Putnam County Common Pleas Judge Randall Basinger sentenced Fay to life in prison with the possibility of parole after 60 years for the deaths of Blaine, 14, and Blake Romes, 17.
Judge Basinger told Fay that he was a ruthless murderer, and his actions of putting a gun to the two teenagers, hiding their bodies, and then lying to police was chilling, and appeared to be remorseless.
The calculated and cold-blooded violence in this case is nearly incomprehensible. Your actions of May 9 are, simply put, premeditated murders of two sleeping, teenage victims. You committed a series of planned and ruthless acts, he said before imposing the sentence. The facts in this case clearly establish you present extreme danger to others and are not fit to live free in society in the foreseeable future.