It appears most of the relevant information comes from the two Nancy Grace podcast episodes and the Gray Hughs YouTube video:
“Bio mom says the sighting is NOT confirmed to be Karlie and she doesn't think it was Karlie. Neighbor in a hot tub saw a teen walking with a piece of paper in her hand. Step mom said it was Karlie's counseling paper? But bio mom pointed out that there was no school on Sat so that doesn't make sense.“
CA - CA - Karlie Lain Gusé, 16, Mono County, 13 Oct 2018
“If we can discuss what Lindsay Fairley divulged on the Nancy Grace podcast... can we talk about the piece of paper the hot tub neighbor saw a young woman carrying?
Melissa’s explanation to Lindsay was that Karlie was in a counseling group at school and Karlie was adamant to have that paper back. Had Melissa taken it away from her? What was on the paper? I’m wildly speculating that it had contact information for the counselor who ran the group and maybe Karlie wanted it so she could get in touch with a counselor.
I also suspect Karlie didn’t have her phone because it was taken away from her as punishment.* For my teen, it’s the only thing she cares about, so we have taken her phone away for the evening on a few occasions. If she wasn’t able to use her phone, she may have left with the paper so she could call her counselor?”
CA - CA - Karlie Lain Gusé, 16, Mono County, 13 Oct 2018
“Bio Mom states that KG was suspended from school for a month because of cannabis use, and was attending counseling on school property during suspension. (Mom was interviewed by Gray Hughes 10/25/18).”
CA - CA - Karlie Lain Gusé, 16, Mono County, 13 Oct 2018
You can listen to the NG podcasts here:
Where is Karlie Gusé ? Desperate search for young girl intensifies as mystery surrounds how, why she disappeared
Link to the @grayhuze YouTube video:
I just finished watching ALL the videos. Wow my theories have changed. I definitely think that polygraphs would be beneficial and should be done ASAP. There are so many inconsistencies even with where she was the night before and what time SM found her missing.
What is the final timeline?
SM found her missing and went for a drive to look for her or SM found her missing and woke up dad then went searching?