Phillip Walker had no way to properly evaluate the situation to determine if MB was a threat to the officer, so if I heard that as a jury member, I would have to discard pretty much all of his testimony. Phillip Walker had no way to know if MB or DJ was armed, or not. It's clear to me Phillip Walker made up his mind about the situation once he "heard" that MB was unarmed, after the fact. IMO. I can believe Phillip Walker was confused, though. That would have been a confusing, frightening situation to come upon. There's a lot of "heresay" and opinion in that quote from PW, IMO, that he would not be permitted to testify to in court, if he were called as a witness. IMO. And I think deposition and cross examination of PW from 2 competent attorneys would be a very difficult situation for PW's words to hold up to what he has claimed in his opinions above. IMO.