I respectfully disagree. I think by saying "that day", he is talking about "that fateful day that Hailey went missing - THAT day", not "that day that DD came over and asked".
It doesn't bother me whether you agree or disagree, but I was not talking about what CD said, but what NS said. I was responding to TexasGiGi's post which said this:
Originally Posted by TexasGiGi
There was something in earlier posts, but I have no idea how to find it, that NS had originally said BD had stopped by for a minute on Monday and then changed her story.
In yesterday's interview, CD said that HD spent Saturday night at his house and the last time he saw her was about noon on Sunday.
NS said that after they told DD that HD had not been there that day (Monday)... then added on in the middle of her line of thinking, that she had originally thought that HD had been by that morning but then had remembered that it was the day before, which was Saturday. Then she finished saying that DD told his mom that they had never seen HD that day (Monday)
Hope I made sense.
IOW, what I was responding to was NOT what CD said, but what NS
said: they told DD (and we know that this is Tuesday) that HD had not been there that day. I think "that day" could mean, in the circumstances, either Monday or Tuesday (but not Saturday). NS said she originally thought HD had been by that morning. I think "that morning" could, in the circumstances, mean Monday or Tuesday (but not Saturday). NS said she then remembered that it was the day before. I think, in the circumstances, "the day before" could mean Monday (the day before the Tuesday conversation) or Sunday (the day before the disappearance), but not Saturday.
I am not the least bit suspicious of NS and am not pointing any fingers at her. For whatever reason, her recollections are not, in my opinion, reliable as to days of the week. And considering that BD got bashed repeatedly for making up a fairy story about NS first saying 'yes', and then saying 'no' to whether or not HD went to the house on Monday, when NS is 'clearly' stating that HD did not come over on Monday, this IMO is relevant.