2011.05.16 Sidebar Thread (Juror Selection Day Seven)

[RR0004]

So all these folks who received jury duty notices- what 2 weeks ago- still have to make themselves available? That's insane.

[katydid23]

Originally Posted by Melanie

Can he do that? Both sides still have strikes, so I would assume they could boot her. I thought that was the law?

It's been a long day though, so anything is possible.

Mel

The state already tried using their preemptive strike against her, and it was denied by the judge because the defense claimed it was because of 'race' that they wanted to strike.
So at this time the state CANNOT strike her off the panel. The defense could I suppose, but they won't. So she is in. [ UNLESS new 'evidence' comes in like she was tweeting or something since then.]

[LyndyLoo]

Originally Posted by RR0004

How many prospective jurors did they get to today?

17 total..plus whatever they accept during morning voir dire....then they get into striking after lunch....I only know their are a few defense dosent want and a few the state doesnt want....so we will see tomorrow...

[xin]

Originally Posted by katydid23

The state already tried using their preemptive strike against her, and it was denied by the judge because the defense claimed it was because of 'race' that they wanted to strike.
So at this time the state CANNOT strike her off the panel. The defense could I suppose, but they won't. So she is in. [ UNLESS new 'evidence' comes in like she was tweeting or something since then.]

She may have a problem that gets her excused later. Just sayin' -- she's my bet for an alternate replacement if we are playing that.

[nursebeeme]

Originally Posted by RR0004

So all these folks who received jury duty notices- what 2 weeks ago- still have to make themselves available? That's insane.

yes! there are at least iirc 20 some left that have not been questioned (however it seems they are not sitting all day... they are called in small clusters of 3-4 for either morning or afternoon session now)

although that being said the questioning seems to have been somewhat shortened by both sides... keeping each one around an hour (first one was like four hours!!!!)

I am soooo curious to see how many they strike after all this hard work. I hope both sides think long and hard and are not too over zealous...

[xin]

Originally Posted by Melanie

Boy do I wish we had a witness list -- in order. I assume after opening, the state will start with the parents. Oh joy! MOO

Mel

Cops. My guess is they start with the cops. Mellich is gonna be great. It'll be the cop that responded to Cindy's call--perhaps.

[LambChop]

Originally Posted by Melanie

Can he do that? Both sides still have strikes, so I would assume they could boot her. I thought that was the law?

It's been a long day though, so anything is possible.

Mel

Yes he can. He's the judge and he made the decision that she was to stay because of the way the State objected. It's final, she stays.

[nursebeeme]

Originally Posted by xin

She may have a problem that gets her excused later. Just sayin' -- she's my bet for an alternate replacement if we are playing that.

she is currently in the 8th seat.....

[gmt]

I think it was right before lunch.

[Melanie]

There are two types of ways a juror can wind up not being on a jury. He or she can either be struck for Cause, or be struck by a Peremptory Strike.

A Peremptory Strike is one that can be used for virtually any reason at all. One of the lawyers may not like a potential juror’s level of enthusiasm. They may not like the potential juror’s hair, eye contact, fashion sense, etc. As long as a Peremptory Strike is not based on race, religion, or gender, etc., the striking attorney can use it however they see fit.

In a Felony jury trial, each side gets 10 peremptory strikes a piece.

[sleutherontheside]

I'd like to take a moment to say thank you to all my WS friends. I have been glued to jury selection this week (much to the dismay of family) and have so enjoyed the sense of family on the daily hearing threads.

I have had the pleasure of meeting another WS member in person, and have had an opportunity to talk to several others directly. I hope that at some point I am able to meet more of you.

Never in a million years would I have imagined that following this case would afford an opportunity to "meet" so many from so many corners of this earth.

I wince as I hear the DT use the term bloggers (because that is an incorrect categorization at best) because I have seen bloggers ....nope not us.

I have seen other forums... and their grade school drama and x-rated insults.

I have seen attention hounds, 15 minutes of fame seekers, and other general types.

I remember about a year ago......some folks left.....and some just wouldn't leave but what we have today is nothing short of a family.

There are some folks that I'd love to see pop by again.....but all in all....I feel like I am sitting in my living room having a grand old time.

This case drew me in because I am a parent and was on my way through Orlando on my way to vacation when the story broke....

Early on the sleuthing kept me interested...later with discovery I enjoyed cross referencing stories and reports....now I enjoy seeing the legal process in action.

Justice for Caylee??? YES, I can't wait to see it.

In the meantime.....being with friends is a good substitute.

THank you for being such a varied, crazy, organized, intelligent, polite, energizing, and fun group.

CM may not be having fun yet...but I sure am.

SOTS

[RR0004]

Originally Posted by LyndyLoo

17 total..plus whatever they accept during morning voir dire....then they get into striking after lunch....I only know their are a few defense dosent want and a few the state doesnt want....so we will see tomorrow...

Thanks...what I should have said was...how many were interviewed today? Is 3 to 4 potential jurors realistic for tomorrow...and all the backstriking? Trying to figure out if trial will really be starting on Thurs.

[MissJames]

Originally Posted by Melanie

Thank U so much. I thought it would be cool to put my headphones on and lie down in bed -- NOT. I think I was snoring within 3 seconds. Hubby better show up with that cable that hooks the pooter to the TV cuz I can't sit in a chair all day - LOL.

Anyway, I pray we get the 8 alternates, because I really think we're gonna need em.

Who wants to guess JB uses all his strikes tomorrow just as a stall tactic?

MOO

Mel

I have been dreaming of getting a Tempurpedic Ergo bed (moves like a hospital bed) to watch the trial.Problem is ,I don't think I'd ever get up!

I am so wiped out watching this jury selection that I have to give Kudos to all the attorneys and Judges who do this every day!
It's intense!

[RR0004]

Originally Posted by sleutherontheside

I'd like to take a moment to say thank you to all my WS friends. I have been glued to jury selection this week (much to the dismay of family) and have so enjoyed the sense of family on the daily hearing threads.

I have had the pleasure of meeting another WS member in person, and have had an opportunity to talk to several others directly. I hope that at some point I am able to meet more of you.

Never in a million years would I have imagined that following this case would afford an opportunity to "meet" so many from so many corners of this earth.

I wince as I hear the DT use the term bloggers (because that is an incorrect categorization at best) because I have seen bloggers ....nope not us.

I have seen other forums... and their grade school drama and x-rated insults.

I have seen attention hounds, 15 minutes of fame seekers, and other general types.

I remember about a year ago......some folks left.....and some just wouldn't leave but what we have today is nothing short of a family.

There are some folks that I'd love to see pop by again.....but all in all....I feel like I am sitting in my living room having a grand old time.

This case drew me in because I am a parent and was on my way through Orlando on my way to vacation when the story broke....

Early on the sleuthing kept me interested...later with discovery I enjoyed cross referencing stories and reports....now I enjoy seeing the legal process in action.

Justice for Caylee??? YES, I can't wait to see it.

In the meantime.....being with friends is a good substitute.

THank you for being such a varied, crazy, organized, intelligent, polite, energizing, and fun group.

CM may not be having fun yet...but I sure am.

SOTS

Oh, SOTS...that's so sweet!!!!!!!!!!
Thank you!

[Melanie]

Originally Posted by katydid23

The state already tried using their preemptive strike against her, and it was denied by the judge because the defense claimed it was because of 'race' that they wanted to strike.
So at this time the state CANNOT strike her off the panel. The defense could I suppose, but they won't. So she is in. [ UNLESS new 'evidence' comes in like she was tweeting or something since then.]

Ohhhhh - gotcha. So they can't strike twice. Makes sense. Boy I'm learning a lot about this jury selection prcoess.

Hugs,

Mel

[QueenD]

I enjoy seeing your posts everyday SOTS. You cracked me up with your pictures. Thank you and everyone else who post everyday as to what is going on. Sometimes this case losing me and with your posts and others help me back on track.

Except when I get lost on that magic carpet ride. LOL. Thanks everyone.

[zoey]

Originally Posted by sleutherontheside

I'd like to take a moment to say thank you to all my WS friends. I have been glued to jury selection this week (much to the dismay of family) and have so enjoyed the sense of family on the daily hearing threads.

I have had the pleasure of meeting another WS member in person, and have had an opportunity to talk to several others directly. I hope that at some point I am able to meet more of you.

Never in a million years would I have imagined that following this case would afford an opportunity to "meet" so many from so many corners of this earth.

I wince as I hear the DT use the term bloggers (because that is an incorrect categorization at best) because I have seen bloggers ....nope not us.

I have seen other forums... and their grade school drama and x-rated insults.

I have seen attention hounds, 15 minutes of fame seekers, and other general types.

I remember about a year ago......some folks left.....and some just wouldn't leave but what we have today is nothing short of a family.

There are some folks that I'd love to see pop by again.....but all in all....I feel like I am sitting in my living room having a grand old time.

This case drew me in because I am a parent and was on my way through Orlando on my way to vacation when the story broke....

Early on the sleuthing kept me interested...later with discovery I enjoyed cross referencing stories and reports....now I enjoy seeing the legal process in action.

Justice for Caylee??? YES, I can't wait to see it.

In the meantime.....being with friends is a good substitute.

THank you for being such a varied, crazy, organized, intelligent, polite, energizing, and fun group.

CM may not be having fun yet...but I sure am.

SOTS

Back at you!!!

[RR0004]

Originally Posted by xin

Cops. My guess is they start with the cops. Mellich is gonna be great. It'll be the cop that responded to Cindy's call--perhaps.

I think when YM walks in to court the gallery should give him a standing ovation. Heck...they should applaud every single last member of LE that was involved in this case.

[logicalgirl]

Originally Posted by AliGirl

Yes, I saw it. It was this afternoon, I just don't remember when exactly. I remember, because it's the first time I've seen her talk to him lately, and not throw a fit!

right after the court recessed for the day. ICA swanned by but JB didn't even look at her - too busy sparring with LDB. Oops I just realized you were probably talking about ICA....

[sleutherontheside]

Originally Posted by QueenD

I enjoy seeing your posts everyday SOTS. You cracked me up with your pictures. Thank you and everyone else who post everyday as to what is going on. Sometimes this case losing me and with your posts and others help me back on track.

Except when I get lost on that magic carpet ride. LOL. Thanks everyone.

I don't get lost on the magic carpet ride but I sure get knocked over by the door hitting my azz often enough. Note to self...buy knee pads and helmet.

[MissJames]

Originally Posted by RR0004

So all these folks who received jury duty notices- what 2 weeks ago- still have to make themselves available? That's insane.

Nothing in this case has been normal. Nothing.

We are charting new territory and so is the Court.

[AsoldiersGrits]

Originally Posted by Melanie

Thank U so much. I thought it would be cool to put my headphones on and lie down in bed -- NOT. I think I was snoring within 3 seconds. Hubby better show up with that cable that hooks the pooter to the TV cuz I can't sit in a chair all day - LOL.

Anyway, I pray we get the 8 alternates, because I really think we're gonna need em.

Who wants to guess JB uses all his strikes tomorrow just as a stall tactic?

MOO

Mel

bbm

Why didnt I think of that??? LOL
off to the store I...err the hubby goes

[Melanie]

Dear sleutherontheside,

Just wanted to say thank you for such a heart-warming post. Yes, we can get testy at times, but we always come together for the good. I, too, consider you all family! And I know that together we can all get through this case without having ending up in a padded cell or rehab

Luv n' hugs,

Mel

[KMouse]

Just before opening arguements start let us all gather together in a moment of silence or prayer (whatever you choose), figuratively join hands, and think of little Caylee and the quest for justice. Light a candle if that works for you. Whatever you choose, let us do it together as Caylee's extended family.

We are here for her and we are here to watch justice be served for the monster that took her life without regret.

[zoey]

Originally Posted by xin

Cops. My guess is they start with the cops. Mellich is gonna be great. It'll be the cop that responded to Cindy's call--perhaps.

Cindy and then the cops....That is of course after the aaahaaa opening jb will give and since that will answer it all....might as well cancel the trial....