Hgbchick, the one thing that tells me something was fishy was, well it's three things actually, all dealing with the Rs behavior on the first morning. On that morning, waiting for the kidnapper to call, the time came and went and neither John nor Patsy said anything about it, no "Why don't they call?" or anything like that, and then when Det. Arndt asked John to search the house (which she shouldn't have done but that's another story) he headed right straight for the basement room where JB's body lay. Do you not think that's kind of strange? And then John planning to fly to Atlanta 45 minutes later. My child has never been kidnapped but I think I have a pretty good idea what I would and would not do, and flying off to Atlanta would be on the not do list. I'm not saying PDI, but I think she knew who did it.