<"I don't know why he decided to leave," Samuel Gagnon told the newspaper. "Everyone's in shock. We're supposed to be celebrating the New Year, but now I got to look forward to my brother in jail the rest of his life."
Does anyone else find this qoute from the drunken idiot's brother kind of ..i can't even think of the word i'm looking for.
Samuel, the brother, is all concerned that his brother is going to jail the rest of his life, nevermind that his brother is a stupid that just killed 5 people???>
Well this is what happens when a lifetime of excessive drinking and partying destroys most of your brain cells. then again, these 2 may not have had much to begin with.
Here's who's at fault here:
#1- the himself
#2- his 's brother and alcoholic friends who KNEW he was wasted and... WHY WERE HIS KEYS NOT TAKEN AWAY AT SOME POINT?? You KNOW your friend is so drunk he can hardly stand,, and all these people have HOW MANY HOURS to get his keys away from him? And, they say there was a designated driver- if you are planning on getting blotto, you're supposed to give up your OWN keys at the beginning of the night. So if he didn't, his friends had a responsibility at some point to get them from him (which admittedly, can be difficult if someone is being belligerent and stubborn). There is nothing wrong and everything right with physically wrestling and restraining a person to get their keys, if they won't give them up. I have seen it done and done it to people myself. they can have their keys back when they get home- and hopefully there is someone there to babysit them til they pass out.
#3- thirdly-- the fault lies with the establishment who served them all that alcohol. Years ago, I had mixed feelings about this, and it brings up all kinds of 'personal responsibility' debates.... but after years of working in bars/restaurants, i now feel strongly about it. Here in Texas we have the TABC (TX alcoholic beverage commission) which made it LAW that you must take a short course to have a permit in order to serve alcohol. And you have to renew it every year. ALL servers are shown videos, and hear testimonies of people whose lives have been affected by drunk drivers... and at the time it seems like a pain and the videos are hard to watch, but it is a good reminder that you are involved in serious business. You also are trained in how to spot drunken behavior, and how to 'pace' people.. and they teach how much a person of a certain size can handle. And you have to take a test. At the time I was a bit miffed that we were held responsible for idiots that couldn't be responsible themselves..... but now I understand, they were right. If an establishment is so dependent on having to serve as much booze as humanly possible in order to do well,, then is that really the type of place you want to work in, or go to? Plus, NO bar/restaurant wants to be known as 'the place where a guy got so wasted that he drove off and killed all those people'. We are also taught to say 'how are you getting home? let me call you a cab, they'll be here in a few minutes'. (also our town has a FREE courtesy cab service around the holidays.) And TABC officers make regular rounds in businesses to keep an eye on them. If it seems a bit excessive or people start thinking they are nazis, just think about what can happen if there were no TABC.
Notice how all these other people tried to stop this idiot from being on the road.. but did 911 get ONE SINGLE CALL from his group of drunk moron friends? OR the bar? the doorguys? ...anyone??? ...saying "hey our friend just left in his car... he needs to be stopped"... They probably thought it was funny that he left.
So yes I think this bar is 100% responsible (assuming they saw his condition and kept serving him anyway) for ALLOWING this assh*le to get crap-faced drunk at their place... and yes I also think they are criminally negligent.
The point is... it is NOT a perfect situation with a perfect solution, the law realizes that bartenders are not magicians, mind-readers or gatekeepers. But they just want them to make a serious EFFORT to help keep drunks off the road. And NOT doing so, for the sake of more profits, more tips, laziness or just not caring, is obviously putting innocent people at risk. And the police can't do everything or be everywhere at once. It would be ideal if we could make people be more responsible and NOT want to get insanely drunk. But they do, IF WE LET THEM. So it's up to the servers to help stop them from doing so... or at least stop them from leaving and driving.