homicide as an option for the jurors. First and third degree murder charges had previously been the only two charges being considered.

After nine hours of deliberation, the jury in the case of two brothers accused of raping and killing Shauna Howe did not reach a decision Tuesday.
http://kdka.com/local/local_story_298223819.html
 
One day before the 13th anniversary of her abduction, a jury convicted James and Timothy O’Brien of five of the seven counts against them including second- and third-degree felony murder charges, involuntary sexual intercourse, kidnapping and conspiracy to kidnapping.

The brothers are now facing life in prison without the possibility of parole.
http://kdka.com/local/local_story_299171318.html
 
James O'Brien, 33, and his brother, Timothy, 39, both of Oil City, were found guilty of second-degree murder, third-degree murder, involuntary deviate sexual intercourse, kidnapping and criminal conspiracy to commit kidnapping. The brothers were acquitted of first-degree murder and rape.

The conviction of second-degree murder carries a mandatory penalty of life in prison without parole.

Shauna's mother, Lucy Howe Brown, wiped away tears, then was hugged from behind by her brother, Keith Sibble, when the verdict was read.

But the O'Brien brothers remained stonefaced. James O'Brien, who was smiling while the jury entered, stopped chewing gum briefly as he found out his fate.

"How do you explain people who just got convicted of murder-two and their face never changed?" Brown asked later.

Still, she expressed relief.
http://www.silive.com/newsflash/topstories/index.ssf?/base/news-31/1130377741165011.xml&storylist=
 
Here is the local news. I've been talking to family and friends in Oil City since last night and so many people are pleased with the verdict.

www.thederrick.com
 
Brothers guilty in killing of 11-year-old girl

Jury convicts pair in Oil City slaying

Thursday, October 27, 2005

By Cindi Lash, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette








FRANKLIN, Pa. -- One day shy of 13 years after Shauna Howe was snatched from an Oil City street, a Venango County jury convicted two brothers of kidnapping the 11-year-old girl, sexually assaulting her and throwing her off a railroad bridge to die. After deliberating for about 16 hours over two days, the jury yesterday found James and Timothy O'Brien guilty of second-degree murder and third-degree murder in the Oct. 27, 1992, kidnap-slaying of the Girl Scout.

Continue at link: http://www.postgazette.com/pg/05300/595683.stm
 
A man who pleaded guilty to his role in the kidnapping and murder of an 11-year-old Girl Scout wants to withdraw his plea and go to trial, now that his two accomplices were convicted of the crime.

Eldred "Ted" Walker, 46, filed a motion yesterday to withdraw his plea to third-degree murder and kidnapping, 13 years to the day after he abducted Shauna Howe from an Oil City street as part of what he thought was a prank with James and Timothy O'Brien.

Mr. Walker served as the star witness in the case against the O'Briens over the last three weeks in Venango County. The O'Briens were convicted Wednesday of kidnapping and killing the girl.

http://www.post-gazette.com/pg/05301/596642.stm
 
Detective Mom said:
Here is the local news. I've been talking to family and friends in Oil City since last night and so many people are pleased with the verdict.

www.thederrick.com

Looks like they might get a chance to go after the third guy.
 
Attorneys for two brothers convicted of murdering 11-year-old Shauna Howe in October 1992 intend to appeal their clients' convictions, according to motions filed in Venango County Court.



Attorneys for James O'Brien, 34, and Timothy O'Brien, 39, asked the court to provide transcripts from the jury trial last October. They want to review the full court proceedings to prepare to appeal the convictions, according to court papers.

More: http://www.thederrick.com/stories/01242006-2002.shtml

:mad:
 
Did Ted Walker ever go to trial? Why would he decide to withdraw his plea and go to trial instead? Does he think he will get less time if he goes to trial?
If so, I think he is in for a surprise. He is the jerk that grabbed that little girl off of the street. Hard to believe that he didn't rape her too as he was there. It was even at his house wasn't it?

In my opinion this guy is every bit as guilty as the other two. They were all in it together. They should all get the same sentence.
 
From today's Derrick:
"It was for their cruelty - for the life they took more than 13 years ago and the remorse they haven't shown in the years since - that Venango County Judge Oliver J. Lobaugh sentenced two brothers to spend the rest of their lives in prison Thursday.


"The world was a better place because of Shauna (Howe) and the world would be a much better place without you walking free ever again," Lobaugh told Timothy and James O'Brien in a calm, even voice.

The night Shauna attended a Girl Scout Halloween party at a home for the elderly on Oct. 27, 1992, the Oil City brothers were lurking, plotting, Lobaugh said. After grabbing her from the Oil City street corner on that autumn night, they subjected her to extreme acts of cruelty and violence before throwing her from a railroad trestle to die in the shallow creek below."

Snip
Timothy and James O'Brien were convicted by an Indiana County jury in October of kidnapping, sexually assaulting and killing 11-year-old Shauna in 1992, an act that, according to a third defendant in the case, was a Halloween prank gone wrong.

In addition to life sentences for second degree murder, Timothy O'Brien, 39, and James O'Brien, 34, were each ordered to serve 10 to 20 years for involuntary deviate sexual intercourse and 5 to 10 years for criminal conspiracy to commit kidnapping. The sentences in the Howe case are to run consecutively, and they will also run consecutively with sentences the brothers are already serving for other, unrelated crimes, Lobaugh said.

Both were also determined to be sexually violent predators under Megan's Law."

Snip
"Even as she left North Carolina to travel to Pennsylvania for Thursday's court date, Lucy Brown said she was calling the courthouse to make sure the sentencing was still on.

That the brothers will be behind bars for the rest of their lives is "wonderful," she said.

"They're gone and they're not coming back."

Although Lucy Brown and her family count the conviction and life sentences as a victory, more court dates still loom in the case.

Eldred "Ted" Walker, the third defendant who pleaded guilty in the case and testified against the O'Briens, asked the court to withdraw his guilty plea immediately after the O'Briens' trial. A ruling still hasn't been issued in the matter."

Snip
Last year, a softball tournament was held in Shauna's memory to raise money for her family to make the trip back to Pennsylvania to attend the trial.

Sibble plans to keep the softball tournament going to keep Shauna's memory alive and raise money for other families that may face similar financial struggles.

Also in attendance at Thursday's sentencing were four of the Indiana County jurors.

Although they declined to comment, one male juror said he and the others returned because they also sought closure."

http://thederrick.com/
 
OIL CITY, Pa. -- An Oil City man that pleaded guilty to third-degree murder and kidnapping for his role in the 1992 death of 11-year-old Shauna Howe was sentenced on Thursday.


A judge sentenced Ted Walker to 20 to 40 years in prison.


Walker abducted Howe and then turned her over to James and Timothy O'Brien

Both of the O'Brien brothers are serving life terms for Howe's murder.


Walker tried to withdraw his plea, but the judge would not accept it

http://www.thepittsburghchannel.com/news/10851967/detail.html
 
just watched a documentary===Cold Case Files --Little Girl Lost on this sad case...:rose:
 
I just watched Shauna's Story on Cold Case Files.... how sad that such evil exists. I'm glad these losers were finally found and held respnsible.
 
With any luck they are being “held responsible” every single day that they are in prison (by their new “prison boyfriends”, he-he-heh). Every “date” they have in prison helps to clean the spiritual slate of the universe.
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
55
Guests online
3,831
Total visitors
3,886

Forum statistics

Threads
592,621
Messages
17,972,058
Members
228,845
Latest member
butiwantedthatname
Back
Top