Total Sidebars for Trial

Discussion in 'Kathleen Savio' started by Niner, Aug 8, 2012.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. Niner

    Niner Long time Websleuther

    Messages:
    17,384
    Likes Received:
    7,743
    Trophy Points:
    113
    Here are the total Sidebars so far, and I will update these at the end of week for grand total for that week!

    1st Week:
    Tuesday, July 31st - 1
    Wednesday, August 1st - 2
    Thursday, August 2nd - 2
    Friday, August 3rd - 2
    Total for Week 1: 7

    When the second week ends I shall post those numbers!
     
  2. Loading...


  3. Niner

    Niner Long time Websleuther

    Messages:
    17,384
    Likes Received:
    7,743
    Trophy Points:
    113
    2nd Week Sidebars

    Tuesday, August 7th - 11

    Wednesday, August 8th - 13

    Thursday, August 9th - Defense: 4 / Prosecutors: 2 = 6

    Friday, August 10th - Defense: 16 / Prosecutors: 7 / Judge: 2 = 25

    Total for 2nd Week: 55

    Total for Trial: 62

    I've been asked to say 'who' asked for the Sidebar, so I shall go back to the first week and the first 2 days of this week - and will repost the totals.
     
  4. Niner

    Niner Long time Websleuther

    Messages:
    17,384
    Likes Received:
    7,743
    Trophy Points:
    113
    I had an error on a couple of days when I went back to count "who" asked for siddebars - a NEW total!!

    1st Week

    Tuesday, July 31st - Prosecutors: 1

    Wednesday, August 1st - Defense: 1 / Prosecutors: 1 // Total: 2

    Thursday, August 2nd - Defense: 1 / Judge: 1 // Total: 2

    Friday, August 3rd - Defense: 1 / Prosecutors: 1 // Total: 2

    1st Week Total: 7

    ***

    2nd Week

    Tuesday, August 7th - Defense: 7 / Prosecutors: 1 / Judge: 4 // Total: 12

    Wednesday, August 8th - Defense: 3 / Prosecutors: 8 / Judge: 3 // Total: 14

    Thursday, August 9th - Defense: 4 / Prosecutors: 2 // Total: 6

    Friday, August 10th - Defense: 16 / Prosecutors: 7 / Judge: 2 // Total: 25

    2nd Week Total: 57

    Total Sidebars: 64

    Defense: 33 / Prosecutors: 21 / Judge: 10
     
  5. dog.gone.cute

    dog.gone.cute Kyron Horman - Missing Since 6-4-10

    Messages:
    15,411
    Likes Received:
    2
    Trophy Points:
    38
    :gthanks: :

    WOW ! That's a lot of work, Niner !

    :tyou:
     
  6. Niner

    Niner Long time Websleuther

    Messages:
    17,384
    Likes Received:
    7,743
    Trophy Points:
    113
    3rd Week:

    Tuesday, August 14th: Defense - 2 / Prosecutors - 1 / Judge - 1 // Total = 4

    Wednesday, August 15th: Defense - 7 / Prosecutors - 2 / Judge - 4 // Total = 13

    Thursday, August 16th: Defense - 5 / Prosecutors - 8 / Judge - 5 // Total = 18
    Pop-tart Jurors: 6 times

    Friday, August 17th: Defense - 4 / Prosecutors - 2 / Judge - 6 // Total = 12
    Pop-tart Jurors: 4 times

    3rd Week Total: 47

    Total Sidesbars = 111

    Defense - 51 / Prosecutors - 34 / Judge - 26
     
  7. Niner

    Niner Long time Websleuther

    Messages:
    17,384
    Likes Received:
    7,743
    Trophy Points:
    113
    NEW totals - a member (katydid) asked for 'how many times the jurors were sent out - so I went back and counted them.

    1st Week

    Tuesday, July 31st - Prosecutors: 1 /
    Jurors out - 1

    Wednesday, August 1st - Defense: 1 / Prosecutors: 1 // Total: 2
    Jurors out - 2

    Thursday, August 2nd - Defense: 1 / Judge: 1 // Total: 2
    Jurors out - 7

    Friday, August 3rd - Defense: 1 / Prosecutors: 1 // Total: 2
    Jurors out - 3

    1st Week Total: 7

    Defense: 3 / Prosecutors: 3 / Judge: 1
    Jurors out: 13


    ***

    2nd Week

    Tuesday, August 7th - Defense: 7 / Prosecutors: 1 / Judge: 4 // Total: 12
    Jurors out - 6

    Wednesday, August 8th - Defense: 3 / Prosecutors: 8 / Judge: 3 // Total: 14
    Jurors out - 6

    Thursday, August 9th - Defense: 4 / Prosecutors: 2 // Total: 6
    Jurors out - 4

    Friday, August 10th - Defense: 16 / Prosecutors: 7 / Judge: 2 // Total: 25
    Juros out - 9

    2nd Week Total: 57
    Jurors out: 25


    Total Sidebars thru 2nd Week: 64

    Defense: 33 / Prosecutors: 21 / Judge: 10
    Pop-Tart Jurors: 38


    ***

    3rd Week:

    Tuesday, August 14th: Defense - 2 / Prosecutors - 1 / Judge - 1 // Total = 4
    Jurors out: 5

    Wednesday, August 15th: Defense - 7 / Prosecutors - 2 / Judge - 4 // Total = 13
    Jurors out: 8

    Thursday, August 16th: Defense - 5 / Prosecutors - 8 / Judge - 5 // Total = 18
    Pop-tart Jurors: 8 (this is a correction!)

    Friday, August 17th: Defense - 4 / Prosecutors - 2 / Judge - 6 // Total = 12
    Pop-tart Jurors: 5 (ditto, correction)

    3rd Week Total: 47
    Jurors out: 26


    Total Sidesbars thru Week 3 = 111

    Defense - 51 / Prosecutors - 34 / Judge - 26
    Pop-Tart Jurors: 64


    :dance:
     
  8. Niner

    Niner Long time Websleuther

    Messages:
    17,384
    Likes Received:
    7,743
    Trophy Points:
    113
    1st Week

    Tuesday, July 31st - Prosecutors: 1 /
    Jurors out - 1

    Wednesday, August 1st - Defense: 1 / Prosecutors: 1 // Total: 2
    Jurors out - 2

    Thursday, August 2nd - Defense: 1 / Judge: 1 // Total: 2
    Jurors out - 7

    Friday, August 3rd - Defense: 1 / Prosecutors: 1 // Total: 2
    Jurors out - 3

    1st Week Total: 7

    Defense: 3 / Prosecutors: 3 / Judge: 1
    Jurors out: 13


    ***

    2nd Week

    Tuesday, August 7th - Defense: 7 / Prosecutors: 1 / Judge: 4 // Total: 12
    Jurors out - 6

    Wednesday, August 8th - Defense: 3 / Prosecutors: 8 / Judge: 3 // Total: 14
    Jurors out - 6

    Thursday, August 9th - Defense: 4 / Prosecutors: 2 // Total: 6
    Jurors out - 4

    Friday, August 10th - Defense: 16 / Prosecutors: 7 / Judge: 2 // Total: 25
    Juros out - 9

    2nd Week Total: 57
    Jurors out: 25


    Total Sidebars thru 2nd Week: 64

    Defense: 33 / Prosecutors: 21 / Judge: 10
    Pop-Tart Jurors: 38


    ***

    3rd Week:

    Tuesday, August 14th: Defense - 2 / Prosecutors - 1 / Judge - 1 // Total = 4
    Jurors out: 5

    Wednesday, August 15th: Defense - 7 / Prosecutors - 2 / Judge - 4 // Total = 13
    Jurors out: 8

    Thursday, August 16th: Defense - 5 / Prosecutors - 8 / Judge - 5 // Total = 18
    Pop-tart Jurors: 8 (this is a correction!)

    Friday, August 17th: Defense - 4 / Prosecutors - 2 / Judge - 6 // Total = 12
    Pop-tart Jurors: 5 (ditto, correction)

    3rd Week Total: 47
    Jurors out: 26


    Total Sidesbars thru Week 3 = 111

    Defense - 51 / Prosecutors - 34 / Judge - 26
    Pop-Tart Jurors: 64


    ***

    4th Week

    Tuesday, August 21st: Defense - 8 / Prosecutors - 2 / Judge - 3 // Total = 13
    Pop-Tart Jurors: 5

    Wednesday, August 22nd: Defense - 6 / Prosecutors - 2 / Judge - 3 // Total = 11
    Pop-Tart Jurors: 4

    Thursday, August 23rd: Defense - 2 / Prosecutors - 1 / Judge - 2 // Total = 5
    Pop-Tart Jurors: 2

    Friday, August 24th: Defense - 0 (!!) / Prosecutors - 4 / Judge - 2 // Total = 6
    Pop-Tart Jurors: 2

    Total for 4th Week: 35
    Jurors out: 13


    Total Sidebars thru Week 4 = 146

    Defense - 67 / Prosecutors - 43 / Judge - 36
    Pop-Tart Jurors out: 77 times
     
  9. Niner

    Niner Long time Websleuther

    Messages:
    17,384
    Likes Received:
    7,743
    Trophy Points:
    113
    Day 1, Tuesday, July 31st - 1: Mary Pontarelli (neighbor of KS)
    Defense asks for Mistrial re hitman comment in State's OS

    Day 2, Wednesday, August 1st - 1: Thomas Pontarelli (neighbor of KS)
    Defense asks for Mistrial (#2) re .38 bullet comment

    Day 3, Thursday, August 2nd - 5: Louis Oleszkiewcz (EMT), Robert Akin (Locksmith), Michael Newton (BFD-in charge), Michael Johnson (BFD-paramedic),Timothy Berkeley (BFD/Paramedic). Note: Harry Smith, KS's attorney was called, but that was delayed.

    Day 4, Friday, August 3rd - 1: Anna Doman (KS's sister)

    Day 5, Tuesday, August 7th - 3: Michael VanOver (Dep. Coroner), Robert Deel (ISP Trooper), and James Coughlin (Lt. BPD). Note: Patrick Collins (Investigator) was bumped.

    Day 6, Wedneday, August 8th - 2: Patrick Collins (Reitred ISP Sgt) and Kristin Anderson (classmate of KS)

    Day 7, Thursday, August 9th - 1: Mary Parks (nursing school friend of KS)

    Day 8, Friday, August 10th - 4: Steve Maniaci (boyfriend of KS), Susan Doman (KS's sister), Susan McCauley (girlfriend of DP) and Dominick DeFrancesco (KS neighbor)
    Defense asks for Mistrial (#3) re prejudice on ??

    Day 9, Tuesday, August 14th - 2: Christopher Long (Forensic Toxicologist) and Teresa Kernc (former Sgt BPD)
    Defense asks for Mistrial (#4) re prejudice regarding Order of Protection mentioned

    Day 10, Wednesday, August 15th - 2: Teresa Kernc (former Sgt BPD) and Dr. Larry Blum (Forensic pathologist)

    Day 11, Thursday, August 16th - 1: Dr. Larry Blum

    Day 12, Friday, August 17th - 4: Dr. Gene Neri (KS's Dr), Scott Rosetto (SP's friend) asked to leave stand, Joseph Steadmann (Ins. Adjuster) and Jennifer Schoon (Steve Peterson's girlfriend)

    Day 13, Tuesday, August 21st - 1: Dr. mary Case (head trauma expert)

    Day 14, Wednesday, August 22nd - 4: Jeffrey Pachter (Hitman), Bryan Falat (ISP Master Sgt), Dr. Vinod Motiani (KS's personal physican) and Nicholas Ponarelli (KS's neighbor)

    Day 15, Thursday, August 23rd - 1: Pastor Neil Schori

    Day 16, Friday, August 24th - 2: Ray Clark (Sprint Record custodian) and Brian hafner (Lt BPD); Stipulation on Cassandra Cates testimony.

    Through 4 weeks of trial: 35 witnesses // Mistrial Requests: 4
     
  10. katydid23

    katydid23 Verified Juanette

    Messages:
    47,673
    Likes Received:
    2,281
    Trophy Points:
    113
    THANK YOU for posting the witness list. I really want to try and review and summarize what the jury has seen in this case so far.

    I have company here and I am in the kitchen waiting for the lasagna to finish baking. Everyone else is in the other room watching the Jets so I can peek in her a minute. :angel:
     
  11. Niner

    Niner Long time Websleuther

    Messages:
    17,384
    Likes Received:
    7,743
    Trophy Points:
    113
    Your quite welcome, katydid - anything to help!! :rocker:
     
  12. Niner

    Niner Long time Websleuther

    Messages:
    17,384
    Likes Received:
    7,743
    Trophy Points:
    113
    Day 1, Tuesday, July 31st - 1: Mary Pontarelli (neighbor of KS)
    Defense asks for Mistrial re hitman comment in State's OS

    Day 2, Wednesday, August 1st - 1: Thomas Pontarelli (neighbor of KS)
    Defense asks for Mistrial (#2) re .38 bullet comment

    Day 3, Thursday, August 2nd - 5: Louis Oleszkiewcz (EMT), Robert Akin (Locksmith), Michael Newton (BFD-in charge), Michael Johnson (BFD-paramedic),Timothy Berkeley (BFD/Paramedic). Note: Harry Smith, KS's attorney was called, but that was delayed.

    Day 4, Friday, August 3rd - 1: Anna Doman (KS's sister)

    Day 5, Tuesday, August 7th - 3: Michael VanOver (Dep. Coroner), Robert Deel (ISP Trooper), and James Coughlin (Lt. BPD). Note: Patrick Collins (Investigator) was bumped.

    Day 6, Wedneday, August 8th - 2: Patrick Collins (Reitred ISP Sgt) and Kristin Anderson (classmate of KS)

    Day 7, Thursday, August 9th - 1: Mary Parks (nursing school friend of KS)

    Day 8, Friday, August 10th - 4: Steve Maniaci (boyfriend of KS), Susan Doman (KS's sister), Susan McCauley (girlfriend of DP) and Dominick DeFrancesco (KS neighbor)
    Defense asks for Mistrial (#3) re prejudice on ??

    Day 9, Tuesday, August 14th - 2: Christopher Long (Forensic Toxicologist) and Teresa Kernc (former Sgt BPD)
    Defense asks for Mistrial (#4) re prejudice regarding Order of Protection mentioned

    Day 10, Wednesday, August 15th - 2: Teresa Kernc (former Sgt BPD) and Dr. Larry Blum (Forensic pathologist)

    Day 11, Thursday, August 16th - 1: Dr. Larry Blum

    Day 12, Friday, August 17th - 4: Dr. Gene Neri (KS's Dr), Scott Rosetto (SP's friend) asked to leave stand, Joseph Steadmann (Ins. Adjuster) and Jennifer Schoon (Steve Peterson's girlfriend)

    Day 13, Tuesday, August 21st - 1: Dr. mary Case (head trauma expert)

    Day 14, Wednesday, August 22nd - 4: Jeffrey Pachter (Hitman), Bryan Falat (ISP Master Sgt), Dr. Vinod Motiani (KS's personal physican) and Nicholas Ponarelli (KS's neighbor)

    Day 15, Thursday, August 23rd - 1: Pastor Neil Schori

    Day 16, Friday, August 24th - 2: Ray Clark (Sprint Record custodian) and Brian hafner (Lt BPD); Stipulation on Cassandra Cates testimony.

    Prosecutors rest

    Day 17, Monday, August 27th - 6: Mary Ponarelli (neighbor), Bryan Falat (ISP Master Sgt), Joseph Steadmann (Ins Adj.), Joseph Basile (FBI Spcl Agent-Chicago Office), Bob Sud (BPD) and Darrin Devine (ISP Spcl Agent)
    no: Harry Smith (yet!) or Thomas Peterson...

    Day 18, Tuesday, August 28th - 4: Dr. Jeffrey Jentzen (Forensic Pathologist), Dr. Vincent DiMaio (Forensic Pathologist), Robin Queen (ISP Special Agent), and Bridget Bertrand (ISP Captain).

    Day 19, Wednesday, August 29th - 4: Patrick Collins (ISP Sgt), Eileen Payona ( ISP Officer-Investigative Unit), Harry Smith (KS's divorce attorney) and Thomas Drew Peterson (KS & DP's son)

    Defense rests

    Through 5 weeks of trial: Prosecutors: 35 witnesses // Defense: 14 witnesses // Mistrial Requests: 4
    __________________
     
  13. Niner

    Niner Long time Websleuther

    Messages:
    17,384
    Likes Received:
    7,743
    Trophy Points:
    113
    1st Week

    Tuesday, July 31st - Prosecutors: 1 /
    Jurors out - 1

    Wednesday, August 1st - Defense: 1 / Prosecutors: 1 // Total: 2
    Jurors out - 2

    Thursday, August 2nd - Defense: 1 / Judge: 1 // Total: 2
    Jurors out - 7

    Friday, August 3rd - Defense: 1 / Prosecutors: 1 // Total: 2
    Jurors out - 3

    1st Week Total: 7

    Defense: 3 / Prosecutors: 3 / Judge: 1
    Jurors out: 13


    ***

    2nd Week

    Tuesday, August 7th - Defense: 7 / Prosecutors: 1 / Judge: 4 // Total: 12
    Jurors out - 6

    Wednesday, August 8th - Defense: 3 / Prosecutors: 8 / Judge: 3 // Total: 14
    Jurors out - 6

    Thursday, August 9th - Defense: 4 / Prosecutors: 2 // Total: 6
    Jurors out - 4

    Friday, August 10th - Defense: 16 / Prosecutors: 7 / Judge: 2 // Total: 25
    Jurors out - 9

    2nd Week Total: 57
    Jurors out: 25


    Total Sidebars thru 2nd Week: 64

    Defense: 33 / Prosecutors: 21 / Judge: 10
    Pop-Tart Jurors: 38


    ***

    3rd Week:

    Tuesday, August 14th: Defense - 2 / Prosecutors - 1 / Judge - 1 // Total = 4
    Jurors out: 5

    Wednesday, August 15th: Defense - 7 / Prosecutors - 2 / Judge - 4 // Total = 13
    Jurors out: 8

    Thursday, August 16th: Defense - 5 / Prosecutors - 8 / Judge - 5 // Total = 18
    Pop-tart Jurors: 8 (this is a correction!)

    Friday, August 17th: Defense - 4 / Prosecutors - 2 / Judge - 6 // Total = 12
    Pop-tart Jurors: 5 (ditto, correction)

    3rd Week Total: 47
    Jurors out: 26


    Total Sidesbars thru Week 3 = 111

    Defense - 51 / Prosecutors - 34 / Judge - 26
    Pop-Tart Jurors: 64


    ***

    4th Week

    Tuesday, August 21st: Defense - 8 / Prosecutors - 2 / Judge - 3 // Total = 13
    Pop-Tart Jurors: 5

    Wednesday, August 22nd: Defense - 6 / Prosecutors - 2 / Judge - 3 // Total = 11
    Pop-Tart Jurors: 4

    Thursday, August 23rd: Defense - 2 / Prosecutors - 1 / Judge - 2 // Total = 5
    Pop-Tart Jurors: 2

    Friday, August 24th: Defense - 0 (!!) / Prosecutors - 4 / Judge - 2 // Total = 6
    Pop-Tart Jurors: 2

    Total for 4th Week: 35
    Jurors out: 13


    Sidebars thru Week 4 = 146

    Defense - 67 / Prosecutors - 43 / Judge - 36
    Pop-Tart Jurors out: 77 times


    ***

    Week 5:
    Monday, August 27th: Defense - 4 / Prosecutors - 6 / Judge - 4 // Total: 14
    Jurors out: 5 times

    Tuesday, August 28th: Defense - 5 / Prosecutors - 5 / Judge - 3 // Total: 13
    Jurors out: 7 times

    Wednesday, August 29th: Defense - 5 / Prosecutors - 6 / Judge - 5 // Total: 16
    Jurors out: 7 times

    Total for Week 5: 43
    Jurors out: 19


    Grand total for trial = 189 Sidebars

    Defense - 81 / Prosecutors - 60 / Judge - 48
    Pop-tart Jurors out 96 times


    Defense wins on sidebars!! :fence:
     
  14. Niner

    Niner Long time Websleuther

    Messages:
    17,384
    Likes Received:
    7,743
    Trophy Points:
    113
    Through 5 weeks of trial: Prosecutors: 35 witnesses // Defense: 14 witnesses // Mistrial Requests: 4

    Day 20, Thursday, August 30th - Prosecutors' Rebuttal Witnesses: Dr. Michael Baden and Dr. Mary Case (both forensic pathologists)
     
  15. Niner

    Niner Long time Websleuther

    Messages:
    17,384
    Likes Received:
    7,743
    Trophy Points:
    113
    Grand total for trial: 189 Sidebars
    Defense - 81 / Prosecutors - 60 / Judge - 48
    Pop-tart Jurors out 96 times


    Rebuttal
    Day 20, Thursday, August 30th: Defense -7 / Prosecutors - 9 / Judge - 0 // Total: 16
    Jurors out: 5 times

    Total Sidebars for trial: 205

    Defense - 88 / Prosecutors - 69 / Judge - 48

    Pop-Tart Jurors out 101 times
     
  16. Niner

    Niner Long time Websleuther

    Messages:
    17,384
    Likes Received:
    7,743
    Trophy Points:
    113
    Prosecutors Closing - 1 hour 9 minutes

    Defense objected 6 times - all overruled

    ***

    Defense Closing - 2 hours 20 minutes

    Prosecutors objected 11 times / 1 - overruled / 5 - sustained / 5 - sidebars

    Judge - 1 sidebar

    Jurors out - 2 times
    ***

    Total Sidebars for trial: 211

    Defense - 88 / Prosecutors - 74 / Judge - 49

    Pop-Tart Jurors out 103 times
     
  17. Niner

    Niner Long time Websleuther

    Messages:
    17,384
    Likes Received:
    7,743
    Trophy Points:
    113
    Prosecutors Closing - 1 hour 9 minutes

    Defense objected 6 times - all overruled

    ***

    Defense Closing - 2 hours 20 minutes

    Prosecutors objected 11 times / 1 - overruled / 5 - sustained / 5 - sidebars

    Judge - 1 sidebar

    Jurors out - 2 times

    ***

    Prosecutors Rebuttal

    Defense - objected 14 times: 1 - overruled / 7 - sustained / 5 - sidebars

    Jurors out: 4 times
    ***

    Grand Total Sidebars for trial: 216

    Defense - 93 / Prosecutors - 74 / Judge - 49

    Pop-Tart Jurors out 107 times


    :woohoo: it's over!! The Defense wins with the Sidebars! :fence:
     
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page

  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice