On John Lourdan's Brainscratch on Lucas today he said something to the extent that he was surprised how much of a pass JH was getting on websleuths.He needs to read this thread today.He is a big fan of this site.
It seems to go back and forth depending on the thread. Sometimes there is a little more sympathy for him and other times less.
Personally, I can be empathetic and not give a pass. Probably my experience as a foster parent. Current foster child for example. I definitely feel for the parents who have been through hell in their lives, been addicted to drugs since they were in foster care themselves, have lost many children who I believe they do love in their own ways. But I absolutely believe they are incapable of parenting and that to give them a chance without them having a couple years of working on their issues successfully as well as actually working the service plan would be a huge risk. This child (or the next, and there is always a next for them) can’t be made to wait those years to see if they can become safe and healthy. It is terribly sad for the parents. But the child comes first.
This is where I am with JH also. He is not safe or healthy at this point. And it would take too long for him to prove himself to become so. MH and if there is a new baby (EG didn’t look pregnant to me when she was released) are so young and vulnerable. JH didn’t protect Lucas so there is no reason to believe him capable of protecting MH. Also, he was likely involved in the abuse (there is NO way his version of what happened to EG’s son would have resulted in bruises). I absolutely believe that he didn’t like the abuse and never dreamed it could escalate to a fatality. And I feel for him that he lost Lucas, a pain he will live with forever more. But though I feel for him, the decisions he made, his possible reasoning, and the nightmare of living with this, I cannot give him a pass. LUCAS was the one who needed the pass.
When in doubt, the rights of the child should supersede the rights of the parents. After 20some years involved in the system, I know that isn’t how it works; but I maintain that it *should* be about the best interests of the child.
Anyway, if you read through the threads, there seems to be a healthy mix of beliefs and feelings towards JH. If you don’t like what is said one day, wait a day or two. It’s kinda like the weather in Texas around here