Ok, so I'm really thinking outside of the box here so please bear with me for a bit and I'm happy for everyone to poke holes in my latest theory. :blushing:
Below are a couple of screen grabs of the Angler's Tavern. (Source:
Google Maps). The first image shows the tavern and the carpark to the right. There looks to be a grassy walking track between the carpark and the river. Would that lead back to Karen's house at Avondale Heights? I'm sorry but I don't know the area, I'm a Sydney girl.
The second image is a satellite view of the tavern, again showing the carpark and what I assume to be a walking track. The most recent police search was in this vicinity and down to the bridge, which is out of shot and below where the tavern is pictured.
As I put forward up thread, perhaps Karen walked to the tavern for a prearranged meeting or simply to rest and collect her thoughts for a while. She met with foul play at the tavern, either by getting into the car of the person she had planned to meet, thinking that they were going to drive her home. The second scenario is that on her way home on foot via the walking track she was grabbed by someone in the carpark and bundled into their car. Third scenario, Karen phoned BR asking him to pick her up from the tavern and it all went south from there.
Yes, I know it's almost a foregone conclusion that BR is responsible for Karen's disappearance and supposed murder and that may well be the case. But I keep thinking back to Jill Meagher. Everyone was pointing the finger at poor Tom Meagher, her beautiful husband. I knew immediately that he wasn't guilty. There was also talk of her male friend offering to share a taxi with Jill. There wasn't as much public interest placed on him, yet he was the last one (at that stage) to see her alive. By all accounts and purposes the public had deemed that Tom Meagher had murdered his wife. Shocking stuff!!
Anyway feel free to poke holes in this, my latest theory.