CA - 13 victims, ages 2 to 29, shackled in home by parents, Perris, 15 Jan 2018 #5

Status
Not open for further replies.
I also do not think DT is or will turn out to be the "wimpy" "weak" "follower" some are assuming. He was aggressive enough to engage in alleged sexual predation on his 14 year old daughter.

I do not believe one iota that he was just some docile, weak-minded, follower that deferred to LT.

Not by a longshot.

Neither do I,

I believe that DT manipulated LT into his ways of control thinking and manipulation. DT could have threatened her if he didn't comply. LT was brainwashed and worn down by DT's demands. Over the years, LT began to identify with this as normal behavior, and so did most of the children. The reasoning is because they were never exposed to a normal life, except under very rare and still controlling circumstances. The Mother out with the one of the kids at a time. One of the kids allowed to attend Community College while LT waited in the hallway. (Was this the oldest son?) I wonder what the class was about that he took? At what college?

Satch
 
maybe[/I] they're dance shoes. I had very similar shoes as a little girl in the 70's, but no way could I find any shoe that style to fit my adult-sized clodhoppers now. Unless there's a source for girl's shoes in adult sizes that I am not aware of, those poor young women were quite stunted. :(

.

Children's shoes,especially shoes like that, usually come in sizes up to a child's size 6. A child's 6 is an adult 8. I am not very big but I'm within the normal range for adult women and I wear a children's size 4. They are children's shoes but they probably come in sizes that fit many adults.
 
I've been thinking about the vow renewals, and have come up with a semi-plausible explanation for why they had them. I've been wondering f they were using them as a way to show themselves (and each other?) that they're beginning a new life of sorts.

In 2011, the renewal took place after their bankruptcy. It was also shortly after the abuse has been said to have started, the new home (?), and I believe a new job. I could be off on when some of these things happened, but I believe they were within a year or so of the first renewal of the vows that we've heard about.

In 2013, the renewal appears to have taken place somewhere around the time that the "alleged" molestation ended. It may hve been his way of showing that he was going to be faithful to her again (whether he was or not remains to be seen.)

in 2015, the renewal appears to have happened within a few months of the birth of a child they may have been trying to have for years. Whether there were miscarriages between them, or just a long gap, the age difference means they were without a "baby" for a long time (for them).

It all could just be a coincidence, but I thought it was interesting. MOO


Just a quick note to add... The one part of the picture of them with the blue shirts that I really like was the fact that the little one was holding her arms out just like the rest. Well, that and the fact that they actually had a chance for a little bit of fresh air and sunshine that day.
 
I just can’t see her investing that kind of time and energy into something for the children.
Wasn't really for the children though was it, I hear you but I think she was more about preparing everything for the photo op, making sure everything looked right.
 
I don;t know either. I hope we will get to find out. I have three borderlines in my life (MIL, aunt by marriage and long time friend from childhood) and have come across about three more in my practice. Only one was into cutting that I am aware of. Three made suicide attempts or seriously threatened.

Not surprising (the attempted suicides and cutting) and I am sorry.

All have zero damn memory of the things they have done or things that occurred in the past. They completely remember them the wrong way.

This is SO true. And the nature of the absolute Mind**** that ensues on a constant basis.

Only a couple have been sexually promiscuous as most are supposed to be.

Meh...maybe to avoid abandonment in Borderline, but classically more of a mania symptom. People can have both Bipolar Disorder and Borderline Personality disorder, in fact, clinically they mimic each other upon first assessment and a differential dx needs to be made. MOO.


I think while some of that is common, none of it has to be there for the person to be diagnosed. For me, the constants are intense fear of abandonment that results, inexplicably, in crazy behaviors that ensure they will be abandoned - rages, pulling the person in and then shutting them out, intensive boundary crossing (like the allegation that LT picked the locks and watched her sister come out of the shower, if that allegation is to be believed) but extreme distress or rage if anyone ever tries to pry into their business, and then it's the idealization which swings to hatred.

Absolutely SPOT ON.

Only thing here is that I must have missed that and only understood the showering episodes to be DT not LT and DT. Correct me if I am wrong.

I could see some of that applying to LT. She idealizes her husband. Let's see if she turns on him.

This would be important to know, I agree, we just don't know enough yet here. To me they seem to be in absolute narcissistic "love" and bizarre adoration for each other, but that could be just for the cameras (Vegas), a facade, like everything else they ever showed the public. The power dynamics in their relationship are paramount to understand and I don't think we do yet. Her being raised Evangelical, and him, Pentecostal, makes me lean toward a patriarchal narrative in their marriage. But that is pure informed (lol) speculation.

She seems to maybe idealize her babies but then hates them as they age?

Agreed! Are they dolls? When they grow up does she become disinterested in dressing them up and playing with them? When they talk back or push back do they shake up her regressed narrative? She appears stuck in childhood as well. Trauma? Trauma and a high functioning Intellectual Disability? It does appear that childhood and fantasy (Disney etc) are a very fixed theme with her, at least for 29 years. Does anything that shakes her out of that fantasy incite rage in her? I don't know. But its a good analytical question

I don't see evidence of intellectual disability in her actions or facial expressions in the videos, narratives about her, etc. In fact, she seems pretty sharp. "No, we don;t call him James. WE call him Jonathan!" Her ability to keep things hidden. Her close control of her son when he went to college. her stated desire for a reality show. her communications on FB, like to the fertility nurse? etc.

My speculation about an ID in the high range are based on limited information such as her regressed state, her inappropriate affect in videos both in court and in Vegas, her obsession with Disney and her apparent disinterest in her children other than her baby. It is really just a feeling at this point, as in I wouldn't be shocked if we learned that, but if not, I wouldn't be shocked either.


A huge cause of it is actually abandonment by a caretaker. From what I've read and witnessed, the primary caretaker not allowing for proper separation-individuation early in life and then in adolescence is not a cause as much as abandonment is (either physical or more often, emotional). And of course straight up abuse, physical and especially emotional.

Yes, absolutely abandonment or, more importantly perceived abandonment during the separation individuation process as a toddler and then again as an adolescent. When a child/toddler is given the message that the mother is upset with the separation individuation (Crawling to explore your world and then later pushing boundaries as teen) and love is withheld or taken away, the child learns that their separation individuation means abandonment and the attachment gets all distorted. This causes the Borderline adult to have poor boundaries (get to close to fast, ALL IN unrealistically ) and then to see abandonment everywhere and then to idealize, rage and split. Lather rinse repeat. Separation individuation happens twice during our development. And LT was effectively abandoned by her father when he found out about her relationship with DT. LT effectively replaced her father figure for sure. She was a child, 16 years old.

Calling out "No, Jonathan! " in response to the Elvis Impersonator regarding J's name would not be out of the realm of high functioning ID. I also am not sure if DT or LT made those comments on FB to the OBGYN. Either way they were very strange and inappropriate whether he made them or she did. Her close control of her son while in classes says more about his fear than her not having a high functioning ID in my opinion. And again, it's just a vibe I get, not something I am absolutely asserting. As far as her actions to keep things hidden...OH YEAH, I believe she knew right from wrong and that she had to hide it. But an intellectual disability in the high range would not thwart you from knowing right from wrong.


I don't know about bi-polar for her. I don't know enough. Don't they tend to have issues with substance or alcohol abuse a lot? Anxiety and depression?



Bipolar disorder and substance abuse are found together in extremely high numbers. Also Bipolar Disorder and Borderline often present similarly and can take clinicians time to differentiate. And to make it all easier , you can be DX'd with both Bipolar and Borderline. So Yes. YES. AND YES. Bipolar Disorder is an actual form of depression. (Unipolar Depression and Bipolar Depression. And Borderline Personality Disorder presents with a ton of anxiety. So many Diagnosis can exist within one person.

The latter sure fits with hoarding.

Hoarding almost always has roots in trauma and is a form of anxiety

I hope we will be able to find something out. I doubt it though. Usually that stuff is sealed.

I hope so too. And It's always a pleasure posting with you and learning from you Gitana. All the way back from the days of Caylee Anthony.

BBM
 
I think it *is* that sibling. The lewd act is charged to have happened a few years ago, making her under 14 at the time. And if she is the one who escaped, it would make sens that she reported this thing that others may not be ready to talk about yet if they were subjected to same.
There were a few kids under 14, though. It could be any of those.

Sent from my SM-G955U using Tapatalk
 
I think the ugly hand made dresses and white tights and shoes are all part of her deluded Disney dream. It's quite and old fashioned style all together like something out of bedjnibs and broomsticks or something like that. Alas that mattered really was what she looked like, she's the only person that really matters.

I wonder if all the children were initially loved, fed and looked after while they were babies and toddlers, it's only as they grow and start to grow up that they're not as appealing and become a nuisance that just need to be tolerated. Having babies every year or so, and then when perhaps unable to get pregnant has the constant wedding renewals, all to keep her feeling youthful.
 

She seems too selfish to sew for her children. I make quilts and have recently started sewing for my little girl. She loves the stuff I make, as imperfect as it is (which is very imperfect!), and her happiness makes me want to make her more things. It’s time consuming and I wouldn’t do it if she didn’t love it. LT doesn’t seem like she liked her kids or cared about what they liked. I assume she bought the dresses off Etsy or something.

How sad that the same dresses fit the girls two years later. They didn’t grow. :(
 
I agree, he definitely provided more details than I thought he would. I just wonder when they will release more info. Maybe when the victims are ready to leave the hospital?

I don;t think they will release much more info voluntarily. But more will come out at the pretrial. Judge would likely put a gag order.
 
BBM LE stated they want to bring in cadaver dogs. It's possible the daughters have been pregnant many times with few or no surviving offspring.

This case is so disturbing. I’d love to think a dad wouldn’t ever do that but just a few years ago was the case about Josef Fritzl, who kept his daughter in his cellar for years as his sex slave and had a bunch of kids with her. I sincerely hope that this isn’t the case in this family’s situation.
 
We homeschool and have for years. I am also a former teacher. We are part of a very large homeschool community (not religiously affiliated). The ‘specialists’ aren’t being accurate. What they described is not true of 99% of the families I know that homeschool. Most homeschool so that the children aren’t in a ridged/controlled environment. I am not sure where they found those ‘specialists’ but I have never heard of them and we are very involved in curriculum conventions and our state organization. That may be their opinion but it isn’t a true depiction of the majority of homeschool families that I have met in the past decade.

I'm with you. Most homeschoolers are doing it for the right reasons and want to ensure the best outcomes for their kids. I don't think there is a need for stringent oversight, and I don't appreciate the media's negative spin and perseverance on the fact that these kids were homeschooled. Homeschooling was not the problem here. Even the most strictly religious homeschooled kids I've met are well cared for. I homeschool for the freedom to teach my kids in a
Way thatvworks for them and allows them time to follow and act on their passions. This is a .1% if that kind of case. Just wish the media would get off it.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
I don't believe that cadaver dog story. It sounds fishy to me.

I know that fact was attributed to Chris Hansen, but I could see that conversation going as follows:

Hansen: "What steps are you taking to investigate the abuse?

LEO: "We are doing whatever it takes to see that justice is done."

Hansen: "Are you looking into whether any children may have died between the 12yo and the 10yo?"

LEO: "We are looking at everything.

Hansen: "Would you bring in cadaver dogs to inspect the Turpin property?"

LEO: "We will use whatever tools are necessary."

Hansen reports: "I have it on good authority that law enforcement is considering bringing in cadaver dogs to inspect the property."

IMO cadaver dogs everywhere they have lived should have been the first thing they did beyond getting the kids in hospitals and the parents in jail. I can’t imagine why they wouldn’t take that step.

DNA and genetic tests would have been very high on my to do list if I was an investigator involved with this, simply based on the fact that many of the kids have very interesting facial features. They don’t look quite right, more than just extremely thin, so if I was a doctor I would want to know what kinds of things may be undiagnosed given their complete lack of medical care.
 
I wonder if we're over-thinking it. Maybe someone asked the siblings (or a representative for the siblings), "What kind do you want, crew-neck or v-neck?" and the answer was "Umm..crew neck is fine." So crew neck went on the list.

jmo

I've wondered about this since it was first listed. I wonder if V-Necks were, for the most part, their daily attire while in seclusion? Just a thought.
 
The middle boy breaks my heart the most of all. I don't know why.

OT: I went to public school with a girl who became a good friend who had 11 sisters and 2 brothers. I loved hanging out at their house. They were so... different and amazing. They all had names like faith hope charity patience etc and wore clothes from a bygone era. Their brothers were very special to all those sisters.

The middle Turpin brother looks so forlorn. I hope he gets good vision care from here on out. Being able to see well is very important to... connecting with the world around you.
The middle boy breaks my heart most too, I'm not sure why, just something about him

Sent from my SM-G955U using Tapatalk
 
I think it's safe to say the investigators are hard at work, sharing very broad and general information with the media until they have a more comprehensive statement to make. It's only been a week. Feels to us like it's taking forever - I bet the survivors also feel like that hell was a whole nother life ago now.
 
She seems too selfish to sew for her children. I make quilts and have recently started sewing for my little girl. She loves the stuff I make, as imperfect as it is (which is very imperfect!), and her happiness makes me want to make her more things. It’s time consuming and I wouldn’t do it if she didn’t love it. LT doesn’t seem like she liked her kids or cared about what they liked. I assume she bought the dresses off Etsy or something.

How sad that the same dresses fit the girls two years later. They didn’t grow. :(

I agree with the selfishness. She/They shopped a lot and hoarded from what we have seen. There are also websites that are commonly known in religious circles, all different religions, where you can purchase "modest" clothing for children and adults online.

I see her purchasing on a site like that rather than taking the time to "lovingly" sew 13 different outfits.

No way.
She was all about spending, shopping, and instant gratification. She lived in squalor and appears way to impulsive to take to the time or have the patience to actually sew for the children she hated and abused.
 
There were a few kids under 14, though. It could be any of those.

Sent from my SM-G955U using Tapatalk

The child’s initials or the first few letters of her first name and last initial are listed next to the charge.
 
I think the ugly hand made dresses and white tights and shoes are all part of her deluded Disney dream. It's quite and old fashioned style all together like something out of bedjnibs and broomsticks or something like that. Alas that mattered really was what she looked like, she's the only person that really matters.

I wonder if all the children were initially loved, fed and looked after while they were babies and toddlers, it's only as they grow and start to grow up that they're not as appealing and become a nuisance that just need to be tolerated. Having babies every year or so, and then when perhaps unable to get pregnant has the constant wedding renewals, all to keep her feeling youthful.

I wondered the same thing about if the kids were ever initially loved and cared for. My theory is that as each kid got old enough to understand what was happening to the siblings, they had to then be forced into submission and stripped of their dignity so that they couldn’t or wouldn’t tell anyone. I’m sure this sweet little baby was going to be chained to a bed in the next few years. I’m so grateful that her sister rescued her from the same fate.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
181
Guests online
1,709
Total visitors
1,890

Forum statistics

Threads
594,830
Messages
18,013,445
Members
229,523
Latest member
Hardsaf
Back
Top