TX TX - Virginia Carpenter, 21, Denton, 1948

Its been a while that this thread was used.

But my 2 cents, what I find very suspicious is the role of the taxidriver, Edgar Ray Zachary, he was the last one seeing her. Dont get me wrong, I mean the guy is dead so I dont want to blame anybody till its proved that they did it indeed or till the day God judges this world and it will be known who the killer was if she was killed ofcourse.

But the taxidriver was accused of attempting for raping a girl years afther Virginia got missing. In fact, there is an newsarticle about it in the Abilene reporter news paper of Texas. On page 15 of august 20, 1957, for those with an account on websites containing historical newspapers you can search it up yourself. Or use google for an other newspaper also mentioning this case: https://news.google.com/newspapers?...AIBAJ&sjid=JVYDAAAAIBAJ&pg=3745,5189669&hl=nl
The taxidriver was also been in and out of trouble with the law years before Virginia got missing.

There is an book written by an old texas ranger Private that investigated the Viriginia Carpenter case, the book is called
In the Line of Duty: Reflections of a Texas Ranger Private. You can see parts of the book trough google books, from page 82 till 89 you can read about this case. And also the mentioning of the attemted rape of the taxidriver and that the police thought the taxidriver was the main suspect for while. He past an polygraph test.


The taxidriver had an alibi, his wife told the police that he came home arround 10:00 p:m. But years later I found that she stated that she had lied about this and the her husband came home late in the night. I only found this on an website containing some info about this case.

So all clews are pointing in my opinion to the last person that saw her alive. But stil never convicted so only God knows.

Interestingly, the lead investigator of the time, Lewis C. Rigler, finally believed that Virginia ran away to start a new life for herself. I'm not sure how he arrived at that conclusion, as there was no evidence for it and every reason to suspect foul play. Perhaps it was just his way of dealing with the fact they never found out what happened to her.

Anyway, I agree with you. The taxi driver was the last confirmed witness to see Virginia, he was later accused of sexually assaulting another young woman, and apparently he was known to abuse his wife and kids. Not to mention his decision to leave Virginia's trunk on the lawn instead of delivering it to her dorm is very suspicious.
 
https://www.peoplemagazine.co.za/real-people/real-stories/true-crime-missing-virginia-carpenter/

By Walton Golightly

On June 1, 1948, Virginia Carpenter 21, travelled by train from Texarkana to the Texas State College For Women in Denton to begin classes. Taxi driver Edgar Zachary dropped her off at her college residence at 17h30. Two men in a cream-coloured convertible – one tall, the other short and stocky – called out to Virginia. According to Zachery, she responded by saying, “Well, what y’all doing over here?”
Because one of her trunks had yet to arrive, Virginia paid Zachary a dollar to fetch it from the train station the following morning. The two men would help her with the luggage she had with her, she added. Zachary drove off. The following morning, he dropped off the trunk at Brackenridge Hall, but Virginia was missing – she hadn’t even checked into the residence yet.
In the months following Virginia’s disappearance numerous sightings of the young woman poured in from south Texas to Louisiana and Arkansas.
“One report from a ticket agent in DeQueen, Arkansas is particularly compelling,” says crime writer Stephanie Weber. He claimed that on the night of Friday, June 11, a young woman matching Virginia’s description climbed off a bus from Texarkana and found a seat in the bus terminal lobby.


About 10 minutes later, a man in his mid-20s with light brown hair arrived, and the two vanished into the night. Not long afterwards, the agent received a phone call from a female caller. She wanted to know if Miss Virginia Carpenter happened to be at the station.
 
I can think of an additional reason to suspect Zachary:

- In addition to being a cab driver, wife beater and sexual assailant, Zachary was also a mechanic and an auto trader. Yet, he could only describe a claimed sighting of an unusual nice car in very general terms as a "cream colored convertible"- or was it yellow? He appears to have given to different color descriptions. This and his inability give the general make of the convertible does not seem very likely given his auto interests.

But, his ex wife's claims also seem strange:

- Zachary was described as being badly educated. He was probably functionally illiterate or perhaps even completely illiterate. Yet, his wife describes him knowing that the Denton paper carried articles about the case and then driving hours to buy a paper that he probably could not fully read. This is in contrast to most murderers of his education who follow the "out of sight, out of mind" philosophy regarding crime. No arrest and a move to Midland put Zachary way "out of sight".

Even considering that "un-educated" does not always mean "un-intelligent", especially in earlier generations, the Texas Ranger does not describe Zachary as being quick witted. Rather, he points out that he was uneducated. This could imply a fairly simple individual and not likely to read a lot of papers, nor be concerned about their contents.

Perhaps she was changing her story as way to incriminate her husband for the years of abuse?
 
Last edited:
VCarpenter.jpg
VCarpenter1.jpg


Name: Mary Virginia Carpenter
Case Classification: Endangered Missing
Missing Since: June 1, 1948
Location Last Seen: Denton, Denton County, Texas

Physical Description
Date of Birth: January 25, 1927
Age: 21 yrs old
Race: White
Gender: Female
Height: 5'3"
Weight: 120 lbs
Hair Color: Brown
Eye Color: Brown
Nickname/Alias: Jimmie/Virginia Carpenter
Distinguishing Marks/Features: Long hair

Identifiers
Dentals: Not Available
Fingerprints: Not Available
DNA: Not Available

Clothing & Personal Items
Clothing: Striped chambray dress, White hat and Red platform shoes
Jewelry: Unknown
Additional Personal Items: A bag

Circumstances of Disappearance
Carpenter was last seen in Denton, Texas on June 1, 1948. She left her home in Texarkana, Texas and took a train to Denton. She got off the train in Denton and took a taxi to the campus of what is now Texas Woman's University. She stepped out of the cab in front of Brackenridge Hall at the Texas State College for Women a little after 21.00. She gave the cab driver the ticket for her trunk and a dollar to fetch it the next day from the train station. She walked over to talk to two young men she appeared to know. ``Well, hi. What are you doing here?'' she asked them. The cab driver then drove away.

The cab driver delivered Carpenter's trunk the next morning. It sat on the porch for days. In 1948, police questioned Miss Carpenter's boyfriend for 12 hours the first time around and interviewed him more than a dozen times after that. He also passed a polygraph test. Police searched the cab driver, looking for scratches or bruises. They grilled the cabby numerous times. He was 45, with little education and a reputation for physical abuse. According to reports in the Denton police files, the cabby was a ``bootlegger, part-time mechanic and automobile trader''.

In 1957, his wife, who was married to someone else by then, told Midland police she had lied when she said he was home that night by 22.00. Actually, according to the police files, she said he had come in at 02.00 or 03.00 a.m. the next morning. And each year on June 1, when the Denton Record-Chronicle rehashed the unsolved case, he traveled from Midland to Denton and bought a paper, his wife told the officers. He was never charged.

The year before her disappearance, five Texarkana teens were murdered by a person who has never been identified. The press dubbed him the ``Phantom Killer.'' Miss Carpenter and her family were friends with three of the five victims.

In May of 1998, police were given a tip by a man in his 70s who claimed to know who killed Ms. Carpenter and where she was buried. Police said the informant was close to some of the people who were allegedly involved in Ms. Carpenter’s disappearance. The sheriff said the two suspects in the murder are now dead.

Investigating Agency(s)
Agency Name: Denton County Sheriff's Office
Agency Contact Person: Captain Rick Clark
Agency Phone Number: 940-349-1600

Information Source(s)
Doe Network
Denton County Sheriff's Office
Laredo Morning Times
Denton Record-Chronicle - 8/3/97

Admin Notes
Added: 1/29/06; Last Updated: 7/8/2017
 
I can think of an additional reason to suspect Zachary:

- In addition to being a cab driver, wife beater and sexual assailant, Zachary was also a mechanic and an auto trader. Yet, he could only describe a claimed sighting of an unusual nice car in very general terms as a "cream colored convertible"- or was it yellow? He appears to have given to different color descriptions. This and his inability give the general make of the convertible does not seem very likely given his auto interests.

But, his ex wife's claims also seem strange:

- Zachary was described as being badly educated. He was probably functionally illiterate or perhaps even completely illiterate. Yet, his wife describes him knowing that the Denton paper carried articles about the case and then driving hours to buy a paper that he probably could not fully read. This is in contrast to most murderers of his education who follow the "out of sight, out of mind" philosophy regarding crime. No arrest and a move to Midland put Zachary way "out of sight".

Even considering that "un-educated" does not always mean "un-intelligent", especially in earlier generations, the Texas Ranger does not describe Zachary as being quick witted. Rather, he points out that he was uneducated. This could imply a fairly simple individual and not likely to read a lot of papers, nor be concerned about their contents.

Perhaps she was changing her story as way to incriminate her husband for the years of abuse?

You have a really valid point Cryptic. If he was a mechanic or an auto trader he would of imediately said oh yeah it was a canary yellow 46 Ford or a Cream Convertable 48 Chevy or a 47 GM..
Your absolutely right. I have dated mechanics and Car enthusiasts and have gone to car shows and racing events. With that in mind all the men talking about cars always mention Make and Year. Your right how could a mechanic and a auto trader be so vague with a description of a car?!
 
Hello, websleuths! Long time lurker, first time poster. I've always been fascinated by this case, and finally got to put my two cents in.
So I was looking up some new information or deatils on this case and stumbled across a website of Decatur Bowling Association. There I saw a photo of a lady whose name was Virginia Carpenter. This is her photo:
View attachment 103506

The website says that she started playing bowling in the middle 1950's, became a professional bowler and later became a coach.

I must say that I do see a resemblance between this lady and the missing Virginia Carpenter. The smile, the chin, the nose... Here is a combined picture of them:
View attachment 103507

And, of course, the name! But, in my opinion, if she had decided to run away deliberately and start a new life, then she would have changed her name. But, who knows. What do you guys think?

Here is the original link: The Decatur USBC - Decatur, Illinois

I do have to say this bowling Virgina has an uncanny resemblance to the missing Virginia. Does anyone know anything more? Has this woman ever been contacted.. it is kind of weird.
 
Mary Virginia Carpenter
  • mary_virginia_carpenter_1.jpg
  • mary_virginia_carpenter_2.jpg
Carpenter, circa 1948

  • Missing Since 06/01/1948
  • Missing From Denton, Texas
  • Classification Endangered Missing
  • Sex Female
  • Race White
  • Date of Birth 01/15/1927 (93)
  • Age 21 years old
  • Height and Weight 5'3, 120 pounds
  • Clothing/Jewelry Description A white chambray dress with brown, red and green stripes and silver buttons down the front, red leather high-heeled platform shoes, a small white straw hat with a flipped-up brim and a feather in the back, and a gold Wittnauer watch. Carrying a red purse.
  • Distinguishing Characteristics Caucasian female. Brown hair, brown eyes. Carpenter's nickname is Jimmie. Many agencies refer to her by her middle name, Virginia. She has an appendectomy scar on her abdomen and she limps due to a prior bone infection in her right hip. Carpenter was recovering from a severe case of sunburn at the time of her disappearance.
Details of Disappearance
Carpenter was last seen in Denton, Texas on June 1, 1948. She left her home in Texarkana, Texas and took a train to Denton, six hours away. She packed a brown steamer trunk, a matching makeup case and a black pasteboard hatbox. At the station she took a taxicab to Texas State College for Women (TSCW), now called Texas Women's University. She was planning to complete a summer term there.

Carpenter had previously attended the University of Arkansas and studied journalism, but transferred to the TSCW because she'd decided to enter into a career in the sciences instead; she aspired to a career as laboratory technician.

Carpenter first enrolled in the TSCW for the 1945-46 school year, then took a break from school to help her sick mother and save up money to pay for her education. She attended Texarkana Junior College for a time, then enrolled in the 1948 summer term at TSCW. She planned to begin training there as laboratory technician in the autumn, but disappeared just before the summer term began.

The cab driver, Edgar Ray "Jack" Zachary, later stated he stopped in front of Brackenridge Hall at 9:00 p.m. and Carpenter gave the driver a ticket for her trunk and paid him a dollar so he would fetch it for her from the train station the next day.

After getting out of the cab, Zachary said, Carpenter approached two young men standing near a yellow or cream-colored convertible car, possibly a Pontiac. One of the men was tall and the other is described as "chunky." Carpenter appeared to know them and began to speak to them, and Zachary drove away. She never checked into her dormitory, Brackenridge Hall, and has never been heard from again.

Some of Carpenter's former boyfriends stated she became infatuated easily and speculated she ran away with a lover, but her family did not believe she would have left without telling them. She had previously been engaged, but broke off the relationship just weeks prior to the wedding.

Carpenter's boyfriend passed a polygraph in connection with her disappearance, but authorities learned Zachary had a record for petty crimes and a reputation for being abusive. He was charged with attempted rape in 1957, but the charge was dropped after the victim asked authorities not to prosecute.

Zachary's wife stated he had been home with her from 10:00 p.m. onwards on June 1, but ten years after Carpenter's disappearance, his wife told police she had lied to them and her husband had not actually arrived home until 2:00 or 3:00 a.m. on June 2. Zachary died in 1984. He was never charged in connection with Carpenter's case, but he remains a suspect, although he passed two polygraphs in her case.

In the winter and spring of 1946, five young people were murdered in lovers' lanes in Carpenter's hometown of Texarkana. The crimes are believed to have all been committed by the same person. The murderer was never caught and became known as the Texarkana Phantom Killer.

Carpenter was actually acquainted with three of the killer's victims. Authorities investigated to see if there was a link between her disappearance and the Texarkana slayings, but they found no evidence to support this theory.

In 1998, authorities received a tip that two men had raped and killed Carpenter shortly after her disappearance and buried her body in a dam at a stock tank near the Texas Women's University campus. The suspects were both deceased by 1998 and were not publicly identified. Authorities searched the dam after receiving the information, but uncovered no evidence.

Numerous leads and possible sightings of Carpenter have surfaced throughout the decades since her disappearance, but no evidence has been uncovered and none of the accounts have been proven. Her father died prior to her disappearance and her mother died in 1980, and she has no siblings, but three of her cousins still hope to get answers in her case.

Carpenter was declared legally dead in 1955. Her disappearance remains unsolved.
Investigating Agency
  • Denton County Sheriff's Office 940-349-1600
Source Information
 
The Chilling Disappearance of Virginia Carpenter
220px-virginia_carpenter.jpg

Virginia Carpenter

On June 1, 1948, 21-year-old Virginia Carpenter arrived in Denton, Texas from Texarkana with the intention of taking a summer class at the Texas State College for Women (now TWU). However, before she could fulfill her aspirations of becoming a nurse or lab technician, she disappeared.

At approximately 3:00 pm on June 1, Virginia left Texarkana by the Texas Special #31, bound for Denton. On the train, Virginia met Marjorie Webster, a school teacher who, like Virginia, was heading to TSCW from Texarkana in order to enroll in a course. When they arrived about 6 hours later, they shared a cab to the dorms driven by Edgar Ray “Jack” Zachary....

... When they arrived at the dorm, Brackenridge Hall, Virginia realized that she forgot to check whether her trunk had arrived safely at the train station. Virginia asked Zachary if he would take her back to the station. Marjorie offered to accompany her but Virginia refused, saying “No. I’ll go alone. I’ll be alright.” Virginia drove back to the station and was told that her luggage would arrive later. Zachary offered to bring her luggage to her the next morning and Virginia agreed. Zachary drove Virginia back to her dorm and dropped her off at about 9:30 pm. Zachary claimed that when they arrived, there were two men waiting for them with a cream-colored car. Virginia asked: “What are you doing here?” Virginia told Zachary that she knew the men and said they would assist her with the luggage she had in the taxi.

Zachary reportedly left her with the young men and returned the following morning with the suitcase from the train station. Virginia’s suitcase would sit on the lawn of the dorm for two days, unclaimed. Virginia would never retrieve her suitcase, check into her dorm, or enroll in the course.

A few days later, worried that he hadn’t heard from her, Virginia’s boyfriend called her mother. Her mother called first the school and then friends and family to see if any of them had seen or heard from Virginia in the last few days. No one had. Her mother called the police to report her daughter missing and the Texarkana police reportedly told her to “just go to bed and we’ll get on the case in the morning.”

The search for Virginia Carpenter encompassed the entire state. Airplanes, boats, search dogs, and rescue parties scoured the landscape, looking for any sign of the missing girl. Photos of Virginia were sent out across the country in the hope that someone may have seen or heard something about her disappearance.

Zachary fully cooperated with the investigation and passed multiple polygraph tests. His wife told the police that he was home by 10:00 pm, substantiating his alibi. However, almost 10 years later Zachary was arrested for attempted rape but was released because the woman chose not to press charges. Not long after, his now ex-wife says that he convinced her to lie for him about the night of Virginia’s disappearance, saying he got home at 10 when he really got home around 2:00 or 3:00 am. However, without any hard evidence, Zachary was never prosecuted. He died in 1984.


There were many reported sightings of Virginia in the year following her disappearance. On June 11, 10 days after her disappearance, a ticket agent claimed to see Virginia at a train station in DeQueen, Arkansas. The ticket agent was able to pick out a photo of Virginia in a lineup but later doubted her identification. On June 12, a woman was seen riding with two men in Mena, Arkansas. A girl matching Virginia’s description was seen in Tuscon, Arizona on July 8. In January of the following year, a woman named Gladys Bass claimed to have met a woman who was hitchhiking who said that her name was Virginia. Gladys said the woman seemed well-educated and she said her name was Virginia. Virginia told Gladys that she had run away. None of the supposed sightings were ever substantiated, however.

There were a few human remains examined but none ever matched. In 1998, a man even reported that she was buried on the TWU campus but excavations only found a glove, a boot, and animal bone fragments. Theories surrounding her disappearance range from murder, to running away, to amnesia. While the case remains open, it has officially been declared cold and without any new evidence, it will most likely remain that way...

LINK:
The Chilling Disappearance of Virginia Carpenter
 
Does anyone know how to find the address of the taxi company Zachary worked for, or where their garage/maintenance facility was located? Just guessing, but, hypothetically, a location where a taxi driver would feel comfortable bringing the victim of a spontaneous abduction would be someplace he was very familiar with and where he would know if anyone else was going to be around. A pretext to keep her calm during the abduction would be for him to make up a story about the cab needing service then getting her away from public view. Seems the garage would be a good place to search.
 
I find this website and this disappearance in particular fascinating. Generally I'm under the impression the cab driver was involved, but I noticed something that has gone unmentioned in this thread. This is a quote from page one of this thread (#17) by Richard, all italics mine:

"And in 1957, his (meaning Zachary's) wife, who was married to someone else by then, told Midland police she had lied when she said he was home that night by 10. Actually, according to the police files, she said he had come in at 2 or 3 a.m. the next morning. And each year on June 1, when the Denton Record-Chronicle rehashed the unsolved case, he traveled from Midland to Denton and bought a paper, his wife told the officers. He became nervous, uneasy, and she believed he had something to do with the girl's disappearance. He was never charged."

And then add to that this quite interesting tidbit: the newspaper link posted by bbking on page two of this thread (#40) has this nugget: "Mrs. Smith (Virginia's mother, formally Mrs. Carpenter) has since remarried, and now lives in Midland, Tex.."

The first article above posted by Richard implies that Edgar Zachary and his now remarried wife both lived in Midland at the same time, and Zachary's ex-wife must have stayed in touch with him because she was aware of his travel habits and was talking to the police. And then, by sheer coincidence, Virginia's mother and her new husband are also living in Midland? Everyone involved in now living in Midland? This could very well be a rabbit hole, or red herring, but it is interesting.....
 
Didn't the watchman corroborate the taxi driver's story that Virginia got into a convertible with some guys? Assuming that it was Virginia that he saw, and the other witness who said he saw a girl matching her description with some guys in a convertible, I'm beginning to suspect the taxi driver was innocent.
 
I have the impression that this girl escaped with a boyfriend and that she had an altercation with him and finally ended up murdering her in those times it was easier to hide a body, it could also be some Jane Doe and since there were no DNA tests it is difficult to know now ..
rest in peace friend.
 
What was the Texarkana population back then? Could it have been small enough that ‘everybody knew everybody,’ which would make any connection with the ‘phantom killer’s’ victims irrelevant?

A possible point in the defense of the cab driver: in an era pre-Daylight Savings, 9 pm was quite dark. So, cream or yellow convertible? Couldn’t we say that stating a definite color in the pitch dark would be more suspicious? Indicative of an invented story? And is the description of the two men centered around their silhouettes? Height and build—which you could pick out in almost-dark.

all MOO
 
A photo of the taxi driver and an account of the kidnapping, physical assault and attempted rape incident in which Zachary struck her on the head with his .38 pistol, bound her with strips of cloth and forced her to lie on the back floor of her car on the way back to his car.
 

Attachments

  • virginiacarpenter.jpg
    virginiacarpenter.jpg
    126.4 KB · Views: 99
  • virginia2ndincident.jpg
    virginia2ndincident.jpg
    136.3 KB · Views: 14

Denton is the town where Brad Majors, Janet Weiss, Dr. Everett Von Scott, Ralph Hapschatt, and Betty Munroe live. Known as "The Home Of Happiness", it is also the location of the Denton Episcopal Church and Denton High School, all fiction characters and places in the movie: Rock Horror Picture Show.

LINK:
Denton - RockyWiki
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
56
Guests online
3,546
Total visitors
3,602

Forum statistics

Threads
592,491
Messages
17,969,812
Members
228,789
Latest member
Soccergirl500
Back
Top