I spend a lot of time studying DocG theory. DocG is very intelligent and talented writer. He, like majority of us, strongly believes in his own theory. He has invested a lot of time and analytical deduction (some of them are brilliant!) in support of his theory and I'm full heartily applaud him for doing it. But, IMHO his theory has a lot of holes. Here is the list of the holes
based on my opinion and known facts:
- If JR original plan was to get rid of the JBR body then what was the purpose to wipe her off and redress?
- If JR was the child molester then how this decease starts and stops? Yes, child molestation is a decease which cannot be controlled by molester. Child molestation performed by man 40 and older is NOT one-time/one-child occurrence;
- If JR has wrote RN for the purpose to gain control of the time (dealing himself with 'kidnappers' without Patsy and Burke presence, scare Patsy to NOT call the police) then why write such a silly, long, not-convincing, not-scary assay? It didn't scare Patsy, right? She make 911 call anyway. It didn't scare anyone who did read this RN: even his own son (JAR) and JR friends were surprised of how stupid and childish this RN sounds. Forget about FBI! JR is smart, ruthless and coward man. And if he wanted to gain CONTROL - he knows how to do it. Regardless of the handwriting - RN was written in NOT JR style!;
- Now, the most important part. As the fact, the time of JBR death (based on 'pineapple', rigor mortis and more) is between 11pm-1:00am. For the sake of the argument, let's say JBR death from strangulation happens at 1:00am on December 26. Based on Kolar book, the time between head blow and strangulation takes almost 1 1/2 hours. Again, for the sake of the argument, let's say 1 hour. So, JBR ordeal starts around midnight, correct? Patsy finds RN and called 911 at 5:52am. Means, JR has almost 6 hours (!!!!) to create his 'kidnapping' plan and perform the staging. In another word, to get control of the situation to achieve his main goal: GET RID OF JBR BODY. Please tell me, which part of the 'staging' or facts/evidences points to preparation to 'get rid of the body'? Please don't forget, JR has 6 hours to be ready! Did he placed the body inside of his car trunk or somekind of suitcase? Does JBR body was wrapped in the carpet ready to be transferred? No! Her body was nicely covered in HER blanket, with HER nightgown, with HER doll, cleaned and redressed! Such a lovely gesture's prior to trough-out/get rid of your own daughter body
???!!! I don't think so...I cannot see how JR would be able to get rid of the body without be cought by FBI and police later on, right away. His car fibers would be all over JBR blanket, JR driving activities would be traced right away. So, the whole DocG theory toward JR plan to get rid of JBR body - holds no water for me.
Otherwise, I like DocG analysis of the broken window and I LOVE his passion
...