Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
does anyone know if this Doe was ever entered into NAMUS and what the case number is? I was just searching and couldn't find her there.
I would be curious to know where the rat poisioning and the toy soldier were found in relation to the body. I would also be curious about what your thoughts are about the watch. I think someone mentioned it was from 1966, is that correct?
The reason I mention this is that I found a missing person that I believe is a good match for this Jane Doe but the problem is that she disappeared in 1970.
Denise Sheehy is a possible match in the following ways:
Her surname is probably the most intriguing in possibilities that this could be her in that it is Irish. Just as the police predicted the UID to be.
Her height estimate matches Midtown Jane Does at 5'2"
Her age when she went missing was 16
She is a good proximity match: She dissapeared from Queens County, New York
She was supposedly wearing a Gold ring with the initials DS, and Gold boys school ring
Regarding the watch near the UID, how likely would it be in your opinion that she would be wearing a 22 year old watch vs. wearing a 4 year old watch? It's possible of course, but in all likelihood, I would make the assumption in the favor that the watch the UID was wearing was not nearly that old when she was wearing it. This is in favor of the fact that I believe Denise Sheehy should at least be looked at.
What do you think???
Denise's page:
https://www.findthemissing.org/en/cases/5533/89
Carl, regarding the Judith O'Donnell match, the height is definitely a huge discrepancy, but according the website linked previously (and linked below), the clothing tag was actually misidentified. According to the link, the real company that manufactured her clothing dissolved in 1973, which could push her time of death back tremendously. Check it out and see what you think:
http://missing-and-unidentified.org/midtown_jane_doe/study.html
I have been following Cathy Moulton's case and I think you can rule her out as a possible. Of course I can't be sure but I honestly believe the lead on her page about her possibly being found in the woods is a pretty sensible one. I also agree on the on the stats for Denise Sheehy. This case is just so hard to date the UID.