Okay so in the audio Judy Cole says she sent that first picture to the paper along with her current photo. So that explains why we never saw that one, it's not from Alcala, has nothing to do with it. She also says she "thinks" she is in NYP #166, and the NYDailynews #196, with a caption of 169.
She goes on to say she "cannot say positively that it was him". She also goes on to say that they were in an apartment, which she felt was not his apartment, and she thinks there was someone else there, but things went sour when they (the two of them) went up to the roof when he got out his camera equipment. (That leads me to believe no pictures were taken inside the apartment.) She also says he unbuttoned her blouse and it "progressed to the point where I was semi-topless". Not quite sure what that means, but there are no bra straps showing in this picture, so unless this girl is wearing a tube top (which has no buttons), I'd say she looks pretty topless to me. I guess she could have been wearing a strapless bra maybe. She also says she was 19 or 20. She further states that she doesn't know if it was her in the picture, but her mother and her friend think it is. And then she says something off the wall talking about her writing "I am a very good writer." WTH? Weird.
Anyway, if this woman is that unsure: she can't be sure it's even her and she can't be sure it was even Alcala, then whichever picture it turns out to be, I think we should leave this thread open. At least for now anyway.