Learn more about this case on DNASolves.

  • #1,061
Interesting....

A woman named Mary disappeared in September, 1996, in Washington State.

The sizes of the women are drastically different and Mary Hunter's story makes it highly unlikely they are the same person.


Just food for thought, bumping the thread, and likely eliminating a person that could be
This Mary only had scars around the breast area and no birthmarks documented. I’m clutching at straws with hope for solving this case, so I wish it was a match 😔
 
  • #1,062
Having Middle Eastern/Iranian ancestry doesn't automatically make someone an immigrant; she could easily be first- or second-generation. My DNA says I'm 50% English, but I don't have any immediate family from England.
 
  • #1,063
Having Middle Eastern/Iranian ancestry doesn't automatically make someone an immigrant; she could easily be first- or second-generation. My DNA says I'm 50% English, but I don't have any immediate family from England.
That is true, however there were virtually no Iranian immigrants to the US before the Iranian Revolution. So it is likely she was an immigrant. Given her age, she may have migrated as a young woman with a husband, which explains why she had no noticeable accent. That would also explain why noone was looking for her in the US. If most of her relatives stayed in Iran and she had no children and was estranged from her (ex) husband.
A second generation immigrant usually has local family.

jmoo
 
Last edited:
  • #1,064
That is true, however there were virtually no Iranian immigrants to the US before the Iranian Revolution. So it is likely she was an immigrant. Given her age, she may have migrated as a young woman with a husband, which explains why she had no noticeable accent. That would also explain why noone was looking for her in the US. If most of her relatives stayed in Iran and she had no children and was estranged from her (ex) husband.
A second generation immigrant usually has local family.

jmoo
There are Iranian/Persian related ethnic groups in what was the Soviet Union, in what now are independent countries near Iran. There is a small possibility that she might have come to the US as being 'Russian'.
 
  • #1,065
There are Iranian/Persian related ethnic groups in what was the Soviet Union, in what now are independent countries near Iran. There is a small possibility that she might have come to the US as being 'Russian'.
a bit of a long stretch, the soviet union was fairly closed off and one couldnt easily escape to the West, let alone the US. Not likely in my opinion
 
  • #1,066
a bit of a long stretch, the soviet union was fairly closed off and one couldnt easily escape to the West, let alone the US. Not likely in my opinion
Not really true, that was depending on what group a person belonged to, whether they were allowed to leave or not. The Jackson-Vanik amendment of 1974, between the US and Russia, is mostly associated with Soviet Jews, but it also included various ethnic and religious minorities, including Muslims, Christians, people who the Soviet Union saw as unwanted in their society.
While only about 3,000 Jews left legally between 1960 and 1970, roughly 347,100 people received visas to leave the USSR between 1971 and 1980
 
  • #1,067
Not sure if she's been mentioned already, but I came across Behdokht Behnia Pyke looking at another thread, she went missing in 1981 and was originally from Iran:


She's a poor match though. Too short (5'1-5'4 vs Mary's 5'8) and very light (110lbs to Mary's 240lbs). People can gain weight over years but she wouldn't have gotten taller! (Although height estimates have been wildly off before). They also don't look that similar imo, except maybe in the paler picture of her. But if you added 130lbs and 15 years to her... maybe? Behdokht would have been 44 in 1996. I've read elsewhere that she has DNA on file in CODIS though so probably already automatically excluded already. From the limited information I've found online, nobody is exactly sure of her missing date and it seems to me that a person close to her was probably responsible for her disappearance, but she could also have simply left.

None of her profiles (Namus, Charley) that I can find online mention that she's from Iran. I guess that's a reminder that there may be people who are in Namus who are Persian but are not reported as such, and are listed as white.
 
  • #1,068
None of her profiles (Namus, Charley) that I can find online mention that she's from Iran. I guess that's a reminder that there may be people who are in Namus who are Persian but are not reported as such, and are listed as white.
If you think that "white" only mean "Caucasian", that's not true, as this is how 'white' in the U.S. Census is defined:
  • U.S. Census/Technical Definition: The U.S. Census Bureau defines "White" as anyone having origins in Europe, the Middle East, or North Africa, which includes Iranians.
 
  • #1,069
What about Carole Dianne Roy?
- Missing the same day our Doe was found.
- Less weight (175), but weight is often wrong (old numbers/people lie about their weight)
- missing from Beckwith Township - Canada
- brown hair brown eyes
- 43 years old
- used the aliases of Carole Lalonde and Dianne Davis.

The websleuths page mentions : partial dental plate

Carole Dianne Roy was reported missing to the OPP on May 23, 2012. Through OPP investigation it was established that the last confirmed sighting for Roy was on Oct. 11, 1996.


 

Attachments

  • IMG_0528.webp
    IMG_0528.webp
    32.1 KB · Views: 12
  • IMG_0531.webp
    IMG_0531.webp
    20.9 KB · Views: 11
  • #1,070
If you think that "white" only mean "Caucasian", that's not true, as this is how 'white' in the U.S. Census is defined:
I know, I just thought it was worth noting :)
 
  • #1,071
What about Carole Dianne Roy?
- Missing the same day our Doe was found.
- Less weight (175), but weight is often wrong (old numbers/people lie about their weight)
- missing from Beckwith Township - Canada
- brown hair brown eyes
- 43 years old
- used the aliases of Carole Lalonde and Dianne Davis.

The websleuths page mentions : partial dental plate

Carole Dianne Roy was reported missing to the OPP on May 23, 2012. Through OPP investigation it was established that the last confirmed sighting for Roy was on Oct. 11, 1996.


Can't be Carole unfortunately unless she was of Persian ancestry, which doesn't seem to be the case
 
  • #1,072
What about Carole Dianne Roy?
- Missing the same day our Doe was found.
- Less weight (175), but weight is often wrong (old numbers/people lie about their weight)
- missing from Beckwith Township - Canada
- brown hair brown eyes
- 43 years old
- used the aliases of Carole Lalonde and Dianne Davis.

The websleuths page mentions : partial dental plate

Carole Dianne Roy was reported missing to the OPP on May 23, 2012. Through OPP investigation it was established that the last confirmed sighting for Roy was on Oct. 11, 1996.


Sex is listed as “Male” but there are several references to her as “she” so I am guessing it is either a typo or possibly she is transgender?
 
  • #1,073
Sex is listed as “Male” but there are several references to her as “she” so I am guessing it is either a typo or possibly she is transgender?
I think it’s a mistake. I haven’t found any mentions of transgender or some other possibilities than just a born & living woman. (Sorry if i don’t type this the right/most respectfull way, English is only my 3th language)

“She is described as a Caucasian female”

 

Guardians Monthly Goal

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
121
Guests online
2,141
Total visitors
2,262

Forum statistics

Threads
645,763
Messages
18,847,861
Members
245,787
Latest member
Monkey2
Top